Fabula
S2E8 · Shibboleth
S2E8
· Shibboleth

C.J.'s Turkey Audition Fiasco and Song Confession

C.J. drags Donna aside, confessing her ignorance of the traditional Thanksgiving song 'We Gather Together' despite her credentials, revealing a rare vulnerability amid press secretary pressures. Inside her office, amid flashing cameras, she conducts a final 'audition' for turkeys Eric and Troy, selecting Eric over Troy for his composure despite flapping concerns. Struggling to wrangle the lively Eric, C.J. receives Donna's practical tip on supporting the bird's hindquarters, blending absurd comedy with the staff's frantic holiday prep. This interlude provides levity, humanizing C.J. as she juggles frivolity against the refugee crisis, underscoring thematic tensions between ceremony and catastrophe.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

C.J. admits her musical incompetence for the Thanksgiving event, exposing the absurd contrast between her professional stature and elementary school song knowledge.

tension to comedic vulnerability ["C.J.'s office door"]

C.J. conducts high-stakes turkey auditions with camera flashes, treating livestock selection with presidential campaign rigor.

vulnerability to absurd authority ["C.J.'s office"]

Donna re-enters with poultry handling advice as C.J. wrestles with Eric the turkey, physical comedy underscoring the surreal demands of White House ceremonies.

authority to chaotic frustration

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4
Eric
primary

Stoic resistance, avian instincts overriding human handling.

Eric perches defiantly on C.J.'s office chair during the final camera-flash audition, remains unflappably composed to win pardon selection over Troy, then resists C.J. and Donna's wrangling attempts to get him down and toward the door.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain perch and composure to secure pardon
  • Resist dislodging from comfortable chair
Active beliefs
  • Chair provides secure vantage against threats
  • Stillness ensures survival in chaotic environments
Character traits
unflappable stubborn composed
Follow Eric's journey
Troy
primary

Agitated panic from flashes and competition.

Troy participates in the office camera-flash audition alongside Eric, flaps frantically in response to flashes disqualifying himself, and lunges forward as C.J. physically blocks him back while she handles the victorious Eric.

Goals in this moment
  • Compete aggressively for audition spotlight
  • Advance toward C.J. during wrangling distraction
Active beliefs
  • Flapping asserts dominance in rivalry
  • Chaos aids escape or opportunity
Character traits
frantic disruptive energetic
Follow Troy's journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Exasperated vulnerability masking press secretary overload, blending self-deprecating humor with frantic multitasking.

C.J. borrows Donna urgently from the bullpen, banters briefly with Josh, confesses her shocking ignorance of 'We Gather Together' at her office door, then enters to flash-camera audition turkeys, selects Eric despite his eerie stillness, and wrestles him off the chair while blocking Troy, snapping fingers in frustration.

Goals in this moment
  • Select the most photogenic, composed turkey for pardon to avoid Oval mishaps
  • Quickly learn or adapt Thanksgiving song for CNN performance amid crisis
Active beliefs
  • Flapping turkeys undermine presidential dignity and photo ops
  • Personal knowledge gaps like song lyrics expose cracks in her elite credentials but can be patched with aides
Character traits
vulnerable witty under pressure decisive exasperated
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey
Donna Moss
primary

Helpful exasperation tinged with amusement at C.J.'s elite blind spots, steady amid chaos.

Donna stands rifling her folder at her bullpen desk, agrees to help C.J., notes INS arrival to Josh, teaches 'We Gather Together' and suggests 'Madrigals' alternative with a sigh, then re-enters office to offer hindquarter support tip while assisting in wrangling Eric off the chair.

Goals in this moment
  • Aid C.J. with song knowledge and turkey handling to smooth holiday prep
  • Alert Josh to incoming INS amid her logistical duties
Active beliefs
  • Basic cultural songs like 'We Gather Together' are common knowledge everyone should know
  • Practical grips under hindquarters make turkey wrangling feasible even for novices
Character traits
helpful pragmatic mildly exasperated knowledgeable
Follow Donna Moss's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Donna's Folder

Donna's Folder serves as a mundane anchor at her bullpen desk, rifled through as C.J. interrupts for urgent help, symbolizing the clash of routine admin with holiday absurdity and refugee undercurrents; it grounds Donna's initial state before song lessons and turkey aid.

