Fabula
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks Part 2

Doctor and Jamie uncover the shop’s temporal anomaly

The Doctor and Jamie enter Waterfield’s antique shop under the pretense of an early appointment, immediately sensing something amiss. Jamie’s sharp observation—that all the 'Victorian' antiques are suspiciously pristine—triggers the Doctor’s analytical instincts. Their examination of a 1866 invoice and a brand-new statuette reveals an impossible contradiction: genuine artifacts that defy time’s passage. Jamie’s playful joke about a 'time machine' inadvertently foreshadows the truth, while the Doctor’s growing unease signals his recognition of unnatural forces at work. The discovery escalates when Perry (posing as Kenneth) enters, his evasive behavior and knowledge of the TARDIS raising further suspicion. The Doctor’s insistence on investigating the locked back room—where Kennedy was just murdered—sets the stage for their confrontation with the Daleks’ experiment. This moment marks the turning point where the shop’s anomalies shift from curiosity to existential threat, propelling the Doctor toward Waterfield and the 1866 portal.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

The Doctor and Jamie enter the antique shop, noting its odd collection of brand-new 'Victorian' items. Their arrival, earlier than scheduled, immediately raises questions about the shop's authenticity and purpose.

curiosity to suspicion

Jamie points out that the 'antique' items are brand new. The Doctor confirms their authenticity but notes the strangeness of their pristine condition, revealing the central anomaly that drives their investigation.

confusion to realization

Jamie correctly deduces the impossible nature of brand-new Victorian antiques and jokes about Waterfield having a time machine, which foreshadows the underlying truth. The Doctor states the need to find and question Waterfield.

confusion to determination

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Jamie is a mix of excitement and suspicion. His initial playful tone gives way to a sharper focus as the Doctor’s deductions reveal the shop’s unnatural secrets. He is clearly protective of the Doctor and eager to uncover the truth, particularly about the TARDIS’s location. There’s a hint of frustration with Perry’s evasiveness, but his Highland resolve keeps him focused on the task at hand. His emotional state is one of cautious optimism—he senses they are on the verge of a discovery, but he is also aware of the potential dangers lurking in the shop.

Jamie enters the shop alongside the Doctor, immediately noticing the unnatural pristine condition of the antiques. His playful joke about a 'time machine' foreshadows the truth, and he assists the Doctor in examining the statuette and invoice, his curiosity piqued. When Perry enters, Jamie challenges his evasive behavior, pressing him for answers about the TARDIS and the locked back room. His boldness and directness contrast with the Doctor’s more measured approach, adding a layer of urgency to the scene. Jamie’s insistence on investigating the yard gates and his readiness to act on the Doctor’s suspicions highlight his role as a proactive companion.

Goals in this moment
  • To support the Doctor in uncovering the shop’s secrets, particularly the location of the TARDIS.
  • To challenge Perry’s evasions and push for direct action, such as investigating the yard gates.
Active beliefs
  • That the shop’s antiques are connected to a temporal anomaly, possibly involving the Daleks.
  • That Perry is hiding something dangerous in the locked back room, and that they need to act quickly to uncover it.
Character traits
Curious Playful Bold Protective Direct
Follow Jamie McCrimmon's journey
Kennedy
primary

Anxious and conflicted, Perry oscillates between feigned professionalism and barely concealed panic. His internal struggle is palpable—he is clearly uncomfortable with the Doctor’s probing questions and the implications of the TARDIS’s presence, but he lacks the authority or courage to fully resist. There’s a flicker of guilt when the Doctor presses him about the locked back room, hinting at his awareness of the violence that occurred there.

Perry (posing as Kenneth) enters the shop after the Doctor and Jamie, caught off-guard by their presence. He initially feigns ignorance but is quickly exposed by the Doctor, who calls him out on his alias. Perry reveals his real name (Keith) and attempts to explain the presence of the TARDIS, but his evasive behavior—avoiding direct answers about the locked back room and the shop’s secrets—betrays his complicity. His nervous demeanor and reluctance to involve the police underscore his role as a reluctant participant in Waterfield’s scheme.

