Fabula
S3E20 · Tin Man
S3E20
· Tin Man

Data’s Existential Pause: The Probe’s Revelation and the Weight of the Unknown

On the Enterprise bridge, Data—midway through processing the Vega Nine probe’s findings—pauses mid-sentence, his golden eyes flickering with uncharacteristic hesitation. The crew gathers around Science One as he reveals their destination: the Beta Stromgren system, a region of space untouched by human exploration. But it’s not the coordinates that fracture his composure—it’s the implications of the probe’s data, which he describes as ‘astonishing.’ The moment stretches, heavy with subtext: Data’s rare display of vulnerability (his earlier question to Geordi about his own ‘presence’) now mirrors the crew’s collective unease about what lies ahead. Riker’s sharp observation about the distance underscores the stakes, while Geordi’s physical reassurance—clasping Data’s shoulders—contrasts with the android’s existential musing. The beat is a narrative pivot: the probe’s discovery isn’t just a scientific anomaly; it’s a threshold, one that forces Data (and by extension, the audience) to confront the unknown—not just as data, but as meaning. The pause becomes a bridge between Data’s personal quest for self-understanding and the mission’s looming first-contact crisis, foreshadowing the telepathic encounter with Tin Man and the moral dilemmas it will demand.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Data pauses, then expresses astonishment at what the probe discovered, injecting mystery and heightening the sense of wonder and potential peril.

anticipation to astonishment

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

A rare moment of existential unease, where Data’s usual precision is overshadowed by a flicker of doubt—both about the mission’s unknowns and his own sense of self.

Data stands at Science One, loading the Vega Nine probe’s data chip. Midway through processing the findings, he pauses mid-sentence, his golden eyes flickering with hesitation. He reveals the destination (Beta Stromgren system) and describes the probe’s data as ‘astonishing,’ displaying rare vulnerability. His posture is slightly rigid, betraying internal conflict, as he grapples with both the mission’s implications and his own existential query about ‘presence.’

Goals in this moment
  • To accurately convey the probe’s findings to the crew, despite his own disquiet.
  • To reconcile his existential questioning with the practical demands of the mission.
Active beliefs
  • That the probe’s data holds profound implications beyond mere scientific discovery.
  • That his own ‘presence’—his existence as a sentient being—is a question worth exploring, even in the midst of a crisis.
Character traits
Vulnerable Introspective Hesitant Analytical Existentially curious
Follow Data's journey

Cautiously analytical, balancing the crew’s emotional moment with the need to assess the mission’s risks and logistical challenges.

Riker stands at Data’s shoulder, listening as the probe’s findings are revealed. He reacts to the distance of the Beta Stromgren system (23 parsecs beyond human exploration) with a note of apprehension, his analytical mind immediately grasping the stakes. His posture is attentive, and he contributes to the dialogue with a measured tone, grounding the crew in the practical realities of the mission.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure the crew understands the magnitude of the mission’s risks, particularly the distance and isolation of the Beta Stromgren system.
  • To maintain operational focus while allowing space for Data’s personal struggle.
Active beliefs
  • That first contact with the unknown requires both scientific rigor and emotional preparedness.
  • That the crew’s trust in one another is essential for success, even in the face of uncertainty.
Character traits
Analytical Apprehensive Grounded Protective Loyal
Follow William Riker's journey

Genuinely concerned for Data’s well-being, offering physical and emotional support to counteract Data’s moment of vulnerability.

Geordi stands at Data’s shoulder, listening intently as Data processes the probe’s data. When Data voices his existential question, Geordi responds by physically clasping Data’s shoulders—a gesture of reassurance, as if testing his solidness. His expression is supportive, and he engages in the dialogue with warmth, grounding Data in the moment.

Goals in this moment
  • To reassure Data of his tangible presence and worth, countering his existential doubt.
  • To ensure the crew remains focused on the mission despite the personal moment unfolding.
Active beliefs
  • That Data’s struggles with self-perception are valid and worthy of acknowledgment.
  • That the crew’s unity and trust in one another are critical to navigating the unknown.
Character traits
Supportive Reassuring Empathetic Grounded Loyal
Follow Geordi La …'s journey
Supporting 1

Collectively attentive and slightly tense, absorbing the weight of the mission’s unknowns while maintaining their roles.

The supernumerary bridge crew members are present at their stations but do not actively participate in the dialogue. They listen attentively, their presence contributing to the bridge’s operational atmosphere. Their focus is on their respective duties, though they are clearly aware of the tension in the air.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure the bridge remains fully operational and responsive to any developments.
  • To support the lead officers in their decisions and actions.
Active beliefs
  • That the crew’s cohesion is essential for navigating the challenges ahead.
  • That their individual roles, though small, contribute to the mission’s success.
Character traits
Attentive Professional Supportive (collectively) Disciplined
Follow USS Enterprise's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Science One Console (Enterprise-D Bridge — Data's Primary Science Station)

The **Science One Console** serves as the bridge between the Vega Nine probe’s data and the crew’s understanding of it. Data loads the data chip into the console, and its screen projects the Beta Stromgren system coordinates and the probe’s findings. The console becomes a visual and narrative focal point, amplifying the tension as the crew grapples with the implications of the data. Its display underscores the mission’s stakes and Data’s moment of hesitation.

