Failed Call and Barbara’s Collapse
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
The group's desperate attempt to contact the outside world fails, leaving them stranded and defeated. Barbara collapses from exhaustion following the failed communication attempt, heightening the tension and sense of urgency.
Ian attempts to aid Barbara with water, but she becomes agitated, refusing to let him touch her handkerchief. Barbara collapses, revealing she has been exposed to the insecticide.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Weakened, secretive, then relieved (upon waking and accepting help). Underlying guilt for endangering the group.
Barbara collapses from exhaustion and insecticide exposure, her body betraying her earlier attempts to hide her condition. She resists Ian’s attempt to take her handkerchief, revealing her secrecy about the poisoning. Upon waking, she admits her mistake and accepts the group’s urgency to return to the TARDIS. Her physical weakness contrasts with her usual resilience, and her dialogue reveals guilt for endangering the group. The Doctor’s diagnosis forces her to confront the severity of her situation.
- • Hide her poisoning to avoid distracting the group from their mission.
- • Accept the group’s help and return to the TARDIS to be restored to normal size.
- • Her poisoning is a personal failure that could jeopardize the group’s survival.
- • The group’s mission to stop the insecticide plot is more important than her individual health.
Frustrated but determined, with underlying anxiety about Barbara’s condition and the group’s inability to call for help.
Ian’s frustration boils over as the phone call fails, but his focus quickly shifts to Barbara’s collapse. He tries to help her by offering water and reaching for her handkerchief, only to discover it’s contaminated. His emotional state oscillates between concern for Barbara and frustration at the group’s helplessness. He presses the Doctor for solutions, his urgency to return to the TARDIS driven by a protective instinct to save Barbara, even as he grapples with the reality of their shrunk state.
- • Discover the cause of Barbara’s collapse and ensure her safety.
- • Push the group to return to the TARDIS immediately to restore Barbara’s size and treat her poisoning.
- • Barbara’s condition is critical and requires immediate medical intervention (restoring her size).
- • The group’s survival depends on their ability to act decisively, even in the face of setbacks like the failed phone call.
Concerned but composed, with a flicker of frustration at Barbara’s secrecy and the group’s vulnerability.
The Doctor takes responsibility for the failed phone call attempt, his brusque authority momentarily faltering as he admits fault. He shifts into clinical mode, using his pen to examine Barbara’s handkerchief and diagnosing her poisoning with sharp precision. His dialogue reveals a mix of concern and frustration—chastising Barbara for hiding her condition while reassuring Ian that her recovery is possible if they return to the TARDIS. His urgency to leave underscores the life-or-death stakes, blending alien detachment with grandfatherly protectiveness.
- • Diagnose and confirm Barbara’s poisoning using the handkerchief as evidence.
- • Convince the group to prioritize returning to the TARDIS to restore Barbara’s size and neutralize the insecticide.
- • Barbara’s poisoning is treatable if she is restored to normal size, as her protective cells will then be large enough to combat the insecticide.
- • The group’s survival depends on immediate action, and emotional secrecy (like Barbara’s) can be fatal in their current state.
Worried but hopeful, trusting in the Doctor’s ability to save Barbara.
Susan acts as a supportive companion, expressing concern for Barbara and questioning the Doctor about her condition. She defers to the Doctor’s authority but reinforces Ian’s urgency to return to the TARDIS. Her dialogue is minimal but emotionally charged, reflecting her worry for Barbara and her trust in the Doctor’s expertise. She serves as a bridge between Ian’s frustration and the Doctor’s clinical approach, her presence grounding the group’s emotional response.
- • Ensure Barbara receives immediate help from the Doctor.
- • Support Ian’s urgency to return to the TARDIS and restore Barbara’s size.
- • The Doctor’s scientific expertise is their best chance of saving Barbara.
- • The group’s unity and trust in each other are critical to their survival.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
Barbara’s handkerchief is the critical clue that exposes her poisoning. Stained with insecticide residue from handling the coated seeds, it becomes a silent witness to her secrecy. When Ian reaches for it, she resists, revealing her hidden condition. The Doctor uses his pen to lift it, confirming the poison’s presence through its aroma and glistening residue. The handkerchief’s contamination symbolizes Barbara’s self-sacrifice and the group’s collective vulnerability to the giant world’s dangers.
