Fabula
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks Part 2

Waterfield reveals Dalek blackmail and trap

In Maxtible’s laboratory, the Doctor interrogates Waterfield and Maxtible about their reckless time-travel experiments, which inadvertently opened a portal for the Daleks. Under pressure, Waterfield confesses that the Daleks coerced him into stealing the Doctor’s TARDIS and luring him and Jamie to 1866 by threatening his daughter, Victoria. The Daleks then materialize, asserting control by revealing they’ve captured the TARDIS and demanding the Doctor’s cooperation in a sinister experiment to isolate the ‘human factor’—the trait that allows humans to defeat them. The Doctor’s defiance clashes with Waterfield’s desperation, while Maxtible’s vague theories about the Daleks’ motives hint at their long-term strategic threat. The scene escalates the stakes, exposing the Daleks’ premeditated manipulation of human vulnerability and forcing the Doctor into a precarious position as their unwilling pawn. The revelation of Jamie’s role as the experiment’s subject adds immediate urgency to the Doctor’s resistance.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Waterfield reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap by stealing his box (TARDIS), and transporting him and Jamie to this location, hinting at a deeper understanding the creatures have of The Doctor

Fear to revelation

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6

Triumphant and domineering, with an undercurrent of cold, calculating anticipation. The Dalek exudes confidence in its superiority, treating the humans as pawns in a larger game.

The Dalek materializes abruptly from the mirrored room, its eyestalk sweeping over the laboratory with cold authority. It dominates the scene with its metallic, echoing voice, issuing demands and threats in a tone that brooks no dissent. The Dalek's physical presence is oppressive, its movements precise and menacing as it asserts control over the Doctor, Waterfield, and Maxtible. It reveals its plan to experiment on Jamie with clinical detachment, using the Doctor's TARDIS as leverage. The Dalek's dialogue is sparse but devastating, each word calculated to instill fear and compliance.

Goals in this moment
  • To force the Doctor into compliance by threatening the destruction of his TARDIS and leveraging Jamie's capture.
  • To isolate and transplant the 'human factor' from Jamie into Dalek physiology, ensuring their future invincibility.
Active beliefs
  • That humanity's ability to resist the Daleks is rooted in a tangible, extractable 'human factor' that can be replicated or eradicated.
  • That the Doctor, as a Time Lord, possesses the knowledge and skills necessary to facilitate this experiment, making him a valuable asset.
Character traits
Absolute authority Emotionless pragmatism Strategic ruthlessness Collective consciousness (speaking as 'we') Disdain for human life
Follow Dalek Strategic …'s journey

Crushed by guilt and fear, oscillating between remorse for his actions and desperation to save his daughter. His emotional state is a mix of self-loathing and hopeful pleading, directed at the Doctor as his only potential savior.

Waterfield stands trembling beside Maxtible, his face a mask of guilt and desperation. He confesses to being coerced by the Daleks into luring the Doctor and Jamie to 1866, his voice breaking as he reveals the threat to his daughter, Victoria. Waterfield's physical presence is one of submission, his shoulders hunched and his hands clasped tightly. He pleads with the Doctor for help, his moral outrage at the Daleks' actions palpable, yet his complicity in their scheme is undeniable. His admission that Jamie is 'in the house' seals his role as an unwilling accomplice in the Daleks' plan.

Goals in this moment
  • To secure the Doctor's help in rescuing Victoria and thwarting the Daleks' experiment on Jamie.
  • To absolve himself of guilt by revealing the full extent of the Daleks' coercion and his own complicity.
Active beliefs
  • That the Doctor is his only hope of escaping the Daleks' control and saving Victoria.
  • That the Daleks' experiment on Jamie is a monstrous violation that must be stopped, even if it means risking his daughter's life.
Character traits
Moral conflict (guilt vs. desperation) Emotional vulnerability Desperate pragmatism Fatherly devotion (to Victoria) Unwitting collaborator
Follow Edward Waterfield's journey

Vulnerable and unknowingly endangered, though his bravery and adaptability would likely surface if he were present. The Doctor's reaction suggests Jamie is seen as both a companion and a symbol of what the Daleks seek to destroy or replicate.

Jamie is not physically present in this event but is referenced as the subject of the Daleks' experiment. His absence looms large over the scene, as the Daleks demand his location and reveal their intent to use him as a test subject. The Doctor's alarm at the mention of Jamie's name—'Jamie?'—underscores the immediate danger Jamie is in, while Waterfield's admission that Jamie is 'in the house' confirms his captivity. Jamie's role as the 'human being who is to be tested' elevates the stakes, as the Doctor's protective instincts are fully aroused.