Before: At Donna's desk in Josh's Bullpen Area, open …
After: Unchanged at Donna's desk, abandoned as she assists …
Before: At Donna's desk in Josh's Bullpen Area, open and being examined standing.
After: Unchanged at Donna's desk, abandoned as she assists C.J.
C.J.'s Turkey Audition Camera Flash

C.J.'s Turkey Audition Camera Flash erupts in blinding bursts inside her office, testing Eric and Troy's composure under stress to mimic presidential photo pressure; its pulses disqualify flapping Troy, crown stoic Eric, and heighten C.J.'s vulnerability amid farce.

Before: In C.J.'s possession, ready inside her office.
After: In C.J.'s hand post-audition, set aside for wrangling.
Before: In C.J.'s possession, ready inside her office.
After: In C.J.'s hand post-audition, set aside for wrangling.
C.J.'s Office Chair

C.J.'s Office Chair becomes Eric's defiant perch during the audition, creased under his sprawl as flashes test reactions; it transforms into a chaotic wrangling battleground where C.J. and Donna lunge, snapping fingers, underscoring the slapstick humanizing staff amid crises.

Before: In C.J.'s office, occupied by Eric.
After: Vacated by Eric, creased and disheveled post-wrangle attempt.
Before: In C.J.'s office, occupied by Eric.
After: Vacated by Eric, creased and disheveled post-wrangle attempt.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Josh's West Wing Bullpen

Josh's Bullpen Area hosts the event's frantic opening—Donna at her folder-laden desk, C.J.'s urgent borrow, Josh banter—propelling duo toward C.J.'s office door for confession; its cluttered desks amplify West Wing pandemonium, bridging holiday levity to INS alerts.

Atmosphere Bustling with interrupted routines, casual banter masking underlying urgency.
Function Launch pad for C.J.-Donna collaboration and info handoff.
Symbolism Embodiment of staff chaos where frivolity collides with diplomacy.
Access Open to senior West Wing staff.
Desks shadowed by late frenzy Ambient staff movement and turkey gobble echoes

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
CNN International

CNN amplifies stakes as C.J. laments conducting her musical on their broadcast, framing the song ignorance confession and turkey audition as high-wire optics prep amid national scrutiny, humanizing her pressures.

Representation Invoked as broadcast platform for upcoming children's song performance.
Power Dynamics Media overlord dictating White House ceremonial tempo and image.
Impact Blends news velocity with holiday farce, heightening narrative tensions.
Capture feel-good holiday spectacles for ratings Scrutinize White House principals live Public broadcast pressure on performances Optics agenda forcing staff perfection
Immigration and Naturalization Service (I.N.S.)

Immigration and Naturalization Service (I.N.S.) looms as impending authority when Donna alerts Josh of their imminent arrival amid turkey chaos, injecting refugee crisis gravity that contrasts and elevates the comedic audition's frivolity.

Representation Via off-screen agents referenced as 'INS guys' arriving soon.
Power Dynamics External bureaucratic force infiltrating White House frenzy, demanding procedural focus.
Impact Underscores tension between holiday ceremony and humanitarian diplomacy.
Conduct credible fear interviews for Chinese refugees Coordinate with White House on asylum decisions Imminent physical arrival of agents Procedural mandates shifting staff priorities

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Temporal medium

"Josh's deflection with Thanksgiving plans is immediately followed by Donna's bombshell about the INS agents, highlighting the overlap of crises."

Leo Urgently Briefed on Stowaway Crisis, Orders C.J. Alert
S2E8 · Shibboleth
Temporal medium

"Josh's deflection with Thanksgiving plans is immediately followed by Donna's bombshell about the INS agents, highlighting the overlap of crises."

Josh Briefs C.J. on Refugee Crisis and Toby's Prayer Fight Gambit
S2E8 · Shibboleth

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: "I need help with the song." DONNA: "Is it the usual song?" C.J.: "There's a usual song?""
"C.J.: "Troy, I want you know it was neck-and-neck but I'm giving it to Eric. You were in it right to the end but it's the flapping thing you've got going on.""
"DONNA: "The guy said to support him under his hindquarters." C.J.: "Well I don't know where his hindquarters are and I'm not going to look that hard.""