Polly and Ben develop the solvent weapon

In the moonbase sickbay, Polly—inspired by Jamie’s earlier remark about 'sprinkling witches'—tests acetone on plastic and discovers it dissolves the material. This accidental breakthrough leads her to theorize that the solvent could weaken the Cybermen’s chest control units. Ben, initially skeptical, quickly grasps the potential and collaborates to refine the idea. Together, they identify available solvents (benzene, ether, alcohol) and brainstorm a delivery method, ultimately deciding to repurpose fire extinguishers as makeshift weapons. The scene marks a critical shift from passive observation to active resistance, transforming Polly’s scientific curiosity into a tangible countermeasure against the Cybermen’s technological dominance. Their improvisation underscores the companions’ resourcefulness and sets up the next phase of the battle, where the solvent’s effectiveness will be tested in the field.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Polly asks Ben about nail varnish remover, learning that it contains acetone. She then tests acetone on a piece of plastic, and it dissolves, leading to Polly's excited realization that acetone may be a weapon against the Cybermen.

curiosity to excitement ['sickbay']

Polly explains her idea of "sprinkling" the acetone on the Cybermen, and Ben understands that the solvent could damage their control units. Ben then suggests that they create a mixture of all available solvents to enhance its effectiveness, prompting Polly to consider how they'll deliver the mixture.

excitement to determination ['sickbay']

Polly and Ben enumerate the solvents available to them, including benzene, ether, and alcohol, to brew a cocktail. Ben then proposes using fire extinguishers as a delivery method, revealing his idea to weaponize it.

planning to resolve ['sickbay']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

Cautiously optimistic, shifting from confusion to determined excitement as the plan takes shape.

Ben stands beside Polly in the moonbase sickbay, initially puzzled by her sudden focus on nail varnish remover. His skepticism softens as Polly demonstrates the acetone’s dissolving power on plastic, and he quickly pivots to collaboration, listing available solvents (benzene, ether, alcohol) and brainstorming delivery methods. His practical naval background surfaces as he dismisses bottles in favor of fire extinguishers, his voice carrying a mix of excitement and urgency. Physically, he leans in, hands gesturing as he outlines the plan, his posture shifting from cautious observation to active participation.

Goals in this moment
  • To validate Polly’s discovery and turn it into a viable weapon against the Cybermen.
  • To ensure the delivery method (fire extinguishers) is both effective and feasible given their limited resources.
Active beliefs
  • That the Cybermen’s chest units are vulnerable to chemical corrosion, given their plastic composition.
  • That improvisation and teamwork are key to overcoming the Cybermen’s technological advantage.
Character traits
Quick-thinking Practical Collaborative Resourceful Skeptical-to-convinced
Follow Ben Jackson's journey

Energized and focused, her scientific curiosity driving her to solve the problem with creative urgency.

Polly takes the lead in the sickbay, her scientific mind racing as she tests acetone on plastic and watches it dissolve. Her initial excitement is met with Ben’s skepticism, but she persists, articulating her theory that the solvent could weaken the Cybermen’s chest units. She lists available chemicals (benzene, ether, alcohol) and debates delivery methods, her hands steady as she pours and observes. Her dialogue is rapid, ideas flowing as she adapts to Ben’s suggestions, ultimately embracing the fire extinguisher plan. The sickbay lights reflect off her determined expression, her focus unwavering.

Goals in this moment
  • To prove that acetone (and a solvent cocktail) can dissolve the Cybermen’s chest units, creating a weakness to exploit.
  • To develop a practical delivery method for the solvent, ensuring it can be used effectively in combat.
Active beliefs
  • That the Cybermen’s organic components are susceptible to chemical corrosion, given their plastic-like chest units.
  • That teamwork and quick thinking are essential to outmaneuvering the Cybermen’s technological superiority.
Character traits
Innovative Persistent Collaborative Analytical Adaptive
Follow Polly Wright's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

5
Alcohol (Component of Polly's Solvent Mixture)

The bottles collected by Polly represent the initial, discarded idea for delivering the solvent. Though Ben suggests using them to throw the mixture, he quickly dismisses this in favor of fire extinguishers. Their presence in the scene underscores the improvisational nature of the companions’ plan, as they scavenge whatever is available. The bottles symbolize the raw materials of rebellion—ordinary objects repurposed for extraordinary ends—before being superseded by a more effective solution.

