Fabula
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part 3

Davros’s Faustian Bargain: The Price of Peace

In a dimly lit Thal war room, Davros—his voice dripping with calculated sincerity—offers the Thal Councillor a chemical formula that will weaken the Kaled dome, ensuring the Thals’ rocket can penetrate and annihilate his own people. The exchange is a masterclass in manipulation: Davros frames the genocide as a 'necessary sacrifice' for peace, while Nyder reinforces their shared goal of ending the war. The Thal Councillor, suspicious but desperate, accepts the formula, unknowingly playing into Davros’s grand design. Meanwhile, the Doctor and Harry, hidden outside, overhear the plot, realizing the stakes have escalated from war to existential annihilation. This moment is the narrative’s fulcrum—Davros’s ruthless pragmatism is laid bare, the Thals’ complicity is sealed, and the Doctor’s race against time becomes a matter of survival for both races. The scene’s tension lies not just in the dialogue but in the unspoken: the Thals’ moral compromise, Davros’s chilling detachment, and the Doctor’s dawning horror at the scale of the threat.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

The Councillor questions Davros's motive for providing the formula, noting it will lead to the extermination of his own people, the Kaleds, but Davros justifies it as a necessary sacrifice for peace and requests assistance in rebuilding the planet after the war.

suspicion to feigned hope

Davros and Nyder reinforce that their only goal is to end the conflict and Davros declares that peace could arrive by dawn.

hope to anticipation

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6

A storm of horror and urgency; he is both repulsed by Davros’s actions and galvanized by the need to act before it’s too late.

The Doctor and Harry press themselves against the cold metal wall outside the Thal war chamber, their breaths shallow and controlled as a patrol passes by. The Doctor’s eyes widen slightly as he overhears Davros’s chilling proposal, his grip tightening on Harry’s arm in a silent warning. His expression darkens with each word, the weight of the revelation settling over him like a physical burden. He exchanges a glance with Harry, a wordless acknowledgment of the stakes now at play. The Doctor’s mind races, calculating the implications of Davros’s betrayal and the limited time remaining to stop the impending genocide.

Goals in this moment
  • Gather as much intelligence as possible about Davros’s plan to sabotage the Kaled dome.
  • Devise a way to intervene before the Thals launch their rocket, even if it means risking his own life.
Active beliefs
  • Davros’s actions are not just evil but existentially dangerous, threatening the balance of time and reality itself.
  • The Thals, though enemies of the Kaleds, are being manipulated into committing an atrocity they would never otherwise consider.
Character traits
Horror-stricken Urgently analytical Protective of Harry Determined Morally outraged
Follow The Doctor's journey

Feigned sincerity masking deep-seated malice and triumph; a predator savoring the moment before the kill.

Davros dominates the Thal war chamber with a calculated performance, his voice dripping with feigned sincerity as he offers the chemical formula to the Thal Councillor. He frames the impending genocide of his own people as a 'necessary sacrifice' for peace, his body language exuding chilling detachment. His dialogue is a masterclass in manipulation, alternating between appeals to shared suffering and cold pragmatism. He leans slightly forward as Nyder hands over the formula, his eyes locked onto the Councillor, ensuring his words land with maximum impact. The dim lighting casts shadows across his face, accentuating the ruthlessness beneath his veneer of reason.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure the Thal Councillor’s acceptance of the chemical formula to ensure the Kaled dome’s destruction.
  • Frame the genocide of the Kaleds as a noble sacrifice for peace, justifying his actions to both the Thals and himself.
Active beliefs
  • The ends justify the means, especially when those ends serve his vision of a Dalek-dominated future.
  • The Thals are too desperate for victory to question his motives, making them easy to manipulate.
Character traits
Manipulative Ruthlessly pragmatic Chillingly detached Persuasive Theatrical Calculating
Follow Davros's journey

A mix of cautious optimism and gnawing doubt; he wants to believe in the promise of peace but is acutely aware of the moral cost.

The Thal Councillor engages in a tense verbal sparring match with Davros, his posture rigid with suspicion but gradually softening as Davros’s argument gains traction. He listens intently, his fingers tapping restlessly on the armrest of his chair, betraying his internal conflict. When Davros reveals the chemical formula, the Councillor’s eyes narrow, weighing the offer against his instincts. His acceptance is reluctant, his voice laced with residual doubt, but the promise of victory over the Kaleds proves too tempting. He leans back slightly as Nyder explains the formula’s effects, his grip tightening on the arms of his chair—a physical manifestation of his moral compromise.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure a decisive victory over the Kaleds to end the war and save the Thal people.
  • Avoid appearing weak or indecisive in front of Davros and Nyder, lest he lose leverage in the negotiation.
Active beliefs
  • The Kaleds are an existential threat that must be eradicated at any cost.
  • Davros’s offer is too good to be true, but he cannot afford to reject it without risking his people’s survival.
Character traits
Suspicious Desperate for victory Morally conflicted Pragmatic Authoritative but wavering
Follow Thal Councillor's journey
Supporting 3

Cold satisfaction in serving Davros’s will; he derives no personal pleasure from the deception, only a sense of duty fulfilled.