Goals in this moment
  • To deflect the Doctor and Jamie’s suspicions without revealing the full extent of Waterfield’s involvement or the Daleks’ experiment.
  • To maintain the facade of the antique shop’s legitimacy, even as the Doctor’s deductions unravel it.
Active beliefs
  • That the Doctor and Jamie are dangerously close to uncovering the truth about the shop’s temporal anomalies and Kennedy’s murder.
  • That involving the police would escalate the situation beyond his control, potentially exposing the Daleks’ operations.
Character traits
Evasive Nervous Reluctant Complicit Defensive
Follow Kennedy's journey

The Doctor’s emotional state is a mix of intellectual excitement and deepening unease. He is intrigued by the temporal puzzle but increasingly alarmed by the implications—particularly the locked back room, where he suspects foul play. His defiance toward Perry’s evasions and his insistence on investigating the TARDIS reflect his protective instincts, both for Jamie and for the integrity of time itself. There’s an undercurrent of urgency, as if he senses the Daleks’ involvement lurking just beneath the surface.

The Doctor enters the antique shop with cautious curiosity, immediately sensing that something is amiss. He silences Jamie’s chatter and examines the pristine Victorian antiques with growing unease, deducing that they are genuine yet impossibly new—a temporal anomaly. His dialogue with Jamie reveals his sharp analytical mind, as he pieces together the clues (the statuette, the 1866 invoice) and connects them to the possibility of time travel. When Perry enters, the Doctor takes control of the conversation, exposing Perry’s evasiveness and demanding access to the locked back room. His determination to investigate the TARDIS’s location and the shop’s secrets drives the scene forward, setting the stage for the confrontation with the Daleks.

Goals in this moment
  • To uncover the truth behind the shop’s temporal anomalies and the TARDIS’s concealment.
  • To protect Jamie and prevent the Daleks from exploiting the human factor for their experiments.
Active beliefs
  • That the shop’s antiques are being brought from the past through a temporal rift, likely opened by the Daleks.
  • That Perry is hiding critical information about the locked back room, where Kennedy was murdered and the TARDIS is hidden.
Character traits
Analytical Observant Authoritative Protective Defiant
Follow The Second …'s journey
Supporting 2

Kennedy’s emotional state is one of tragic finality—his death is a stark reminder of the Daleks’ ruthlessness and the stakes of the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation. While he does not physically appear, his murder looms over the scene, infusing it with a sense of urgency and danger. The Doctor’s reference to hearing someone shouting earlier in the scene hints at the violence that took place, and the locked back room becomes a symbol of the hidden horrors the Doctor and Jamie are determined to expose.

Kennedy is mentioned as the victim fatally shot by a Dalek in the antique shop’s secret room, triggering the Doctor’s investigation. His murder is the catalyst for the Doctor and Jamie’s urgency—they suspect foul play and are determined to uncover the truth. Kennedy’s absence is a looming presence in the scene, his death a silent accusation against Waterfield and the Daleks. The locked back room, where his body lies, is a physical manifestation of the violence that has taken place, and the Doctor’s insistence on investigating it reflects his determination to bring Kennedy’s killers to justice.

Goals in this moment
  • None (post-mortem), but his death drives the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation forward.
  • His murder serves as a warning of the Daleks’ capacity for violence and the need for the Doctor to act quickly.
Active beliefs
  • That the Daleks will stop at nothing to achieve their goals, including murder.
  • That his death is part of a larger conspiracy involving Waterfield and the antique shop’s temporal anomalies.
Character traits
Victimized Silent witness Catalyst for action
Follow Edward Waterfield's journey
Keith Perry
secondary

While Waterfield is not physically present, his emotional state can be inferred through the actions of Perry and the state of the shop. He is likely torn between his desperation to save his daughter Victoria and his moral outrage at the Daleks’ brutality. His absence suggests a man operating under extreme duress, possibly fearing for his life as much as for his daughter’s. The shop’s eerie atmosphere—pristine antiques, locked doors, and hidden violence—reflects his internal conflict and the unnatural forces he has unleashed.

Edward Waterfield is mentioned indirectly in this event, as the owner of the antique shop and the figure the Doctor and Jamie intend to question. His absence from the scene is palpable—his influence is felt through Perry’s evasive behavior, the locked back room, and the pristine antiques, all of which suggest his involvement in the Daleks’ temporal experiment. The Doctor’s determination to speak with Waterfield hints at his central role in the conspiracy, and the tension in the shop is a direct result of Waterfield’s complicity in the Daleks’ scheme.