Before: Operational and ready for data input, with no …
After: Actively displaying the Vega Nine probe’s data, including …
Before: Operational and ready for data input, with no active displays or readings.
After: Actively displaying the Vega Nine probe’s data, including the Beta Stromgren system coordinates and the ‘astonishing’ findings, now the center of the crew’s attention.
Vega Nine Probe

The **Vega Nine Probe Data Chip** is the catalyst for this event. Data slots it into Science One, and its contents—revealing the Beta Stromgren system and the ‘astonishing’ discovery—become the focal point of the crew’s attention. The chip’s data is both a scientific clue and a narrative threshold, pushing the crew toward the unknown. Its implications force Data into a moment of existential reflection, while Riker and Geordi react to the practical and emotional weight of the findings.

Before: Contained within Data’s possession, holding classified readings on …
After: Inserted into Science One, its data now displayed …
Before: Contained within Data’s possession, holding classified readings on the Beta Stromgren system and the Vega Nine probe’s astonishing discovery.
After: Inserted into Science One, its data now displayed on the console, becoming the centerpiece of the crew’s discussion and the impetus for their mission.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Bridge of the USS Enterprise-D

The **Main Bridge** of the *USS Enterprise-D* is the command center where this event unfolds. Its hum of activity and the crew’s focused presence create a tense, high-stakes atmosphere. The bridge’s layout—with Data at Science One, Riker and Geordi at his shoulders, and Worf at Tactical—frames the crew’s dynamic as they react to the Vega Nine probe’s data. The forward viewscreen, though not actively displaying anything in this moment, looms as a symbol of the unknown ahead. The bridge’s operational mood is one of controlled urgency, with the crew’s reactions to Data’s revelation adding an emotional layer to the scene.

Atmosphere Tense and focused, with an undercurrent of unease as the crew absorbs the implications of …
Function Command center for the *Enterprise-D*, where critical mission decisions are made and crew dynamics play …
Symbolism Represents the intersection of exploration and emotion, where the crew’s personal struggles (like Data’s existential …
Access Restricted to authorized crew members only, with clear roles and responsibilities for each station.
The hum of the *Enterprise-D*’s warp drive, a constant backdrop to the crew’s dialogue. The glow of the Science One console as Data loads the data chip, casting a soft light on the crew gathered around it. The forward viewscreen, dark but symbolic of the unknown ahead. The attentive silence of the supernumerary crew, their focus adding to the scene’s tension.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Starfleet

Starfleet’s influence is palpable in this event, though not explicitly stated. The Vega Nine probe’s data, the classified nature of the mission, and the crew’s adherence to protocol all reflect Starfleet’s institutional priorities: exploration, first contact, and the pursuit of knowledge—even in the face of the unknown. The crew’s reactions to the Beta Stromgren system’s distance and the probe’s ‘astonishing’ findings are shaped by Starfleet’s mandate to push boundaries, even as they grapple with personal and ethical dilemmas.

Representation Via institutional protocol (classified data, mission parameters) and the crew’s collective adherence to Starfleet’s exploratory …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over the crew’s actions through mission directives, while also being challenged by the …
Impact The crew’s reactions to the probe’s data reflect the tension between Starfleet’s exploratory imperatives and …
Internal Dynamics The crew’s unity is both a product of Starfleet’s training and a point of tension, …
To advance the boundaries of human (and android) exploration, even into uncharted and potentially dangerous regions of space. To ensure that first contact with unknown entities is conducted with both scientific rigor and ethical consideration. Through classified mission parameters and data (e.g., the Vega Nine probe’s findings). Through the crew’s internalized sense of duty and loyalty to Starfleet’s values. Through the institutional structures that govern the *Enterprise-D*’s operations and decision-making.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 4
Foreshadowing medium

"Data expresses astonishment about the probe's findings, creating anticipation for the reveal of "Tin Man."

The Race to Tin Man: Science, Secrets, and the Shadow of War
S3E20 · Tin Man
Foreshadowing medium

"Data expresses astonishment about the probe's findings, creating anticipation for the reveal of "Tin Man."

Tam’s Unraveling: The Weight of Isolation and the Cost of Trust
S3E20 · Tin Man
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data reveals the Enterprise's destination as Beta Stromgren, then he and Tam present the information about Tin Man."

The Race to Tin Man: Science, Secrets, and the Shadow of War
S3E20 · Tin Man
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data reveals the Enterprise's destination as Beta Stromgren, then he and Tam present the information about Tin Man."

Tam’s Unraveling: The Weight of Isolation and the Cost of Trust
S3E20 · Tin Man

Key Dialogue

"DATA: *Commander, Geordi... do you ever feel as if I am not 'there?' That is to say... not 'here.'*"
"GEORDI: *You seem to be all here.*"
"DATA: *Our destination is the Beta Stromgren system, following the path of the Vega Nine probe.*"
"RIKER: *That's twenty-three parsecs beyond our furthest manned explorations.*"
"DATA: *Apparently the probe has discovered... [beat] ...Astonishing.*"