Fabula
Season 20 · Episode 23
S20E23
Hopeful
Written by Terrance Dicks
View Graph

The Five Doctors Part 1

The Doctor faces his greatest challenge as five incarnations of himself are brought together to prevent the Dark Tower from falling into the wrong hands.

The Doctor's twentieth regeneration anniversary prompts him to return, warning his future selves about impending dangers. Five incarnations of the Doctor (First, Second, Third, Fourth, and Fifth) are pulled through time to reunite in the Eye of Harmony, an ancient site tied to the Time Lords' power. They face the Dark Tower, a mysterious structure with ties to Rassilon, the founder of Time Lord civilization. As they navigate through the Death Zone on Gallifrey, they encounter Cybermen, Yeti, and other dangers. Along the way, they meet old friends and allies, including Tegan, Turlough, Sarah Jane Smith, Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, and K9. The Doctors soon discover that Borusa, the Lord President of the High Council, seeks immortality using the Ring of Rassilon. The Doctors must work together to stop Borusa and survive the traps and puzzles within the Dark Tower. Ultimately, they succeed in defeating Borusa and claim the Ring, but not for themselves. Instead, it returns to Rassilon's tomb, and Borusa is punished for his ambitions. The Doctors then return to their respective timelines, and the Fifth Doctor is unexpectedly appointed as the new President of the Time Lords, choosing to defy his new role and flee in his TARDIS.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

114
Act 1

The narrative opens with the First Doctor's poignant farewell, setting a reflective tone before shifting to the Fifth Doctor, Tegan, and Turlough enjoying a tranquil moment at the Eye of Orion. This peace shatters as a mysterious conical object begins abducting various incarnations of the Doctor across time and space. The First Doctor is taken from a garden, followed by the Second Doctor and Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart from UNIT HQ, and then the Third Doctor and Sarah Jane Smith from a country road. The Fifth Doctor experiences intense pain and memory loss, realizing his past selves are being 'whittled away.' His TARDIS becomes paralyzed, landing him, Tegan, and Turlough in the desolate Death Zone on Gallifrey. Concurrently, the Time Lord High Council, led by President Borusa, confronts an energy drain from the Eye of Harmony and reactivated Death Zone. They reluctantly recruit the Master, offering a full pardon and a new life cycle, to enter the Death Zone and rescue the Doctor, whose various regenerations have disappeared. Meanwhile, the First Doctor and his companion Susan, now in the Death Zone, evade a Dalek and spot the ominous Dark Tower. The Second Doctor and Brigadier navigate the Death Zone, encountering a Cyberman, and also set their sights on the Tower. The Third Doctor and Sarah Jane, having been scooped into the Zone, encounter the Master, who claims to be an ally but is met with the Third Doctor's deep suspicion. This act establishes the central mystery of the disappearances, the perilous setting of the Death Zone, and the initial, scattered efforts of the Doctors and their companions to understand and respond to their predicament. The Master's involvement introduces a significant element of moral ambiguity and potential betrayal, raising the stakes for the Doctors' eventual reunion.

Act 2

This act intensifies the Doctors' individual struggles and begins their convergence towards the Dark Tower, while Borusa's true machinations unfold. The First Doctor and Susan discover the Fifth Doctor's paralyzed TARDIS, where the First Doctor assumes command, planning to wait for the other Doctors. The Fifth Doctor is abruptly transmatted to the Capitol, where he confronts Borusa and the High Council. He deduces a Time Lord is responsible for the Time Scoop and the presence of Cybermen, using the Cybermen's rapid location of the Doctors and a homing beacon within the Master's recall device as evidence. Borusa, in a calculated move, frames the Castellan for treason and orders his execution, eliminating a potential threat and diverting suspicion. Borusa then reveals his ambition for immortality, forcing the Fifth Doctor to remain in the Capitol under mind control, using the Coronet of Rassilon. Meanwhile, the Master, now in the Death Zone, cunningly manipulates a Cyberman patrol into a deadly trap on the chequered floor of the Dark Tower, securing a weapon and demonstrating his self-serving nature. The First Doctor and Tegan, deducing a mathematical solution, navigate the same trap. The Second Doctor and Brigadier battle a Yeti in the Tower's lower tunnels. The Third Doctor and Sarah Jane, after Bessie's destruction, use a Raston Warrior Robot's efficiency to dispatch a Cyberman patrol before scaling the Tower's exterior. Susan and Turlough, left in the TARDIS, face an imminent threat as Cybermen plant bombs around their vessel. This act culminates with most of the Doctors and their companions having reached or entered the Dark Tower, while the Fifth Doctor is compromised by Borusa, and the TARDIS is under direct attack, raising the stakes dramatically for the final confrontation.

Act 3

The climax unfolds as the remaining Doctors and companions converge in Rassilon's Tomb. The TARDIS, with Susan and Turlough, dematerializes moments before the Cybermen's bombs detonate, then materializes safely within the Tomb. The Second Doctor and Brigadier, having navigated the Yeti-infested tunnels, arrive, with the Second Doctor discerning that apparitions of Jamie and Zoe are illusions. The Third Doctor and Sarah Jane also reach the Tomb, the Third Doctor having similarly dismissed the illusions of Yates and Liz Shaw. The First Doctor and Tegan complete their journey through the chequered corridor, joining the others. All present Doctors and companions gather, translating the ancient inscription on Rassilon's sarcophagus, which speaks of the Ring of Rassilon and the promise of immortality. The Master, having followed them, attempts to claim the Ring for himself but is swiftly knocked unconscious by the Brigadier. Borusa and the mind-controlled Fifth Doctor then arrive via transmat. Borusa freezes the companions, reveals his full plan to the Doctors, and attempts to assert his dominance. However, the combined mental strength of the First, Second, and Third Doctors breaks Borusa's control over the Fifth, allowing them to unite against him. Borusa, undeterred, confronts the spectral head of Rassilon, claiming the promised immortality. Rassilon warns him, but Borusa takes the Ring. This act of hubris triggers Rassilon's trap: Borusa is transformed into a stone face on the sarcophagus, forever trapped in eternal sleep. Rassilon then offers immortality to the other Doctors, who wisely refuse. The Fourth Doctor and Romana are freed from the time vortex and returned to their punt, and the Master is sent back to his original state, his sins to be punished. The Doctors make their farewells, each returning to their respective timelines with their companions. The resolution sees Chancellor Flavia arrive to inform the Fifth Doctor that, due to Borusa's disqualification, he is now President of the Time Lords. Defying this unwanted responsibility, the Fifth Doctor, Tegan, and Turlough immediately flee in the TARDIS, choosing to remain renegades and continuing their adventures, thus reaffirming the Doctor's core identity.