Fabula
S4E20 · The Underwater Menace Part 2

Doctor and Ramo confront Thous about Zaroff

In the Atlantean Council Chamber, the Doctor—disguised in temple garb and accompanied by Ramo—attempts to expose Professor Zaroff as a dangerous madman plotting to destroy the world by raising Atlantis. The Doctor employs a mix of flattery and psychological observation to undermine Zaroff’s credibility, claiming his obsession with the project reveals his insanity. Ramo supports the Doctor’s claims, warning Thous that Zaroff’s plan will split the world in two. However, Thous dismisses their warnings, citing Zaroff’s revered status as a prophesied deliverer and Lolem’s endorsement. The confrontation ends with Thous abruptly cutting off the discussion, leaving the Doctor and Ramo’s pleas unanswered. This failure to convince Thous escalates the urgency of the Doctor’s mission, as Zaroff’s catastrophic plan remains unchecked, and the fate of Earth hangs in the balance. The scene underscores the Doctor’s desperation and the systemic resistance to truth within Atlantean leadership, setting up the next phase of the conflict where action—not persuasion—will be required to stop Zaroff.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

The Doctor, disguised in temple robes and accompanied by Ramo, is introduced to Thous, the ruler of Atlantis. Ramo vouches for the Doctor, emphasizing the life-and-death importance of their visit.

neutral to cautious

The Doctor attempts to discredit Professor Zaroff, casting aspersions on his sanity and warning Thous that he is mad, but Thous defends Zaroff, seeing him as a 'worker of miracles'.

critical to defensive

Ramo supports the Doctor's claims, asserting that Zaroff intends to destroy Atlantis. Thous dismisses Ramo's concerns, reminding him that Lolem deemed Zaroff a prophet and rebuking him for insubordination.

urgent to skeptical

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Anxious but resolute—he knows the stakes but is constrained by his role and the weight of tradition.

Ramo, the priest of Atlantis, serves as the Doctor’s reluctant ally in this confrontation. He introduces the Doctor to Thous and lends credibility to his warnings, framing the Doctor’s presence as a matter of 'life and death.' His dialogue is measured but firm, emphasizing the catastrophic consequences of Zaroff’s plan. However, he defers to Thous’s authority, offering a cautious plea for wisdom rather than outright defiance. His posture is respectful but tense, reflecting his internal conflict between duty and urgency.

Goals in this moment
  • Persuade Thous to heed the Doctor’s warnings about Zaroff
  • Avoid outright rebellion while still advocating for action
Active beliefs
  • Zaroff’s plan will destroy Atlantis, not save it
  • Thous can be influenced by reasoned argument, even if he resists initially
Character traits
Diplomatic (frames the Doctor’s presence as necessary) Urgent (warns of Zaroff’s destructive intentions) Deferential (respects Thous’s authority despite disagreement) Cautious (avoids direct confrontation with Thous)
Follow Ramo's journey

Coldly dismissive—his skepticism is a shield against the uncomfortable truth, and his abrupt cutoff reveals his discomfort with the challenge to his worldview.

Thous, the ruler of Atlantis, presides over the Council Chamber with an air of unyielding authority. He listens to the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings with skepticism, dismissing their claims as unfounded. His defense of Zaroff is rooted in tradition and prophecy, and he shuts down the discussion abruptly, claiming he needs time to 'consider' their arguments. His body language is rigid, his tone final, signaling that the matter is closed—for now. He represents the institutional resistance to change, clinging to the status quo even as catastrophe looms.

Goals in this moment
  • Uphold Zaroff’s status as the prophesied deliverer of Atlantis
  • Maintain the stability of Atlantean leadership by rejecting disruptive claims
Active beliefs
  • Zaroff’s plan is divinely ordained and cannot be wrong
  • External warnings are either misguided or motivated by self-interest
Character traits
Skeptical (doubts the Doctor and Ramo’s claims) Traditionalist (prioritizes prophecy over evidence) Authoritative (dismisses debate with finality) Defensive (protects Zaroff’s status as the deliverer)
Follow Thous's journey

Not directly observable, but implied to be manic or unhinged based on the Doctor and Ramo’s descriptions.

Zaroff is the absent but looming figure in this confrontation, his presence felt through the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings. He is framed as a 'madman' whose obsession with raising Atlantis borders on delusion. The Doctor’s description of his 'lighting up' eyes and Ramo’s claim that his plan will 'split the world in two' paint him as a dangerous, unhinged force. Thous’s defense of Zaroff—citing his prophesied status—only amplifies the tension, as the Doctor’s accusations hang unanswered in the air.

