Fabula
S2E17 · Samaritan Snare

Surgeon's Refusal — Call for Outside Specialist

Captain Picard's condition collapses on the table as diagnostics cascade into failure: metabilation and heterocyclic responses are gone and capillary integrity is too unpredictable for a safe resection. The operating surgeon admits bluntly he is not qualified to attempt the only viable, exceptionally risky procedure. This confession is a turning point — professional humility and raw time pressure force the crew to concede their limits. The biomolecular physiologist immediately contacts an outside specialist, summoning external aid and raising the emotional and logistical stakes for everyone—particularly as Geordi's abduction makes every minute more urgent.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Picard fades on the table, skin ashen, while the SURGEON and BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST crowd in and the fight for his life slips away.

urgency to dread

The BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST fires rapid diagnostic checks—“Metabilation?” “Heterocyclics?”—and the SURGEON answers bleakly: systems failing, capillary integrity too unstable for a resect.

uncertainty to grim clarity

Pressed to attempt a resect, the SURGEON refuses and admits they are not qualified, stripping the room of a viable in-house option.

pressure to limitation

The BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST pivots to a solution, declares they know someone qualified, and slaps the communications panel to summon help.

desperation to decisive action

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Urgent, determined and professionally calm — anxiety channeled into immediate corrective action rather than panic.

Circulating diagnostic questions, calling out critical checks, and when the team's limits are exposed, immediately identifies external expertise and physically engages the wall communications panel to summon that resource.

Goals in this moment
  • Confirm failing diagnostics and gather accurate clinical information
  • Secure the specialized skill set required by contacting an outside specialist
Active beliefs
  • Believes the current surgical team lacks the required specialization to safely attempt the risky resection
  • Believes rapid external consultation or intervention can change the patient's outcome
Character traits
Clinically focused Decisive under pressure Practical problem-solver
Follow Biomolecular Physiologist's journey

Absent from the room but narratively positioned as the potential calm in the storm — a remote locus of competence the team now urgently depends upon.

Referenced offstage — not physically present but invoked by the biomolecular physiologist as the single person with the requisite skill to attempt the high-risk procedure; functions as the emergent hope and procedural possibility.

Goals in this moment
  • Be contacted and briefed so they can evaluate the feasibility of the risky procedure
  • Provide specialized intervention or guidance to salvage the patient
Active beliefs
  • Believes specialized knowledge can overcome otherwise untreatable physiological failure
  • Believes that being summoned implies consent to rapidly engage a high-risk intervention if possible
Character traits
Specialized authority (implied) Rare expertise
Follow Unidentified Outside …'s journey

Physically debilitated and vulnerable; implicitly isolated despite nearby care—his condition imposes emotional pressure on others rather than expressing his own active fear.

Laid out on the operating table, Picard is the failing patient whose pallid, ashen face and lack of measurable metabolic responses make him the immediate focus and the emotional center of the room's crisis.

Goals in this moment
  • Survive the immediate metabolic collapse
  • Trust the medical team to act decisively and preserve his life
Active beliefs
  • Believes medical professionals will determine and enact the proper course
  • Believes that his condition must be handled discreetly to avoid wider alarm
Character traits
Stoic even while vulnerable Passive (unable to contribute) Gravitas present in physical fragility
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Starbase 515 Surgical Suite Communications Panel

The wall‑mounted surgical communications panel is physically activated by the biomolecular physiologist at the exact moment team competence is shown to be insufficient. Its role is functional (initiating a link to an outside specialist) and dramatic (signaling escalation from internal triage to external dependency). The panel is the mechanism by which hope and logistical complication enter the scene.

Before: Idle and recessed in the surgical suite wall, …
After: Engaged—pressed by the biomolecular physiologist to initiate contact, …
Before: Idle and recessed in the surgical suite wall, with sterile smudges and faint glove marks; inactive.
After: Engaged—pressed by the biomolecular physiologist to initiate contact, emitting clinical tones and linking the team to an outside specialist.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 2
Causal

"The biomolecular physiologist calls for outside help; Pulaski arrives and performs the life-saving intervention."

Pulaski Stakes Her Claim
S2E17 · Samaritan Snare
Causal

"The biomolecular physiologist calls for outside help; Pulaski arrives and performs the life-saving intervention."

Pulaski Protects the Captain's Image
S2E17 · Samaritan Snare

Key Dialogue

"BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST: Metabilation?"
"SURGEON: Negative."
"BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST: You're unwilling to make the attempt??"
"SURGEON: I'm not qualified."
"BIOMOLECULAR PHYSIOLOGIST: I know someone who is."