Fabula
S2E20 · The Fall's Gonna Kill You

Josh Confronted by DOJ's Tobacco Fraud Funding Crisis

Emerging from a tense meeting with Leo, Josh meets the impassioned Assistant AG Martin Connelly, who reveals the Justice Department's crippling cash shortage in its monumental fraud lawsuit against Big Tobacco. Connelly defends their righteous battle—outspent 10-to-1—against corporate deception, his fervor underscoring themes of fraud paralleling the White House's MS cover-up. Stunned, Josh absorbs the plea, promises to consult Leo, and stares lingeringly post-departure, signaling strategic ripples amid the administration's mounting paranoia.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Josh finally meets with Connelly, who reveals the Justice Department's financial crisis in fighting Big Tobacco.

professionalism to frustration ["Josh's office"]

Connelly passionately defends the DOJ's efforts against tobacco companies, revealing the staggering financial imbalance in their legal war.

frustration to righteous anger

Josh absorbs Connelly's revelation about tobacco companies' fraud, his lingering gaze signaling deeper implications for the administration's own concealment crisis.

concern to dawning realization

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6

Carrying forward momentum from high-stakes meeting

Exits Leo's office into hallway alongside Josh, pauses as door closes behind them, then splits off purposefully while Josh diverts to intercept Connelly in the lobby.

Goals in this moment
  • Transition efficiently from Leo's strategy session
  • Maintain operational rhythm amid converging crises
Active beliefs
  • Coordinated exits preserve secrecy and pace
  • External interruptions test internal resolve
Character traits
focused methodical tense
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey
Ed
primary

amused

Approaches Donna laughing with Larry, reveals fax about Chinese satellite from Byron Talmadge.

Goals in this moment
  • Share funny fax with Donna
Follow Ed's journey

Impassioned urgency veiling defensive frustration

Stands promptly in lobby at Josh's approach, follows to office, sits clutching briefcase, delivers fervent monologue on lawsuit costs, transfers blocked by House HR-260, and tobacco fraud—departs gratefully after Josh pledges Leo consultation.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure White House intervention for DOJ funding
  • Convince Josh of tobacco case's moral and strategic imperative
Active beliefs
  • Corporate tobacco fraud demands unrelenting pursuit
  • Financial odds cannot justify abandoning justice
Character traits
passionate desperate righteous articulate
Follow Martin Connelly's journey
Donna Moss
primary

Composed professionalism post-relief from prank distraction

Coordinates briefly during transition, informing Josh that deputies are at breakfast and C.J. is unavailable, as he quietly notes her Babish meeting while ushering Connelly inside—efficient anchor amid earlier hosting duties.

Goals in this moment
  • Smooth Josh's engagement with Connelly
  • Provide real-time staff location updates
Active beliefs
  • Seamless logistics sustain West Wing momentum
  • Distractions like pranks yield to core duties
Character traits
professional efficient coordinating
Follow Donna Moss's journey

Meeting with C.J.

Character traits
methodical relentless incisive professional unflappable
Follow Oliver Babish's journey

Sender of fax about Chinese satellite (Associate Administrator for NASA's Office of Space Flight).

Character traits
vigilant decisive institutional
Follow Byron Talmadge's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Josh's Beeper

Activates with shrill vibration on Josh's belt at conversation's outset, signaling Mack Sheridan's page; Josh waves it while probing the unknown crisis, amplifying layered urgencies and yanking focus amid Connelly's unfolding desperation for funds.

Before: Attached to Josh's belt, dormant during lobby approach
After: Acknowledged on belt, queued for return call to …
Before: Attached to Josh's belt, dormant during lobby approach
After: Acknowledged on belt, queued for return call to Mack
Martin Connelly's Briefcase

Gripped vise-like by Connelly upon sitting in Josh's office, it embodies the evidentiary war chest of depositions, experts, and research fueling his heated defense—silent talisman of DOJ's righteous but beleaguered siege against tobacco deception.

Before: Carried during lobby wait
After: Retained in Connelly's possession upon departure
Before: Carried during lobby wait
After: Retained in Connelly's possession upon departure

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

3
West Wing Corridor (Exterior Hallway Outside Leo McGarry's Office)

Facilitates tense emergence of Toby and Josh from Leo's closed-door intensity, with Toby freezing post-door thud—propels staff strides into bullpen fray where external crises like Connelly's await collision.