Goals in this moment
  • Proceed with his plan to raise Atlantis, regardless of consequences
  • Maintain his status as the prophesied deliverer of Atlantis
Active beliefs
  • His scientific vision justifies any cost, including global destruction
  • He is destined to restore Atlantis, and opposition is heresy
Character traits
Obsessive (his fixation on the project is framed as pathological) Dangerous (his plan is described as apocalyptic) Revered (Thous and Lolem’s endorsement elevates his status)
Follow Zaroff's journey

Feigned calm masking deep desperation—his sarcasm and theatricality are a veneer for the growing realization that words alone won’t stop Zaroff.

The Doctor, disguised in temple garb, orchestrates a calculated psychological assault on Zaroff’s credibility. He begins with flattery to disarm Thous, then pivots to unsettling observations about Zaroff’s 'madness,' using exaggerated gestures to emphasize his point. His tone shifts from playful to urgent as he presses his case, but he is ultimately rebuffed by Thous’s dismissal. Physically, he remains composed but tense, his body language betraying his desperation as the stakes rise.

Goals in this moment
  • Convince Thous of Zaroff’s insanity to halt the apocalyptic plan
  • Undermine Zaroff’s authority by exposing his 'madness' to the Atlantean leadership
Active beliefs
  • Zaroff’s obsession with raising Atlantis is a sign of dangerous instability
  • Thous can be reasoned with if presented with undeniable evidence of Zaroff’s threat
Character traits
Manipulative (strategically uses flattery to disarm) Observant (notices Zaroff’s 'eyes' as a tell) Persuasive (attempts to sway Thous with psychological insight) Defiant (pushes back against Thous’s dismissal) Desperate (urgency in his tone as the moment slips away)
Follow The Second …'s journey
Supporting 1

Not directly observable, but implied to be fanatical and unyielding in his beliefs.

Lolem is invoked by Thous as the high priest who proclaimed Zaroff the deliverer of Atlantis. Though not physically present, his influence looms large in the chamber, as Thous cites his endorsement to justify dismissing the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings. Lolem’s superstitious authority is used as a counterargument to reason, reinforcing the systemic resistance to truth. His absence makes his power all the more potent—his words are treated as gospel, unchallengeable even in the face of impending doom.

Goals in this moment
  • Uphold Zaroff’s status as the prophesied savior of Atlantis
  • Enforce the religious doctrine that guides Atlantean leadership
Active beliefs
  • Zaroff’s rise is part of a divine plan that must be fulfilled
  • Doubt in the prophecy is heresy and must be suppressed
Character traits
Superstitious (his prophecies are treated as absolute truth) Authoritative (his endorsement of Zaroff carries weight) Absent but powerful (his influence is felt through Thous’s words)
Follow Lolem's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Doctor's Temple Brother Disguise

The Doctor’s temple garb serves as a critical disguise, allowing him to infiltrate the Council Chamber and gain an audience with Thous. Ramo justifies the Doctor’s presence by framing him as a 'temple brother,' leveraging the garb to bypass Thous’s initial skepticism about outsiders. The garment symbolizes the Doctor’s temporary assimilation into Atlantean religious hierarchy, granting him a veneer of legitimacy that he exploits to deliver his warnings. Without it, Thous would likely have dismissed him outright, highlighting the object’s narrative role in facilitating the confrontation.

Before: Worn by the Doctor as he enters the …
After: Remains on the Doctor as he exits, its …
Before: Worn by the Doctor as he enters the Council Chamber, blending him into the temple’s authority structure.
After: Remains on the Doctor as he exits, its purpose fulfilled but its effectiveness limited by Thous’s dismissal.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Atlantean Council Chamber

The Atlantean Council Chamber serves as the epicenter of power and tension in this confrontation. Its formal, imposing atmosphere amplifies the stakes, as the Doctor and Ramo plead for action against Zaroff’s apocalyptic plan. The chamber’s architecture—likely grand and hierarchical—underscores Thous’s authority, making his dismissal of their warnings feel even more final. The space is charged with unspoken hierarchies and traditions, where prophecy and science clash, and where the Doctor’s outsider status is both a liability and a potential disruptor.