Nyder stands at Davros’s side like a loyal executioner, his presence a silent threat. He hands over the chemical formula with mechanical precision, his movements efficient and unemotional. His dialogue is concise, reinforcing Davros’s narrative without embellishment. He does not engage in the back-and-forth with the Councillor, instead serving as a physical manifestation of Davros’s authority. His posture is rigid, his gaze steady, and his voice devoid of inflection—he is the perfect enforcer, ensuring the Councillor’s compliance through sheer, unspoken intimidation.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure the Thal Councillor accepts the chemical formula without further hesitation.
  • Reinforce Davros’s authority and the inevitability of his plan through his own unwavering presence.
Active beliefs
  • Davros’s vision for the future is non-negotiable, and any means to achieve it are justified.
  • The Thals are a means to an end; their cooperation is temporary and contingent on their usefulness.
Character traits
Loyal to a fault Ruthless Disciplined Intimidating Unemotional
Follow Nyder's journey

Focused and professional; he is a soldier carrying out his duties, unaware of the moral weight of the decisions being made in the room behind him.

A Thal soldier patrols the corridor outside the war chamber with mechanical precision, his boots echoing against the metal floor. He passes within inches of the Doctor and Harry, forcing them to press themselves flat against the wall, their breaths held. The soldier’s gaze is sharp, his hand resting on his weapon, but he does not notice the intruders. His focus is on the perimeter, his mind likely on the impending rocket launch and the promise of victory it represents. He continues his patrol, oblivious to the drama unfolding just beyond the chamber door.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain security around the war chamber to prevent any unauthorized access or eavesdropping.
  • Ensure the Thal Councillor’s negotiations proceed without interruption.
Active beliefs
  • His role is to follow orders and protect the Thal leadership, regardless of the moral implications of their actions.
  • The Kaleds are the enemy, and any means to defeat them is justified.
Character traits
Disciplined Vigilant Oblivious to the larger deception Routine-driven
Follow Thal War …'s journey

A mix of adrenaline-fueled fear and steely determination; he is terrified of what Davros is planning but refuses to let it paralyze him.

Harry Sullivan mirrors the Doctor’s tension, his body coiled like a spring as he listens to the exchange inside the war chamber. His jaw is set, his knuckles white where they grip the wall for support. He glances at the Doctor repeatedly, seeking reassurance or guidance, but remains silent, understanding the gravity of the moment. When the patrol passes, he freezes, his breath catching in his throat, before exhaling slowly as the danger subsides. His eyes reflect a mix of fear and resolve—he knows the stakes, and he is ready to follow the Doctor’s lead, no matter the cost.

Goals in this moment
  • Stay hidden and ensure the Doctor can gather the intelligence they need without being discovered.
  • Be ready to act on the Doctor’s signal, whatever that may entail.
Active beliefs
  • The Doctor’s instincts are always right, and he trusts him implicitly to find a way out of this.
  • Davros’s plan must be stopped at all costs, even if it means putting their lives on the line.
Character traits
Tense Alert Loyal Fearful but resolute Supportive
Follow Harry Sullivan's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Kaled City Protective Dome

The Kaled dome is the primary target of Davros’s genocidal scheme, and its fate is the central focus of the negotiation in the Thal war chamber. Though not physically present, the dome looms large in the dialogue, its invulnerability initially dismissed by the Thal Councillor as a myth. Davros systematically undermines this confidence by introducing the chemical formula, which he claims will weaken the dome’s molecular structure, making it brittle and susceptible to the Thals’ rocket. The dome is framed as both a symbol of Kaled resilience and a barrier that must be destroyed at any cost. Its destruction is not just a tactical objective but the cornerstone of Davros’s plan to ensure the Kaleds’ annihilation, paving the way for his Daleks to inherit Skaro. The dome’s vulnerability becomes a bargaining chip, its fate hinging on the Thal Councillor’s acceptance of Davros’s offer.