Atmosphere Charged with residual secrecy and brisk propulsion
Function Transitional corridor linking strategy to action
Symbolism Pathway where private plots meet public pleas
Access White House staff and cleared personnel only
Fluorescent glare sharpening footfalls Thudding doors echoing closures
Northwest Lobby

Hosts Josh's initial approach and apology to rising Connelly, neutral expanse where DOJ desperation breaches White House orbit—guards oversee as professional ambush ignites funding firestorm.

Atmosphere Vigilant hush pierced by urgent greetings
Function Approach and standoff zone for visitors
Symbolism Threshold of institutional collision
Access Heavily monitored with armed sentries
Marble floors rebounding strides Rifles snapping in poised silence
Josh's West Wing Bullpen

Buzzing hub envelops Connelly's office escort and dialogue core, Donna's coordination threading through as Josh absorbs fraud parallels—chaotic efficiency frames the plea within staff maelstrom.

Atmosphere Frantic yet ordered chaos of crises
Function Operational base for private negotiations
Access Primarily senior staff and appointees
Fluorescent buzz over clustered desks Open-plan flows of interruption

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

4
Tobacco Companies

Depicted as fraud-perpetrating behemoths with 380M war chest crushing DOJ's 36M via 31 lawyers vs. 342 plus subsidiaries—Connelly's indictment rallies Josh, paralleling White House deception themes.

Representation Invoked as lawsuit antagonists through cost stats
Power Dynamics Financially overwhelming government prosecutors
Impact Underscores corporate deception eroding public trust
Sustain defensive spending superiority Lobby Congress to block funding Vast litigation resources Political pressure via subsidiaries
U.S. House of Representatives

Portrayed as obstructionist via HR-260 passage, killing Commerce/HHS transfers to DOJ—Connelly's frustration pivots crisis to congressional veto power stalling righteous pursuit.

Representation Through blocking legislation HR-260
Power Dynamics Wielding appropriations hammer over executive
Impact Balances power via purse control
Enforce spending restrictions Counter executive legal initiatives Committee oversight on transfers Legislative prohibitions
United States Department of Commerce

Revealed as key prior fund source transferred to DOJ tobacco fight, now choked by House HR-260—Connelly highlights interagency lifeline severed amid fiscal warfare.

Representation Referenced in blocked transfer history
Power Dynamics Constrained ally in executive funding chain
Facilitate justice via budget reallocations Navigate congressional hurdles Interagency fund shifts Budgetary cooperation with DOJ
Health and Human Services

Parallel to Commerce as past donor of lawsuit millions, halted by House legislation per Connelly's urgent breakdown—exposes vulnerability in health-justice fiscal alliances.

Representation Via prior transfers cited in plea
Power Dynamics Potential resource under legislative blockade
Bolster anti-tobacco legal efforts Sustain inter-departmental support Health policy fund diversions Collaborative budgeting

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1
Causal

"Donna sets up the meeting with Connelly, which leads to Josh learning about the Justice Department's financial crisis, directly impacting the administration's strategy."

Donna's Bullpen Greeting Interrupted by Satellite Prank Panic
S2E20 · The Fall's Gonna Kill You
What this causes 3
Causal

"Donna sets up the meeting with Connelly, which leads to Josh learning about the Justice Department's financial crisis, directly impacting the administration's strategy."

Donna's Bullpen Greeting Interrupted by Satellite Prank Panic
S2E20 · The Fall's Gonna Kill You
Thematic Parallel medium

"Donna's panic over the falling satellite mirrors the administration's panic over the MS scandal, both representing uncontrolled descents with potentially catastrophic consequences."

Donna's Plutonium Panic: Charlie's Deadpan Banter on Crashing Satellite
S2E20 · The Fall's Gonna Kill You
Thematic Parallel medium

"Donna's panic over the falling satellite mirrors the administration's panic over the MS scandal, both representing uncontrolled descents with potentially catastrophic consequences."

Donna's Satellite Panic Elicits Abbey's Weary 'Tell Me About It'
S2E20 · The Fall's Gonna Kill You

Key Dialogue

"CONNELLY: "The case is running out of money.""
"JOSH: "Which case?""
"CONNELLY: "The US v...""
"JOSH: "You're kidding me!""
"CONNELLY: "These people perpetrated a fraud against the public.""
"JOSH: "The... tobacco companies.""