Before: Scattered across the sickbay counter, filled with various …
After: Abandoned as a delivery method, now empty or …
Before: Scattered across the sickbay counter, filled with various chemicals (including acetone), untouched and unremarkable until Polly’s experiment.
After: Abandoned as a delivery method, now empty or set aside as Ben and Polly pivot to fire extinguishers for pressurized spray.
Moonbase Sickbay Fire Extinguishers (Repurposed as Solvent Weapon)

The fire extinguishers emerge as the solution to the delivery problem, proposed by Ben as a way to pressurize and spray the solvent mixture. Their red metal cylinders and hoses become the vessel for the 'Polly cocktail,' transforming safety equipment into weapons of resistance. The extinguishers’ practicality—already present in the sickbay, designed for emergencies—mirrors the companions’ own role as improvised defenders. Their repurposing marks a turning point, as the sickbay’s mundane tools are weaponized against the Cybermen’s invasion.

Before: Hanging on the sickbay wall or stored in …
After: Seized and repurposed, now filled with the solvent …
Before: Hanging on the sickbay wall or stored in a cabinet, fully charged and unused, intended for fire suppression.
After: Seized and repurposed, now filled with the solvent mixture, ready to be wielded against the Cybermen’s chest units in the upcoming battle.
Nail Varnish Remover

Acetone serves as the catalyst for the entire event, its dissolving power on plastic demonstrated by Polly as a proof-of-concept. Initially referenced as 'nail varnish remover,' it becomes the cornerstone of their weapon strategy. Ben’s confirmation that it is 'something like acetone' validates its potential, and Polly’s experiment—dropping plastic into the solvent and watching it dissolve—proves its efficacy. The object’s role evolves from a household item to a critical component in their improvised arsenal, symbolizing the shift from passive observation to active resistance.

Before: Stored in the moonbase sickbay among other chemicals, …
After: Identified as a key weapon component, now part …
Before: Stored in the moonbase sickbay among other chemicals, unlabeled or minimally labeled, its dissolving properties untested in this context.
After: Identified as a key weapon component, now part of a mixed solvent 'cocktail' intended for deployment via fire extinguishers against the Cybermen.
Polly and Ben's Benzene Solvent (Component of 'Polly Cocktail')

Benzene is one of the solvents listed by Polly as part of their improvised 'cocktail,' identified alongside ether and alcohol. Its inclusion reflects the companions’ willingness to combine volatile chemicals in a high-stakes gamble. Though not tested individually, its presence in the mixture underscores the desperation and ingenuity of their plan. The solvent’s industrial strength symbolizes the high risk of their experiment, as they prioritize effectiveness over safety in the face of the Cybermen threat.

Before: Stored in a labeled bottle in the sickbay, …
After: Mixed with acetone, ether, and alcohol into the …
Before: Stored in a labeled bottle in the sickbay, part of the moonbase’s medical or maintenance supplies, its corrosive properties known but untapped.
After: Mixed with acetone, ether, and alcohol into the 'Polly cocktail,' now a liquid weapon awaiting deployment.
Polly's Plastic Test Sample

The piece of plastic dropped into the acetone by Polly serves as the critical proof-of-concept for their weapon strategy. Its rapid dissolution demonstrates the solvent’s potential to weaken the Cybermen’s chest units, validating Polly’s theory. The object’s role is purely functional but symbolically pivotal, as it bridges the gap between scientific curiosity and tactical innovation. Its destruction in the experiment foreshadows the Cybermen’s own vulnerability, turning an ordinary lab test into a moment of narrative hope.

Before: Lying on the sickbay counter or held by …
After: Dissolved in the acetone, now a liquid residue, …
Before: Lying on the sickbay counter or held by Polly, an unremarkable piece of plastic, likely a fragment from medical packaging or equipment.
After: Dissolved in the acetone, now a liquid residue, its purpose fulfilled as evidence of the solvent’s efficacy.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2

"Polly and Ben's discussion about how to defeat the Cybermen leads to Polly testing acetone and discovering it dissolves plastic, giving them a weapon."

Jamie’s remark sparks solvent solution
S4E25 · The Moonbase Part 3

"Polly and Ben's discussion about how to defeat the Cybermen leads to Polly testing acetone and discovering it dissolves plastic, giving them a weapon."

Polly deduces Cybermen’s solvent weakness
S4E25 · The Moonbase Part 3

Key Dialogue

"POLLY: "If we can sprinkle some of that on their chest units, it might help to soften them.""
"BEN: "I get it! You mean it'll clobber their controls or something.""
"POLLY: "Yes. Wait a minute, how are we going to throw it at them?""
"BEN: "Well, in bottles, I suppose. Now just a tick though. I've got a better idea.""