The giant telephone handset serves as a claustrophobic battleground for the group’s failed attempt to call for help. Its hollow interior becomes a precarious shelter, amplifying their voices into distorted growls audible to Barbara at the other end. The handset’s scale underscores their vulnerability—every shift risks collapse, and its components (dial, receiver) are useless in their miniature state. The object symbolizes their isolation and the futility of their efforts to communicate with the outside world, forcing them to confront the urgency of Barbara’s poisoning.
Ian’s glass of water for Barbara represents a small act of care amid their shrunken peril. Offered to her after her collapse, it symbolizes the group’s instinct to nurture one another despite their dire circumstances. Though she does not drink it onscreen, the glass embodies their humanity and the fragility of their bond in the face of the giant world’s indifference. Its presence contrasts with the clinical urgency of the Doctor’s diagnosis, grounding the scene in emotional realism.
Ian’s handkerchief serves as secondary evidence of Barbara’s poisoning. She had earlier borrowed it to wipe the insecticide from her hands, transferring the contamination unknowingly. The Doctor unfolds it inside the telephone handset, sniffing the residue to deduce Barbara’s condition. While not the primary clue, it reinforces the Doctor’s diagnosis and the group’s realization of how the poisoning occurred. The handkerchief’s role highlights the interconnectedness of their actions in the giant world.
The Doctor’s pen is a tool of precision and safety, used to lift Barbara’s contaminated handkerchief without direct contact. Its rigid tip pierces the fabric, isolating the glistening insecticide residue for inspection. This action underscores the Doctor’s clinical approach and the group’s reliance on his expertise to navigate the microscopic dangers of their shrunken state. The pen symbolizes their need for careful, methodical solutions in a world where even a handkerchief can be lethal.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The telephone handset’s interior is a claustrophobic, echoing chamber that amplifies the group’s desperation. Its plastic and metal walls press in as they scramble to prop collapsing sections with corks, their shouts distorted into growls audible to Barbara outside. The location’s scale—massive to their inch-tall forms—underscores their vulnerability, turning even a household object into a life-or-death trap. The handset’s functional role as a failed communication tool contrasts with its symbolic significance as a metaphor for their isolation and the futility of their attempts to reach the outside world.
Organizations Involved
Institutional presence and influence
The Police are invoked as a potential ally but remain unreachable, their absence underscoring the group’s isolation. Barbara’s failed attempt to call them through the telephone handset highlights the group’s inability to enlist institutional help. The Police’s role in this event is passive—represented only by their potential to intervene if contacted—but their unreachability forces the group to rely on their own resources. This absence reinforces the theme of self-reliance in the face of overwhelming odds, as the group must turn inward to save Barbara without external assistance.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"Barbara begins to feel ill. This foreshadows and directly leads to her contamination and collapse from touching insecticide."
The Doctor deciphers the poison's deadly design"Barbara begins to feel ill. This foreshadows and directly leads to her contamination and collapse from touching insecticide."
The insecticide’s lethal potential revealed"Barbara begins to feel ill. This foreshadows and directly leads to her contamination and collapse from touching insecticide."
The Doctor shifts from water to telephone"Barbara collapses from insecticide exposure. The Doctor confirms the exposure and explains her miniaturized state makes her vulnerable to the poison."
Doctor diagnoses Barbara’s poisoning"Barbara admits to feeling weak from lack of food, foreshadowing her increasing vulnerability. Later, after a failed phone call, Barbara collapses from exhaustion following the failed communication attempt.."
Climbing the telephone receiver"Barbara admits to feeling weak from lack of food, foreshadowing her increasing vulnerability. Later, after a failed phone call, Barbara collapses from exhaustion following the failed communication attempt.."
Barbara’s weakness exposes poisoning urgency"Barbara collapses from insecticide exposure. The Doctor confirms the exposure and explains her miniaturized state makes her vulnerable to the poison."
Doctor diagnoses Barbara’s poisoning"The Doctor announces they must return to the ship, but Barbara insists they must stop the scientists. Barbara prioritizes the mission over her personal safety despite knowing her condition."
Ian Pleads for Barbara’s EvacuationThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"BARBARA: No. No, nothing at all."
"IAN: What's the matter? BARBARA: You can't have it. You mustn't touch it."
"DOCTOR: She's got insecticide on her hands. She touched it. IAN: She never told me. I never saw her do this."
"DOCTOR: No, no, no, no, this little attack you've experienced is only temporary. BARBARA: Am I, am I? DOCTOR: No, no, no, no, this little attack you've experienced is only temporary."
"DOCTOR: We must get her back to the ship. IAN: What are we waiting for."