Goals in this moment
  • To maintain the facade of the antique shop’s legitimacy while secretly aiding the Daleks’ experiment.
  • To protect his daughter Victoria, even at the cost of his own morality and the lives of others (e.g., Kennedy).
Active beliefs
  • That the Daleks will kill his daughter if he does not comply with their demands.
  • That the Doctor and Jamie are a threat to the Daleks’ experiment, and that he must keep them at bay to avoid escalating the situation.
Character traits
Absent but influential Manipulative Desperate Complicit
Follow Keith Perry's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

6
Doctor's TARDIS

The TARDIS (police box) is the central object of the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation. Perry mentions its presence in the locked back room, and the Doctor insists on retrieving it, revealing his ownership and the TARDIS’s critical role in the narrative. The TARDIS’s concealment in the shop is a direct result of the Daleks’ experiment, and its recovery becomes a primary goal for the Doctor and Jamie. The object’s involvement in this event is twofold: it is both a key artifact that the Doctor must reclaim and a symbol of the temporal disruption in the shop. The Doctor’s emotional attachment to the TARDIS and his determination to protect it from the Daleks’ influence drive the scene’s tension.

Before: The TARDIS is hidden in the locked back …
After: The TARDIS remains locked in the back room, …
Before: The TARDIS is hidden in the locked back room of the antique shop, inaccessible due to the electric lock. Its presence is known to Perry and Waterfield, who have concealed it as part of their collaboration with the Daleks.
After: The TARDIS remains locked in the back room, but its significance has been revealed. The Doctor and Jamie now know its location and are determined to retrieve it, setting the stage for their confrontation with the Daleks.
1866 Invoice from William Dearing and Son

The 1866 invoice from William Dearing and Son is the second key clue that confirms the temporal anomaly. The Doctor examines it alongside the pristine statuette, noting that the paper is brand new—ink fresh, edges unyellowed—despite the 1866 date. This contradiction is impossible under normal circumstances, reinforcing the Doctor’s deduction that the antiques are being brought from the past. The invoice functions as a temporal paradox: it is both a genuine historical document and a product of the present, defying the linear flow of time. Its role in the event is to underscore the unnatural forces at play in the shop and to propel the Doctor and Jamie toward the locked back room, where the source of the anomaly likely lies.

Before: The invoice is stored among the antique shop’s …
After: The invoice remains in the shop, but its …
Before: The invoice is stored among the antique shop’s artifacts, appearing as a legitimate historical document but with unnaturally fresh paper and ink. It is part of the shop’s curated collection, designed to deceive.
After: The invoice remains in the shop, but its significance has been revealed. The Doctor and Jamie’s examination of it has exposed its role in the temporal anomaly, and it now serves as evidence of the Daleks’ interference with time.
Waterfield's Antique Shop Doorbell

The antique shop’s doorbell chimes as the Doctor and Jamie enter, announcing their arrival and drawing Perry’s attention. The doorbell is a mundane object, but its role in this event is to mark the threshold between the ordinary and the extraordinary. The chime pierces the quiet shop, signaling the beginning of the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation. Its sound is a stark contrast to the eerie atmosphere of the shop, where time itself seems to be unraveling. The doorbell’s involvement serves as a narrative device, highlighting the moment when the Doctor and Jamie cross into a world of temporal anomalies and hidden dangers.

Before: The doorbell is mounted on the shop’s entrance, …
After: The doorbell remains functional, but its chime has …
Before: The doorbell is mounted on the shop’s entrance, ready to chime when the door is opened. It is a standard feature of the shop’s Victorian facade, designed to announce visitors.
After: The doorbell remains functional, but its chime has now signaled the Doctor and Jamie’s arrival, setting the investigation in motion. The sound lingers in the air, a reminder of the ordinary world they have left behind.
Waterfield's Photograph Staging Box

The box from Waterfield’s valise is mentioned indirectly in this event, as part of the staged scene involving the torn photograph of the Doctor. While the box itself is not physically interacted with during this segment, its role in the broader conspiracy is implied. The box is used to create the illusion of the Doctor’s photograph being torn and trapped, suggesting that Waterfield is manipulating evidence to mislead investigators. This object’s involvement hints at the deeper deception unfolding in the shop, where appearances are carefully constructed to obscure the truth. Its presence in the valise underscores Waterfield’s complicity in the Daleks’ scheme.