Goals in this moment
  • To survive the Daleks' experiment, though he is unaware of the threat at this moment.
  • To remain a source of strength and loyalty to the Doctor, even in captivity.
Active beliefs
  • That his skills and instincts as a Highland warrior will see him through any danger.
  • That the Doctor will find a way to rescue him, as he always has before.
Character traits
Loyalty to the Doctor Resourcefulness in adversity Unwitting pawn in the Daleks' scheme Symbol of human resilience (as the target of the experiment)
Follow Jamie McCrimmon's journey

Unknowingly vulnerable, though his bravery and adaptability would likely surface if he were present. The Doctor's reaction suggests Jamie is seen as both a companion and a symbol of what the Daleks seek to destroy or replicate.

Jamie is referenced as the subject of the Daleks' experiment, but his physical presence is limited to the off-screen mention of his captivity 'in the house.' The Doctor's alarm at the Daleks' demand for Jamie's location—'Why do you ask about Jamie?'—highlights the immediate danger Jamie is in. Waterfield's admission that Jamie is 'in the house' confirms his role as a pawn in the Daleks' scheme. Jamie's absence is a driving force in the scene, as the Doctor's protective instincts are aroused, and the stakes are raised by the Daleks' sinister intentions.

Goals in this moment
  • To survive the Daleks' experiment, though he is unaware of the threat at this moment.
  • To remain a source of strength and loyalty to the Doctor, even in captivity.
Active beliefs
  • That his skills and instincts as a Highland warrior will see him through any danger.
  • That the Doctor will find a way to rescue him, as he always has before.
Character traits
Unwitting subject of the Daleks' experiment Symbol of human resilience Loyal companion to the Doctor Resourceful in adversity
Follow Victoria Waterfield's journey

Calm but evasive, masking deep anxiety beneath a veneer of scientific detachment. He is clearly unsettled by the Daleks' actions but rationalizes his involvement as a necessity, avoiding direct confrontation with his moral failings.

Maxtible stands beside Waterfield, his demeanor a mix of calm rationalization and evasive defensiveness. He offers the Doctor a cigar, a gesture that contrasts sharply with the tension in the room, and attempts to reassure Waterfield with platitudes like 'Oh, my dear fellow.' Maxtible theorizes about the Daleks' motives, speculating that they seek to isolate and transplant the 'human factor' into their own physiology. His dialogue is measured and intellectual, though it betrays a underlying unease. He admits to being coerced by the Daleks but deflects moral responsibility, emphasizing the impossibility of resisting their threats to Victoria. His role as the 'brilliant mind' behind the experiments is underscored, but his complicity is equally clear.

Goals in this moment
  • To convince the Doctor that cooperation with the Daleks is the only viable option, given their superior power and leverage over Victoria.
  • To distance himself from moral responsibility by framing his actions as the result of coercion and intellectual curiosity.
Active beliefs
  • That the Daleks' experiment is a scientific endeavor that can be reasoned with, despite its ethical implications.
  • That the Doctor's knowledge and skills are essential to the Daleks' success, making him a critical asset in their plan.
Character traits
Intellectual detachment Evasive rationalization Calm under pressure Moral ambiguity (justifying complicity) Theoretical curiosity
Follow The Second …'s journey
Supporting 1

Fearful and helpless, though her precise emotional state is implied through Waterfield's desperation and the Daleks' threats. She is likely experiencing a mix of terror, isolation, and longing for her father's protection.

Victoria is mentioned but not physically present in this event. Her absence is a constant, looming threat, as Waterfield's confession reveals that the Daleks are holding her hostage to coerce his cooperation. The Doctor's realization that 'now they've got Jamie' parallels Waterfield's earlier revelation about Victoria, creating a symmetry of vulnerability. Victoria's role as a leverage point for the Daleks is underscored by Waterfield's plea and Maxtible's acknowledgment of the Daleks' hold over her. Her safety is the linchpin of the Daleks' control over Waterfield and, by extension, the Doctor.

Goals in this moment
  • To survive her captivity and await rescue.
  • To remain a source of moral leverage for her father, even unintentionally.
Active beliefs
  • That her father will find a way to save her, as he has always protected her.
  • That the Daleks' cruelty knows no bounds, and compliance is her only means of survival.
Character traits
Innocent victim Symbol of human fragility Unwitting catalyst for the Daleks' scheme Emotional anchor for Waterfield
Follow Theodore Maxtible's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

5
Doctor's TARDIS

The Doctor's TARDIS is referenced as a critical leverage point by the Daleks, who threaten to destroy it unless the Doctor cooperates with their experiment. The TARDIS is described as 'a box belonging to you,' reducing its cosmic significance to a bargaining chip in the Daleks' coercion. Its absence from the scene is palpable, as the Doctor's defiance is tempered by the knowledge that his time ship—and his means of escape—are in the Daleks' control. The TARDIS symbolizes the Doctor's autonomy and power, making its capture a devastating blow that forces him into a precarious position.