Before: The Kaled dome stands intact, its advanced shielding …
After: The dome’s fate is now tied to the …
Before: The Kaled dome stands intact, its advanced shielding rendering it impervious to conventional Thal attacks. It serves as the last line of defense for the Kaled people, sheltering them from the ravages of the war. The dome is a symbol of their scientific prowess and their determination to survive, despite the odds.
After: The dome’s fate is now tied to the chemical formula’s efficacy. If the Thal Councillor accepts Davros’s offer, the dome will be fatally compromised, its molecular structure weakened to the point of brittleness. Its destruction is no longer a question of 'if' but 'when,' as the Thals prepare to launch their rocket with the knowledge that it will now penetrate without resistance. The dome’s status shifts from an impenetrable fortress to a ticking time bomb, its doom sealed by the Thal Councillor’s complicity.
Thal Genocidal Rocket

The Thals’ genocidal rocket is the silent, looming threat that hangs over the entire exchange in the war chamber. Though not physically present in the room, its existence is the unspoken catalyst for Davros’s manipulation. The rocket is described as 'primed and ready,' its countdown poised to begin immediately—a ticking clock that amplifies the urgency of the Thal Councillor’s decision. Davros’s chemical formula is explicitly tied to the rocket’s success, framing it as the key to penetrating the Kaled dome and ensuring the rocket’s destructive payload reaches its target. The rocket symbolizes the Thals’ desperation and their willingness to embrace any means to achieve victory, no matter how morally reprehensible. Its impending launch is the ultimate expression of the war’s escalation, a weapon that will not just end the conflict but erase the Kaleds from existence.

Before: Primed and ready for launch, its countdown paused …
After: The rocket remains in a state of readiness, …
Before: Primed and ready for launch, its countdown paused pending the Thal Councillor’s final approval. The rocket is fully fueled and armed, its destructive payload intact, and its targeting systems locked onto the Kaled dome.
After: The rocket remains in a state of readiness, but its launch is now contingent on the Thal Councillor’s acceptance of Davros’s chemical formula. The countdown has not yet begun, but the rocket’s role as the instrument of annihilation is cemented in the Thal leadership’s plans. The formula’s integration into the Thals’ artillery shells is the next critical step, tying the rocket’s fate directly to Davros’s deception.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Thal War Camp Negotiation Chamber (Antechamber to Davros's Meeting)

The Thal war chamber is the epicenter of Davros’s manipulation, a dimly lit, tension-filled space where the fate of Skaro is decided. The room is designed to intimidate and control, its stark lighting casting long shadows that accentuate the moral ambiguity of the negotiations taking place. The Thal Councillor sits in a position of authority, but the power dynamics are subtly shifted by Davros’s presence, who dominates the conversation with his chilling rhetoric. The chamber’s acoustics ensure that every word is heard clearly, amplifying the weight of Davros’s lies and the Thal Councillor’s moral compromise. Outside the chamber, the Doctor and Harry press themselves against the cold metal wall, their presence a silent counterpoint to the deception unfolding within. The war chamber is not just a physical space but a crucible of moral failure, where desperation and manipulation collide to produce a plan for annihilation.

Atmosphere Tension-filled with whispered conversations and the weight of unspoken moral compromises. The air is thick …
Function Meeting point for secret negotiations and strategic planning, where the fate of the Kaleds is …
Symbolism Represents the erosion of moral boundaries in the pursuit of victory, where desperation justifies any …
Access Restricted to senior Thal officials and trusted allies; heavily guarded to prevent unauthorized access or …
Dim, flickering lighting that casts long shadows across the faces of the negotiators, accentuating their moral ambiguity. The faint hum of machinery and the distant echo of boots on metal, creating a sense of urgency and paranoia. A cold, sterile environment with minimal furnishings, reinforcing the Thals’ militaristic culture and the high stakes of the negotiation. The presence of a patrol outside the door, ensuring security but also symbolizing the Thals’ disciplined but unwitting role in Davros’s plan.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
Kaled People (Entire Population of Skaro)

The Kaleds are the unwitting victims of Davros’s genocidal scheme, their fate decided in the Thal war chamber without their knowledge or consent. Though not physically present in the event, the Kaleds loom large as the target of Davros’s manipulation and the Thals’ impending attack. The Kaled dome, their last line of defense, is the focus of the negotiation, its destruction framed as a necessary step to achieve peace. The Kaleds’ role in this event is passive, their agency stripped away by Davros’s betrayal and the Thals’ complicity. The organization’s power dynamics are entirely reactive, as they are unaware of the plot unfolding against them and unable to defend themselves against the impending attack. Their influence mechanisms are limited to their scientific and military prowess, which Davros seeks to undermine through the chemical formula.