Before: The box is stored in Waterfield’s valise, containing …
After: The box remains in the valise, but its …
Before: The box is stored in Waterfield’s valise, containing the torn photograph of the Doctor. It is part of Waterfield’s staging props, designed to deceive the Doctor and Jamie.
After: The box remains in the valise, but its role in the deception has been set in motion. The torn photograph serves as a red herring, intended to misdirect the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation.
Waterfield's Pristine Victorian Statuette

The pristine Victorian statuette is the first clue that sparks the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation. Jamie notices its unnaturally new condition, despite its 1866 markings, and the Doctor confirms its genuine craftsmanship. The statuette serves as a tangible manifestation of the temporal anomaly in the shop—it is both authentic and impossibly fresh, defying the passage of time. The Doctor’s examination of the statuette alongside the 1866 invoice solidifies his deduction that the antiques are being brought from the past, likely through a Dalek-operated temporal rift. The statuette’s role is pivotal: it is the catalyst for the Doctor’s growing unease and his decision to probe deeper into the shop’s secrets.

Before: The statuette is displayed on a pedestal in …
After: The statuette remains on the pedestal, but its …
Before: The statuette is displayed on a pedestal in the antique shop, appearing pristine and new despite its 1866 provenance. It is part of the shop’s facade of Victorian authenticity, but its condition betrays the unnatural forces at work.
After: The statuette remains on the pedestal, but its significance has shifted from a decorative artifact to a critical piece of evidence. The Doctor and Jamie’s examination of it has revealed its role in the temporal anomaly, and it now serves as a symbol of the shop’s hidden truths.
Waterfield's Servant's Indicator

Waterfield’s servant’s indicator is a minor but telling object in this event. It is checked by Waterfield upon entering the shop, suggesting a routine operational protocol. The indicator’s presence hints at the shop’s dual role as both a legitimate business and a front for the Daleks’ experiment. While it is not directly interacted with by the Doctor or Jamie, its mention underscores the shop’s organized and secretive nature. The indicator serves as a subtle reminder that the shop is not what it appears to be—it is a place of hidden surveillance and controlled access, where every movement is monitored.

Before: The servant’s indicator is positioned near the shop’s …
After: The servant’s indicator remains in place, but its …
Before: The servant’s indicator is positioned near the shop’s entrance, ready for Waterfield to check upon arrival. It is part of the shop’s operational routine, designed to track staff and customer movements.
After: The servant’s indicator remains in place, but its role in the shop’s deception has been subtly reinforced. The Doctor and Jamie’s presence disrupts the usual routine, but the indicator continues to function as a tool of surveillance.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

3
Edward Waterfield's Antique Shop (Interior)

Edward Waterfield’s antique shop is the primary setting for this event, serving as both a facade of Victorian elegance and a gateway to temporal horror. The shop is filled with genuine antiques that gleam unnaturally new, defying the passage of time. The Doctor and Jamie’s investigation begins here, as they examine the pristine statuette and the 1866 invoice, uncovering the shop’s role in the Daleks’ experiment. The shop’s atmosphere is one of polished wood, faint polish scents, and the hum of hidden machinery, creating a tension between its Victorian charm and the unnatural forces at work. The locked back room looms as a symbol of the shop’s darker secrets, while the yard gates offer a potential route to bypass the electric lock. The shop’s dual role—as both a legitimate business and a front for the Daleks’ temporal manipulations—makes it a microcosm of the narrative’s central conflict.

Atmosphere The shop’s atmosphere is a mix of eerie elegance and creeping dread. The polished antiques …
Function The antique shop functions as the primary investigation site for the Doctor and Jamie. It …
Symbolism The antique shop symbolizes the fragility of history and the dangers of temporal interference. Its …
Access The shop is open to the public during business hours, but access to the back …
The scent of polished wood and faint machinery hums in the air. Dim lighting casts long shadows over the pristine antiques. The chime of the doorbell echoes through the quiet shop. The locked back room door is marked by an electric lock, its hum a subtle but ominous sound.
Waterfield’s Locked Back Room (Crime Scene)

The locked back room is a critical location in this event, serving as the physical manifestation of the shop’s hidden secrets. It is where Kennedy was murdered by the Daleks, and where the TARDIS is concealed. The Doctor and Jamie’s determination to access this room drives the scene’s tension, as Perry reveals that it is secured by an electric lock. The room’s role is to symbolize the barriers between the ordinary and the extraordinary, the known and the unknown. Its locked door and the hum of the electric lock create a sense of foreboding, hinting at the violence and temporal anomalies that lie beyond. The Doctor’s insistence on investigating the room sets the stage for their confrontation with the Daleks’ experiment.

