Beverly Initiates Medical Evaluation Amid Growing Concern over Picard
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Beverly commits to ordering medical and psychiatric evaluations to determine the captain's capacity, urging Riker as second-in-command to support this initiative.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Neutral and analytical, focused on factual evidence and procedural correctness.
Data contributes a calm, logical voice emphasizing that current concerns are speculative and insufficient to justify mutiny or drastic action. He stresses that Picard has not endangered the ship, advocating for restraint and rational assessment.
- • Prevent premature or unjustified command disruption
- • Encourage decisions based on objective evidence
- • No concrete evidence exists that Picard endangers the Enterprise
- • Speculation is insufficient grounds for mutiny or command relief
Concerned and cautious, holding back alarm while wrestling with the uneasy possibility of a command crisis.
Riker hosts and moderates the confidential meeting with a composed yet cautious demeanor. He challenges Troi’s empathic concerns with pragmatic reasoning and frames the difficult procedural realities of relieving Picard. Throughout, he balances concern for Picard's condition with his duty to the ship and crew.
- • Assess the validity of concerns about Picard's fitness to command
- • Maintain ship stability and crew loyalty amid potential upheaval
- • Relieving Picard is a grave and complex step requiring consensus and evidence
- • Picard’s recent unusual behavior might be temporary or misunderstood
Troubled and resolute, committed to safeguarding the captain’s health and the ship’s safety despite personal conflict.
Beverly Crusher enters troubled by her recent conversation with Picard, expressing deep medical unease. She advocates for comprehensive medical and psychiatric evaluations, emphasizing the need for documented evidence and Riker’s support to validate intervention measures.
- • Initiate medical and psychiatric assessments of Captain Picard
- • Secure Riker’s backing to legitimize any intervention
- • Picard’s condition could endanger the ship if not addressed
- • Medical evidence is required to justify relieving the captain
Hesitant and worried, burdened by the responsibility of sharing intangible yet alarming impressions.
Troi hesitantly voices her empathic impressions about Picard’s emotional withdrawal and possible danger, struggling to articulate a vague but unsettling psychic sense that parts of his mind are closed off, signaling a potential psychological shift.
- • Communicate empathic concerns about Picard’s mental state
- • Alert command to potential psychological risks despite limited concrete evidence
- • Picard is emotionally closing himself off in a way that endangers the crew
- • Empathic insights, though uncertain, must inform command decisions
Concerned but pragmatic, aware of both the gravity and the complications involved in intervening in command.
Geordi La Forge supports the concern regarding the captain’s unusual behavior, pragmatically emphasizing the serious implications of potentially relieving Picard of command and the difficulties inherent in such a decision.
- • Support appropriate medical evaluation of Picard
- • Highlight procedural challenges of command relief
- • Picard’s unusual behavior might pose a danger
- • Intervention is fraught with risk if evidence is insufficient
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Medical Log is referenced as a crucial piece of evidence Beverly Crusher would require to justify any medical incapacity claim. It symbolizes the need for documented proof to support intervention, marking the tension between medical ethics and command protocol.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
Riker’s quarters function as the secure and confidential setting where senior officers candidly confront their doubts about Captain Picard’s mental fitness. The intimate space fosters serious, tension-laden discourse away from public scrutiny, embodying the weight of loyalty clashing with duty.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"The confidential meeting in Riker's quarters discussing Picard’s dangerous mental closure (beat_fe3036013c07cdc6) parallels the medical and psychiatric evaluation planning (beat_aa318ab636bdd866), both exploring themes of trust, loyalty, and the limits of command."
"The confidential meeting in Riker's quarters discussing Picard’s dangerous mental closure (beat_fe3036013c07cdc6) parallels the medical and psychiatric evaluation planning (beat_aa318ab636bdd866), both exploring themes of trust, loyalty, and the limits of command."
Key Dialogue
"BEVERLY: Sorry. I was just so troubled by my talk with the captain. Something seems wrong... terribly wrong."
"TROI: I just feel the captain's become ... perhaps dangerous."
"RIKER: Only if all command officers agreed it vital to do so. But he's not showing overt unusual behavior."
"BEVERLY: Commander, as second in command, it's still in your corner. I'll order medical and psychiatric exams... You'll have to back me up somehow."