Picard Confronts Beverly on Jameson's Medically Impossible Recovery
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Picard draws Beverly into a private conversation, confronting the unsettling reality of Admiral Jameson's miraculous recovery despite the incurable nature of Iverson's Disease.
Beverly asserts the incurability of Iverson's Disease and the absence of any new therapies, emphasizing Jameson's impossible recovery and highlighting the mystery that grips the crew.
Picard presses for an explanation, his skepticism mounting as Beverly confirms the severity and longstanding confinement of Jameson's disease, underscoring the extraordinary nature of his recovery.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Concerned and increasingly unsettled by the contradiction between observed facts and medical knowledge, resolved to uncover the truth behind Jameson's condition.
Captain Picard leads Beverly Crusher into the private confines of the Captain's Ready Room, firmly questioning her about the medically impossible recovery of Admiral Jameson. He listens intently to Beverly's grave assessment and decisively commands a thorough investigation, embodying his role as a vigilant and strategic leader.
- • Ascertain the medical truth behind Admiral Jameson's recovery.
- • Initiate an investigation to verify or uncover hidden factors influencing Jameson's health.
- • There is more to Jameson's recovery than meets the eye.
- • Starfleet protocol and mission success depend on accurate medical information.
Disturbed by the medical anomaly and concerned for the truth, yet maintaining composure and medical integrity.
Dr. Beverly Crusher responds with solemnity and professional candor, confirming the incurability and lack of remission for Iverson's Disease. She conveys her medical skepticism with a disturbed, earnest tone, emphasizing the gravity of the situation and the implausibility of the admiral's physical condition.
- • Provide an accurate medical assessment to Captain Picard.
- • Support the initiation of an investigation to uncover the truth behind Jameson's condition.
- • Iverson's Disease has no known cure or remission.
- • Deception or unknown factors may be at play regarding Jameson's health.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Admiral Jameson's Physical Support Chair is referenced by Dr. Crusher as a symbol of his prior four-year immobility due to Iverson's Disease, underscoring the medical improbability of his recent ability to walk. Though the chair is not physically present in the scene, its mention anchors the conversation in the reality of Jameson's previous physical frailty.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The Captain's Ready Room serves as the confidential and solemn setting for this critical confrontation between Picard and Beverly. Its privacy allows for candid discussion of sensitive medical and command concerns, heightening the gravity of their exchange and symbolizing the weight of leadership decisions unfolding behind closed doors.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"Crusher's confirmation of medical mystery escalates Picard's resolve to investigate Jameson's condition thoroughly, raising stakes of the unfolding mission."
"Picard's consultation with Beverly and subsequent insight into Jameson's aggressive and impatient attitude illustrates Jameson's psychological shift due to rejuvenation."
"Picard's consultation with Beverly and subsequent insight into Jameson's aggressive and impatient attitude illustrates Jameson's psychological shift due to rejuvenation."
Key Dialogue
"PICARD: The admiral displayed a remarkable improvement out there, wouldn't you say?"
"BEVERLY: Captain, no one recovers from Iverson's Disease. There is no known cure, and there are no cases where it has gone into remission. I haven't heard of any new therapy that would have results like this."
"PICARD: Then how do you account for it?"
"BEVERLY: I can't. All I can tell you is that the admiral has been confined to the support chair for four years by the effects of Iverson's. By all the medical facts we know, he should never have walked again."
"PICARD: I'd like you to look into it, Doctor. Thoroughly."
"BEVERLY: Yes, sir."