Atmosphere The atmosphere of the locked back room is one of oppressive silence and hidden violence. …
Function The locked back room functions as a barrier and a mystery, preventing the Doctor and …
Symbolism The locked back room symbolizes the consequences of temporal interference and the violence that accompanies …
Access The back room is secured by an electric lock, which Perry describes as insurmountable. The …
The air is thick with the metallic tang of blood and the faint whir of hidden machinery. The room is dimly lit, casting long shadows over the TARDIS and Kennedy’s body. The hum of the electric lock is a constant, ominous sound. The door is marked by the lock’s modern mechanism, clashing with the Victorian decor.
Yard Behind Edward Waterfield's Antique Shop (Exterior)

The yard behind Edward Waterfield’s antique shop is mentioned as a potential route to bypass the locked back room. Perry suggests climbing the yard gates to access the TARDIS, highlighting the urgency of the Doctor and Jamie’s investigation. The yard serves as a practical solution to the obstacle posed by the electric lock, but it also adds a layer of physical challenge to their mission. The yard’s role in the event is to symbolize the Doctor and Jamie’s determination to uncover the truth, even if it requires unconventional methods. Its gated enclosure and high walls create a sense of urgency, as the Doctor and Jamie must act quickly to bypass the shop’s restrictions.

Atmosphere The yard’s atmosphere is one of tight confinement and urgency. The high gates and shadows …
Function The yard functions as an alternative access point to the locked back room, allowing the …
Symbolism The yard symbolizes the boundaries between the ordinary and the extraordinary, the known and the …
Access The yard is enclosed by high gates, which require climbing to bypass. The gates are …
The yard is enclosed by high, sturdy gates, requiring climbing to bypass. The air is still, broken only by the Doctor and Jamie’s whispered conversations. Shadows cloak the yard, creating a sense of claustrophobia and urgency. The gates are designed to keep intruders out, adding a layer of physical challenge.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Daleks

The Daleks’ influence is palpable in this event, even though they are not physically present. Their involvement is inferred through the temporal anomalies in the shop (pristine antiques, the 1866 invoice), the locked back room where Kennedy was murdered, and the TARDIS’s concealment. The Daleks’ experiment to isolate the 'human factor' is the driving force behind the shop’s unnatural state, and their ruthlessness is evident in Kennedy’s murder. The Doctor and Jamie’s investigation is a direct response to the Daleks’ interference, as they seek to uncover the truth and protect humanity from becoming pawns in the Daleks’ quest for ultimate power. The Daleks’ involvement in this event is a looming presence, shaping the actions of Perry, Waterfield, and the Doctor and Jamie.

Representation The Daleks are represented through their temporal experiment, which manifests in the shop’s pristine antiques, …
Power Dynamics The Daleks exert absolute authority over the shop and its occupants. Perry and Waterfield are …
Impact The Daleks’ involvement in this event underscores their institutional power and their willingness to exploit …
Internal Dynamics The Daleks operate with a unified, ruthless efficiency, leaving no room for internal dissent or …
To isolate the 'human factor' that allows the Doctor and Jamie to defeat the Daleks, by exploiting the temporal anomalies in the shop. To maintain control over Waterfield and Perry, ensuring their compliance with the Daleks’ experiment. Coercion of human collaborators (e.g., Waterfield and Perry) through threats and violence. Manipulation of time and space, as evidenced by the pristine antiques and the locked back room. Exploitation of human emotions, such as Waterfield’s desperation to save his daughter Victoria. Deployment of advanced technology, such as the electric lock and the TARDIS’s concealment.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1

"The Doctor and Jamie discuss the anachronistic nature of the antique shop (beat_37a2986b93e02412), with Jamie joking about a Time Machine. This foreshadows the actual time travel that is about to occur related to Waterfield (beat_9dbdf0e4adadbc5a)."

Doctor interrogates Perry about TARDIS
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …
What this causes 2

"The Doctor hears shouting and insists on investigating (beat_e6134bfdf83ed292); this action causes him to become involved in Waterfield's distress call (beat_da1c2b56732e0f26.)"

Waterfield’s cry exposes Dalek threat
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

"The Doctor and Jamie discuss the anachronistic nature of the antique shop (beat_37a2986b93e02412), with Jamie joking about a Time Machine. This foreshadows the actual time travel that is about to occur related to Waterfield (beat_9dbdf0e4adadbc5a)."

Doctor interrogates Perry about TARDIS
S4E38 · The Evil of the Daleks …

Key Dialogue

"JAMIE: All the stuff in here's brand new."
"DOCTOR: Except that all these things are not reproductions. They're all genuine."
"JAMIE: Well, that is impossible, unless Waterfield could have invented a time machine like the Tardis, Doctor, and he's bringing all this stuff back from Victorian times."
"DOCTOR: The only way to find out is to ask Waterfield."