S4E4
Tragic (with moments of defiant hope)
Written by Brian Hayles
View Graph

The Smugglers Part 4

The Doctor, Ben, and Polly arrive in 17th century Cornwall and must outwit a band of cutthroat pirates led by the ruthless Captain Pike, all while trying to prevent them from finding Avery's cursed hidden treasure.

The Doctor, along with his companions Ben and Polly, find themselves in 17th century Cornwall, embroiled in a dangerous treasure hunt. They quickly discover that the area is rife with smugglers and pirates, all searching for the legendary lost treasure of Avery. A local squire, initially involved in smuggling, is shot by the pirate Cherub, raising the stakes. Cherub, acting as the advance scout for Captain Pike, attempts to interrogate the Doctor about the location of Avery's gold but is interrupted by Pike.

Captain Pike, a ruthless pirate, arrives with his crew, seeking Avery's hidden treasure. Cherub, who deserted Pike's ship, attempts to regain favor by capturing the Doctor, but Pike, distrustful of Cherub's motives, engages him in a deadly duel in the church crypt, ending in Cherub's death. The Doctor, Ben, and Polly are caught in the middle as Pike demands the treasure's location. Ben and Polly attempt to reach the TARDIS through a secret tunnel, but Polly is ambushed by two pirates who were guarding some treasure on the beach. Ben rescues Polly.

Meanwhile, Blake, a Revenue man, arrives with a squad of militia, intent on stopping the pirates. They confront the pirates in the churchyard. A fierce fight between the militia ensues. Recognizing the danger, the Doctor bargains with Pike, promising to lead him to the gold in exchange for sparing the local villagers from the pirates' violence. He leads Pike to a flagstone in the crypt marked with significant names from Avery's past. The Doctor reveals the treasure is hidden beneath the flagstone, hoping to fulfill his bargain and protect the innocent.

As Pike retrieves the treasure, chaos erupts. Blake and his men descend through the secret passage the doctor discovered earlier. The Militia attack and begin killing of the pirates. The Squire attempts to defend The Doctor and is shot. In the tunnel Polly is attacked but is rescued by Ben and then Blake. The Doctor manages to slip away with Ben. With the pirates defeated and the treasure recovered, the Doctor, Ben, and Polly return to the TARDIS. They dematerialize as Blake mourns that he was unable to thank The Doctor for his help.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

26
Act 1

Cherub, having already shot the Squire, maintains a menacing presence in the church crypt, interrogating the Doctor, Ben, and Polly about the location of Avery's legendary gold. He holds Polly at gunpoint, escalating the threat and demonstrating his ruthless nature. The Doctor, ever resourceful, attempts to buy time by feigning ignorance and presenting a riddle involving names like Ringwood, Smallbeer, and Gurney, which Cherub surprisingly recognizes as former crew members of Avery. This exchange subtly reveals more about the treasure's history and the characters involved. The wounded Squire, propped against a pillar, interjects to warn Cherub about Avery's curse, suggesting a supernatural element to the treasure, though Cherub dismisses it as mere superstition. Meanwhile, a more formidable force arrives as Captain Pike and his pirate crew land on the beach, dragging their longboats ashore. Pike dispatches the Spaniard to find Cherub and then leads his men to the churchyard, where they uncover a stash of smuggled goods in a sarcophagus. Pike orders the goods moved to the beach, but his primary focus remains on finding Cherub and the gold. Simultaneously, Blake, the Revenue man, and his squad of militia men are seen approaching the village, setting the stage for a multi-faceted conflict. Pike's entry into the church signals the imminent confrontation between the two pirate leaders, marking a significant shift in the narrative's power dynamics and escalating the danger for the protagonists.

Act 2

The narrative intensifies as Captain Pike silently descends into the church crypt, confronting Cherub, whom he accuses of desertion. Cherub attempts to mitigate his betrayal by claiming he was working to secure the treasure for Pike, but Pike, distrustful of Cherub's "archangel's tongue," challenges him to a deadly duel. The two pirates engage in a fierce cutlass fight, displaying their brutal combat skills, as the Doctor, Ben, and Polly cautiously retreat to the periphery. During the chaos, Ben and Polly seize an opportunity to escape through a secret tunnel, with Ben intending to return for the Doctor after ensuring Polly's safety at the TARDIS. Pike, after a relentless pursuit, corners Cherub and mercilessly runs him through with his sword, solidifying his position as the dominant and most dangerous antagonist. With Cherub dead, Pike turns his attention to the Doctor, demanding the secret of Avery's gold. The Doctor, strategically playing for time and seeking to protect the innocent villagers from Pike's anticipated violence, proposes a bargain: he will lead Pike directly to the treasure if Pike agrees to keep his men out of the village. Pike, though suspicious of the Doctor's "humane" terms and his disinterest in the gold (which he attributes to Avery's curse), accepts the deal, challenging the Doctor to prove his word. Concurrently, Blake, the Revenue man, finalizes his plan, dividing his militia into two groups to execute a pincer movement, one heading for the church and the other for the secret passage, setting the stage for the inevitable clash. The Doctor then points to a specific flagstone, marked with the names of Avery's crew, indicating it as the precise location of the hidden gold, fulfilling his part of the dangerous agreement.

Act 3

Pike, initially triumphant after retrieving the pearls from beneath the flagstone, is immediately confronted by the sounds of battle as Blake's militia launch their assault on the pirates in the churchyard, catching them off guard. Simultaneously, Polly, nearing the TARDIS in the cave, is ambushed by David and the Spaniard. Ben, hearing her screams, rushes back through the tunnel and rescues her from David. Blake and his men then arrive, with Blake shooting the Spaniard, saving Ben and Polly. Blake and Ben proceed towards the crypt, while Polly returns to the TARDIS. In the crypt, Blake and his militia emerge from the secret passage, joining the fierce battle against the remaining pirates. Pike, realizing the Doctor's "trap," turns his fury on the Doctor. The Doctor attempts to aid the gravely wounded Squire. With a final act of courage, the Squire intervenes, grabbing Pike's arm, which allows Blake to fatally shoot the pirate captain. Pike dies amidst his scattered treasure. The Doctor and Ben seize the opportunity to escape through the secret passage. Blake, after securing the area and aiding the Squire, realizes the Doctor has vanished, offering a silent farewell. Reunited in the TARDIS, the Doctor, Ben, and Polly dematerialize, with the Doctor hinting at a new, cold and potentially worse destination, setting up the next adventure.