Representation Through the Kaled dome, which serves as a symbolic representation of the Kaleds’ resilience and …
Power Dynamics Operating under the constraint of Davros’s betrayal and the Thals’ impending attack. The Kaleds are …
Impact The Kaleds’ fate is hinged on the success or failure of the Doctor’s mission to …
Internal Dynamics The Kaled leadership is divided between those who follow Davros blindly and those who, like …
Survive the impending Thal attack and protect the Kaled dome from penetration. Uncover Davros’s betrayal and prevent the launch of the Thals’ rocket before it is too late. Their scientific and military prowess, which Davros seeks to neutralize through the chemical formula. The Doctor’s intervention, which serves as their only hope of averting the impending genocide. The Kaled Council’s potential to heed warnings from the Doctor and Harry, though their arrogance and inaction thus far have made them vulnerable to Davros’s schemes.
Thal Military Faction

The Thals are represented in this event through the Thal Councillor and the patrolling soldier, both of whom embody the organization’s desperation and moral compromise. The Thal Councillor’s acceptance of Davros’s chemical formula is a pivotal moment in the Thals’ involvement, as it demonstrates their willingness to embrace any means to achieve victory, no matter how morally reprehensible. The Thals’ role in this event is that of unwitting accomplices in Davros’s genocidal plan, their desperation blinding them to the true consequences of their actions. The organization’s power dynamics are shaped by their need for survival, which Davros exploits to secure their compliance. The Thals’ influence mechanisms in this event include their military might, their willingness to follow the Councillor’s lead, and their desperation to end the war at any cost.

Representation Through the Thal Councillor, who acts as the formal spokesman for the Thal leadership, and …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over their own people but operating under the constraint of Davros’s manipulation. The …
Impact The Thals’ acceptance of Davros’s formula marks a point of no return in their moral …
Internal Dynamics The Thal leadership is united in its desire for victory, but there is an unspoken …
Secure a decisive victory over the Kaleds to end the war and ensure the survival of the Thal people. Accept Davros’s chemical formula as a means to penetrate the Kaled dome, despite the moral implications of the Kaleds’ annihilation. Military might and the threat of the genocidal rocket, which serves as both a weapon and a bargaining chip. The Councillor’s authority and the Thals’ willingness to follow his lead, even in the face of moral ambiguity. Desperation as a driving force, making the Thals vulnerable to Davros’s manipulation and willing to embrace any means to achieve victory.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Causal

"Davros attempts to persuade the Thal councillor of the value of peace but is rejected, so he instead changes his strategy to use the Thals in his plan."

Davros’s Poisoned Peace: The Thal Gambit Unfolds
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …
Causal

"Davros attempts to persuade the Thal councillor of the value of peace but is rejected, so he instead changes his strategy to use the Thals in his plan."

Davros’ Poisoned Peace Offering: The Chemical Gambit
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …
What this causes 4
Causal

"Davros attempts to persuade the Thal councillor of the value of peace but is rejected, so he instead changes his strategy to use the Thals in his plan."

Davros’s Poisoned Peace: The Thal Gambit Unfolds
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …
Causal

"Davros attempts to persuade the Thal councillor of the value of peace but is rejected, so he instead changes his strategy to use the Thals in his plan."

Davros’ Poisoned Peace Offering: The Chemical Gambit
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …
Causal

"The Thal Councillor wonders why Davros would doom his own people, so Davros responds that it's a sacrifice for peace which leads to them discussing and confirming their destructive agenda furthering ultimately lead to the Thal Councillor ordering the launch of the chemical barrage."

Davros's Genocidal Gambit: The Doctor and Harry Race Against Time to Warn the Kaleds
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …
Causal

"The Thal Councillor wonders why Davros would doom his own people, so Davros responds that it's a sacrifice for peace which leads to them discussing and confirming their destructive agenda furthering ultimately lead to the Thal Councillor ordering the launch of the chemical barrage."

The Doctor’s Desperate Deception: Seizing the Thal Suits
S12E13 · Genesis of the Daleks Part …

Key Dialogue

"**DAVROS**: *Words such as patriotism and nationalism. My concern is only for peace, an end to this carnage that has virtually destroyed both our races.*"
"**COUNCILLOR**: *Why aren't you telling this to your own government and people?*"
"**DAVROS**: *I have tried. Time and again, I have tried. But now they will be satisfied with nothing other than total annihilation of the Thal people.* **COUNCILLOR**: *Then they deserve to perish, and perish they will when we launch our rocket. It's primed and ready. The countdown for firing can begin immediately.* **DAVROS**: *And it will fail.* **COUNCILLOR**: *It can't fail.* **DAVROS**: *The Kaled dome cannot be penetrated. Your great rocket will hardly scratch it.*"
"**NYDER**: *It is a simple chemical formula. If the substance is loaded into artillery shells and fired onto the surface of the Kaled dome, it will weaken the molecular structure and make it brittle. Your rocket will then be able to penetrate without resistance.* **COUNCILLOR**: *Why are you giving us this information? You know that your own people, the Kaleds, will be utterly exterminated.* **DAVROS**: *No price is too great to pay for peace. I only ask that when the war is over I be allowed to help in the reconstruction of our planet.*"