S1E39
Cynical
Written by Dennis Spooner
View Graph

A Change of Identity

In revolutionary Paris, the Doctor, Barbara, and Susan become entangled in a dangerous game of espionage and escape as they attempt to rescue Ian from the clutches of the French Revolutionaries.

The Doctor arrives in Paris amidst the French Revolution, where he quickly gets caught up in a web of intrigue. A rescue attempt of prisoners scheduled for execution goes awry when the horse pulling the tumbril throws a shoe, delaying the escape and putting the escapees, Barbara and Susan, in grave danger. Jules and Jean, two revolutionaries, successfully intervene, rescuing the women from the tumbril. They take Barbara and Susan to a safe house where Danielle, Jules' sister, cares for them. Barbara reveals that they are searching for her grandfather, who got separated from them. They are also trying to free Ian, who remains imprisoned.

Meanwhile, Ian seizes an opportunity and escapes from his cell, finding the jailer injured. LeMaitre, a shadowy figure, is aware of Ian's escape and seems to be manipulating events behind the scenes. The Doctor, attempting to blend in, visits a tailor, acquiring new clothes and a sash that identify him as a regional officer. He then goes to the prison to inquire about three traitors, learning about the women's rescue and the man's escape. He seeks information from the jailer, who claims Ian overpowered him. LeMaitre then appears and demands to see the Doctor's papers, suspicious of the out-of-place officer. He invites the Doctor to attend a meeting with Robespierre, effectively detaining him under scrutiny.

Back at the safe house, Barbara and Susan reveal their map, recounting their journey to Jules. Barbara and Susan explain the map they drew that indicates where their grandfather was last seen and where they were arrested. Jules sends Leon, another member of the group, to investigate. Leon reports a stranger asking for Jules near the prison. Jules and Jean leave to investigate the stranger, leaving Leon to watch Barbara. The Doctor's disguise and attempt to gather information about his companions have placed him in direct conflict with the Revolutionaries to free his friends, even as the revolutionaries themselves are dealing with traitors in their midst.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

18
Act 1

Act One establishes the immediate peril facing the Doctor's companions and introduces the revolutionary figures who will become their reluctant allies. Jules and Jean, two French revolutionaries, prepare to ambush a tumbril, demonstrating their commitment to rescuing "traitors" from execution. Their tense wait on a quiet street underscores the high stakes of their mission. Concurrently, inside the prison, Ian seizes a fleeting opportunity for escape, noticing a key left in his cell door. This act of self-preservation highlights his resourcefulness under duress. The tumbril carrying Barbara and Susan then encounters an unexpected delay due to a thrown horse shoe, providing the critical window for Jules and Jean to intervene. Their swift, violent rescue of the women from the guards establishes their effectiveness and the dangerous environment of revolutionary Paris. Immediately following this, the Doctor arrives, unobserved, and takes proactive steps to blend into the city. He visits a tailor, shrewdly acquiring the attire and sash of a regional officer through a clever exchange for his unique, futuristic coat and a ring. This disguise is a calculated move to navigate the dangerous city and gather information about his missing friends, but it also places him in a position of authority that could draw unwanted attention. This initial act sets up the scattered state of the companions and the Doctor's immediate, albeit risky, efforts to locate them, while introducing the complex moral landscape of the revolution.

Act 2

Act Two develops the converging storylines of the separated companions and the Doctor, escalating the immediate threats and revealing deeper layers of intrigue. Barbara and Susan find temporary refuge in Jules' comfortable suburban dwelling, where they begin to disclose their extraordinary circumstances. They reveal their map, detailing their journey, the location where their grandfather was last seen, and their arrest point. This information inadvertently exposes a compromised escape route, raising suspicions among Jules and Jean about an informant within their ranks. Simultaneously, Ian successfully escapes from his cell, leaving the jailer injured and drawing the attention of the shadowy LeMaitre, who appears to be orchestrating events from behind the scenes. The Doctor, now convincingly disguised as a regional officer, proceeds to the prison to inquire about "three traitors." His questioning of the injured jailer yields crucial, albeit partial, information: the women were rescued, and the man escaped. This confirms his companions are alive but scattered. However, the Doctor's conspicuous presence and inquiries attract LeMaitre's attention. LeMaitre, suspicious of the out-of-place officer, demands to see the Doctor's papers and, in a move that effectively detains him under scrutiny, "invites" the Doctor to a high-stakes meeting with Robespierre. This act marks a significant turning point where the Doctor's proactive search directly leads him into the heart of revolutionary power, placing him under immediate threat.

Act 3

Act Three intensifies the Doctor's precarious situation and highlights the growing internal tensions within the revolutionary group. Following Leon's report of a "stranger" asking for Jules near the prison, Jules and Jean depart to investigate, leaving Leon to guard Barbara and Susan. This decision inadvertently sends them directly towards the Doctor, who is unknowingly the "stranger" they seek. Meanwhile, Leon, alone with Barbara, begins to probe her origins, revealing a subtle undercurrent of xenophobia and political suspicion. Barbara's admission of being English immediately positions her as a potential enemy in Leon's eyes, foreshadowing future conflicts and demonstrating the pervasive distrust of the era. Concurrently, the Doctor, having been cornered by LeMaitre at the prison, is now effectively under the revolutionary's control. LeMaitre compels the Doctor to attend a meeting with Robespierre, ostensibly to discuss his province, but clearly as a means of keeping him under close surveillance. This forced attendance at the highest echelons of revolutionary power represents a critical escalation of the Doctor's predicament, transforming his disguise from a tool of infiltration into a trap. The act concludes with the Doctor's freedom severely curtailed and the revolutionary group actively, though unknowingly, closing in on him, while Barbara and Susan remain in a state of vulnerable uncertainty.