Before: Concealed in Maxtible's laboratory, under the Daleks' control …
After: Continues to be held hostage by the Daleks, …
Before: Concealed in Maxtible's laboratory, under the Daleks' control and threatened with destruction.
After: Continues to be held hostage by the Daleks, its destruction looming as a constant threat to the Doctor's compliance.
Maxtible and Waterfield's Human Factor Isolation Experiment (Mirror Array Apparatus)

The 144 polished metal mirrors in Maxtible's laboratory are central to the Daleks' materialization and the revelation of their plan. These mirrors, arranged in precise formation and subjected to electric charges, were the apparatus through which Waterfield and Maxtible inadvertently opened a portal to the Daleks' dimension. The mirrors serve as a conduit for the Daleks' arrival, their reflective surfaces shimmering with static electricity as the Dalek emerges from the 'mirrored room.' The mirrors symbolize the dangerous intersection of human ambition and alien technology, a fusion that has unleashed the Daleks' wrath. Their presence in the laboratory is a constant reminder of the scientists' hubris and the catastrophic consequences of their experiments.

Before: Activated and charged with static electricity, arranged in …
After: Continue to hum with residual energy, now serving …
Before: Activated and charged with static electricity, arranged in a precise formation to create a temporal rift.
After: Continue to hum with residual energy, now serving as a portal through which the Daleks exert their control over the laboratory and its occupants.
Maxtible's Laboratory Cigar

Maxtible's cigar, offered to the Doctor as a gesture of false hospitality, serves as a symbolic distraction in the midst of the escalating confrontation. The cigar is a mundane object that contrasts sharply with the high-stakes tension in the laboratory, highlighting the absurdity of Maxtible's attempt to maintain a facade of normalcy. The Doctor's wary reaction to the cigar—'eyes it warily'—underscores the unease and distrust that permeates the scene. The cigar is a fleeting moment of normalcy in a situation that is anything but normal, a reminder of the human desire for comfort even in the face of existential threats.

Before: Offered to the Doctor by Maxtible as a …
After: Likely discarded or ignored as the confrontation escalates, …
Before: Offered to the Doctor by Maxtible as a gesture of false hospitality, lying untouched on a nearby surface.
After: Likely discarded or ignored as the confrontation escalates, its symbolic role as a distraction fulfilled.
Maxtible's Rubber Tubing and Bubbling Retorts

Maxtible's rubber tubing and bubbling retorts are part of the laboratory's scientific apparatus, humming with activity as the Daleks materialize. These objects symbolize the dangerous fusion of human ambition and alien technology, a fusion that has unleashed the Daleks' wrath. The tubing and retorts represent the scientists' failed attempts to control forces beyond their understanding, their bubbling contents a metaphor for the uncontrollable consequences of their experiments. The Dalek's eyestalk sweeps over the setup, a silent acknowledgment of the human scientists' hubris and the Daleks' superior power. The objects serve as a reminder of the catastrophic consequences of playing with forces one does not fully comprehend.

Before: Active and humming with energy, linked to the …
After: Continue to bubble and hum, now serving as …
Before: Active and humming with energy, linked to the mirrors and static electricity generators.
After: Continue to bubble and hum, now serving as a backdrop to the Daleks' domination of the laboratory.
Waterfield's Photograph Staging Box

The box from Waterfield's valise, which previously contained the torn photograph of the Doctor, is not directly referenced in this event. However, its earlier role in staging the trap for the Doctor underscores the Daleks' meticulous planning and manipulation of human pawns. The box serves as a metaphor for the Daleks' ability to control and deceive, using seemingly innocuous objects to further their sinister ends. Its absence in this event highlights the shift from deception to outright coercion, as the Daleks no longer need subtlety—they have the Doctor and Jamie in their grasp.

Before: Previously used to stage the trap for the …
After: No longer relevant to the immediate confrontation, as …
Before: Previously used to stage the trap for the Doctor, now likely discarded or repurposed by the Daleks.
After: No longer relevant to the immediate confrontation, as the Daleks have escalated to direct threats and demands.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Maxtible's House

Maxtible's laboratory is the epicenter of the confrontation between the Doctor, Waterfield, Maxtible, and the Daleks. This high-tech chamber, filled with 144 polished metal mirrors, rubber tubing, and bubbling retorts, is where Waterfield and Maxtible's experiments went catastrophically wrong, opening a portal to the Daleks' dimension. The laboratory is a symbol of human hubris and the dangerous fusion of science and alien technology. It is here that the Daleks materialize, asserting their control over the Doctor and demanding his cooperation in their sinister experiment. The laboratory's atmosphere is one of tension and desperation, as the Doctor's defiance clashes with the Daleks' threats and Waterfield's pleas for help. The mirrors, in particular, serve as a conduit for the Daleks' arrival, their reflective surfaces shimmering with static electricity as the Dalek emerges from the 'mirrored room.'