Atmosphere Tense and formal, with an undercurrent of urgency. The air is thick with unspoken hierarchies …
Function Neutral ground for high-stakes negotiations, where the Doctor and Ramo attempt to challenge Zaroff’s authority …
Symbolism Represents the institutional power of Atlantean leadership and the resistance to change. The chamber’s formality …
Access Restricted to senior figures—Thous, the Brothers of the Temple, and those granted special dispensation (like …
The chamber’s grand, hierarchical design reinforces Thous’s authority. The absence of Zaroff or Lolem creates a power vacuum that the Doctor attempts to fill with his warnings. The whispered urgency of Ramo and the Doctor contrasts with Thous’s cold, dismissive tone.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
Brothers of the Temple

The Brothers of the Temple are invoked by Thous as the religious authority that sanctions his rule. Their endorsement of Lolem’s prophecy—naming Zaroff the deliverer—creates an unassailable barrier to the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings. The organization’s influence is felt through Thous’s deference to tradition, as he cites their collective belief in Zaroff’s divinely ordained role. This institutional resistance to outside perspectives underscores the systemic challenge the Doctor faces in convincing Atlantean leadership to act.

Representation Through Thous’s invocation of their authority and the weight of Lolem’s prophecy, which he treats …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over Thous, who in turn enforces their doctrine on the Council. The Doctor …
Impact Reinforces the systemic resistance to change, where prophecy and tradition are prioritized over evidence or …
Internal Dynamics The organization’s unity is unchallenged in this moment, as Thous aligns fully with Lolem’s prophecy …
Uphold Zaroff’s status as the prophesied deliverer of Atlantis Enforce the religious doctrine that guides Atlantean leadership, suppressing dissent Through Thous’s deference to Lolem’s prophecy and the Brothers’ collective endorsement By framing the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings as disruptive and heretical
Atlantean Council (Leadership Hierarchy)

The Atlantean Council, represented by Thous, embodies the institutional power that must be convinced to act against Zaroff. However, in this moment, the Council is a monolith of skepticism, clinging to Zaroff’s prophesied status and Lolem’s endorsement. The Doctor and Ramo’s pleas fall on deaf ears, as Thous—speaking for the Council—dismisses their arguments with finality. The organization’s inaction in the face of impending doom highlights its paralysis, trapped between tradition and catastrophe.

Representation Through Thous’s authority and his dismissal of the Doctor and Ramo’s warnings, which reflect the …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over the fate of Atlantis, but operating under constraints of tradition and prophecy. …
Impact The Council’s inaction sets the stage for Zaroff’s plan to proceed unchecked, forcing the Doctor …
Internal Dynamics The Council is united in its skepticism, with no internal dissent voiced in this moment. …
Maintain the status quo by upholding Zaroff’s prophesied role Avoid disruptive external influences (like the Doctor’s warnings) that challenge Atlantean doctrine Through Thous’s final word, which shuts down debate and reinforces institutional resistance By citing Lolem’s prophecy as an unassailable truth, dismissing evidence to the contrary

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2

"Doctor getting changed leads to the Doctor presenting his case, with Ramo, to Thous."

Doctor adopts Atlantean disguise for infiltration
S4E20 · The Underwater Menace Part 2

"The Doctor attempting to discredit Zaroff in front of Thous, leads to Thous defending Zaroff."

Thous dismisses the Doctor’s warning
S4E20 · The Underwater Menace Part 2
What this causes 2

"The Doctor attempting to discredit Zaroff in front of Thous, leads to Thous defending Zaroff."

Thous dismisses the Doctor’s warning
S4E20 · The Underwater Menace Part 2

"Doctor and Ramo failing to persuade Thous, all the companions are still in danger. Ara informs them they're in danger from the guards."

Ara’s fleeting alliance and forced separation
S4E20 · The Underwater Menace Part 2

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Key Dialogue

"DOCTOR: Excellency, the Professor is a wonderful man. A worker of miracles. But, have you noticed his eyes lately? When he talks of his project, have you noticed his eyes? They light up like this! The Professor is as mad as a hatter."
"RAMO: We believe Zaroff to be working toward the destruction of Atlantis, not its resurrection. Zaroff's plan will split the world in two. This is not the action of a sane man."
"THOUS: I have heard such words from you before, Ramo. But your own priests proclaimed him to be the prophet who would raise us above the sea. Lolem. He is old and superstitious. And your superior, Ramo. Remember that!"