Atmosphere Tension-filled and oppressive, with an undercurrent of desperation and moral conflict. The air crackles with …
Function Epicenter of the confrontation between the Doctor, Waterfield, Maxtible, and the Daleks. A symbol of …
Symbolism Represents the consequences of meddling with forces beyond human understanding. The laboratory's mirrors symbolize the …
Access Restricted to those under the Daleks' control, including Waterfield, Maxtible, and the Doctor. The laboratory …
The 144 polished metal mirrors, arranged in precise formation and charged with static electricity. The rubber tubing and bubbling retorts, humming with residual energy from the failed experiments. The gothic pointed doors, marking the entrance to the chamber where the Daleks emerged.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Daleks

The Daleks, as an organization, dominate this event through their sudden materialization and ruthless coercion. They assert absolute control over the laboratory, using the Doctor's TARDIS as leverage and demanding his cooperation in their experiment to isolate the 'human factor.' The Daleks' presence is oppressive, their metallic voices echoing with authority as they reveal their plan to experiment on Jamie. Their collective consciousness speaks as 'we,' emphasizing their unity and power. The Daleks' threats to destroy the TARDIS and their hold over Victoria and Jamie underscore their strategic ruthlessness, as they manipulate human vulnerability to achieve their goals. The organization's power dynamics are unchallenged, as Waterfield and Maxtible submit to their demands, and the Doctor is forced into a precarious position.

Representation Through a single Dalek spokesman who materializes from the mirrored room, issuing demands and threats …
Power Dynamics Exercising absolute authority over the humans in the laboratory, using leverage (the TARDIS, Victoria, Jamie) …
Impact The Daleks' involvement in this event underscores their long-term strategic threat to humanity. Their ability …
Internal Dynamics The Daleks operate as a unified collective, with no internal dissent or hierarchy visible in …
To force the Doctor into compliance by threatening the destruction of his TARDIS and leveraging the capture of Jamie and Victoria. To isolate and transplant the 'human factor' from Jamie into Dalek physiology, ensuring their future invincibility. Leverage (threatening the TARDIS, Victoria, and Jamie), Coercion (using blackmail and threats to enforce compliance), Psychological manipulation (exploiting human vulnerability and moral dilemmas)

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 7

"Maxtible gives an explanation causing Waterfield and Maxtible to describe their experiments with electromagnetism (beat_718b0be013b1aa49), further clarifying the situation for the Doctor and the audience."

Doctor Accuses Maxtible and Waterfield
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible gives an explanation causing Waterfield and Maxtible to describe their experiments with electromagnetism (beat_718b0be013b1aa49), further clarifying the situation for the Doctor and the audience."

Doctor Confronts Maxtible and Waterfield
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible gives an explanation causing Waterfield and Maxtible to describe their experiments with electromagnetism (beat_718b0be013b1aa49), further clarifying the situation for the Doctor and the audience."

Waterfield’s Grief Exposes His Vulnerability
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Scientists Reveal Their Catastrophic Experiment
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks reveal their experiment and blackmail the Doctor
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks demand Jamie for human factor experiment
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks Demand the Human Factor
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …
What this causes 5

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Scientists Reveal Their Catastrophic Experiment
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks reveal their experiment and blackmail the Doctor
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks demand Jamie for human factor experiment
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"Maxtible and Waterfield explain their experiments, which caused the portal to open. Waterfield then reveals the creatures forced him to lure the Doctor into a trap (beat_0d873b88e4141528) by stealing his box."

Daleks Demand the Human Factor
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"The Doctor learns the Daleks seek the 'human factor' to transplant into Daleks (beat_a53bebed5fbda278). This causes the Doctor to defy the Daleks' wishes to warn Jamie (beat_d18a62c3c1672011), showing his protective nature."

Doctor defies Dalek orders to warn Jamie
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"WATERFIELD: They are monsters. Creations of the devil!"
"WATERFIELD: They forced me into the horror of time travel, Doctor. They ordered me to steal a box belonging to you and thus lure you into a trap and transport you here, together with your colleague Mister McCrimmon."
"DALEK: We have your time ship. We will destroy it unless you help us with an experiment."
"DOCTOR: What sort of test?"
"DALEK: Silence! You will reveal nothing to your companion. Obey the Daleks! You are in our power!"
"MAXTIBLE: They, I mean the Daleks, tell me they have always been defeated by human beings. Possibly because of some factor, possessed by human beings, that is absent in Daleks."