Worf's Silence, Data's Misstep
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Worf stands frozen before the viewport, a solitary monument to cultural grief, his silence and stillness radiating alienation; Geordi and Data observe him with analytical concern, their dialogue framing his withdrawal as a solvable problem rather than a sacred wound.
Data bluntly confronts Worf’s silence, interpreting isolation as a behavioral anomaly needing correction; Worf erupts in a furious, culturally charged dismissal—'BE GONE!'—shattering Data’s clinical detachment and forcing him to recognize the depth of his misunderstanding.
Data retreats, stunned into methodical observation, while Geordi delivers a sardonic punchline—'Seeing is believing, huh?'—turning Worf’s raw rejection into dark comedy that underscores the crew’s growing awareness: some wounds resist data, logic, and good intentions.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Neutral and detached; functions as a social prop rather than an emotional participant.
Graham appears briefly as Kyle's acquaintance, exchanges a polite goodbye handshake, and exits, providing social texture and allowing Kyle and Pulaski privacy.
- • To acknowledge Kyle and continue on his way without becoming involved.
- • To sustain the illusion of normal shipboard social life around an unfolding private moment.
- • This encounter is casual and not my business.
- • Polite exit maintains social harmony.
Compassionate and amused on surface; purposeful and probing underneath—willing to unsettle Kyle to elicit truth.
Pulaski engages Kyle at the bar with candor and teasing, cutting through his self-presentation to name his loneliness and his relationship with Will while offering both critique and consolation.
- • To draw honest assessment from Kyle about his feelings and motives toward Will.
- • To puncture Kyle's polished exterior so others (and Kyle) see the man beneath the reputation.
- • Honest confrontation is a kinder path than flattery.
- • Emotional truth will help reconcile personal and professional tensions between father and son.
Mildly vulnerable beneath a practiced stoicism; proud but softened by memory and an awareness of past mistakes.
Kyle exchanges pleasantries and then enters a more vulnerable, nostalgic exchange with Pulaski, admitting what might have been and reflecting briefly on his place in Will's life.
- • To test whether Pulaski's assessment is true and to position himself as more sympathetic than his reputation suggests.
- • To gauge the possibility of reconciliation with Will and to justify his life choices to an old acquaintance.
- • His reputation precedes him and must be managed, but it doesn't tell the whole story.
- • Personal history and duty can coexist; revealing vulnerability sometimes invites connection.
Sincerely concerned and excited by an opportunity for behavioral study; surprised but composed when rebuffed.
Data approaches Worf with formal politeness and offers an observational diagnosis and social prescription—arguing that Worf is lonely and could be helped by friends—then withdraws when Worf's Klingon fury forces him away.
- • To assess Worf's social withdrawal and propose a human-centered remedy.
- • To collect observable data that could be used to relieve a crewmate's anxiety.
- • Social withdrawal is a remediable problem if addressed with the right interventions.
- • Logical observation and gentle prodding are valuable ways to help others integrate socially.
Deeply grieving and inward-focused; anger surfaces as a protective mechanism to preserve the sanctity of his ritual mourning.
Worf stands isolated at the large viewport in silent mourning, refusing initial engagement; when Data persists he wheels around and issues a thunderous Klingon command ordering Data to leave, defending his ritual solitude.
- • To maintain solitude and the integrity of his private ritual mourning.
- • To repel well-meaning intrusions that would secularize or trivialize Klingon grief.
- • Klingon grief and ritual must be observed in isolation and cannot be translated into Starfleet social remedies.
- • Allowing outsiders to 'fix' my state is an affront to my honor and cultural practice.
Worried about a crewmate but reluctant to overstep; uses humor to mask real concern.
Geordi watches Worf with a mix of concern and casual levity, exchanges a pragmatic aside with Data, and withdraws after Worf lashes out—preferring to observe rather than force the issue.
- • To support Worf indirectly while avoiding cultural missteps.
- • To keep the situation from escalating into a public spectacle or breach of Worf's dignity.
- • Some interventions do more harm than good if they ignore cultural context.
- • It's appropriate to let those close to the problem (like Wesley) handle sensitive matters where possible.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Ten-Forward bar serves as the physical anchor for the Pulaski–Kyle exchange; its counter provides Pulaski and Kyle a semi-public stage where candid personal history is traded amid routine social bustle, highlighting intimacy inside a public venue.
A nearby dark-polished table sits cleared in the background as Geordi and Data find a vantage point; it functions as an observational platform enabling them to watch Worf discreetly without interrupting, reinforcing the divide between spectators and the mourner.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
Ten-Forward functions as the social amphitheater where private and cultural ruptures become publicly visible: it houses Pulaski's probing conversation and Worf's ritual solitude at the viewport, compressing personal reckonings into a communal space that cannot fully accommodate Klingon grief.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
No narrative connections mapped yet
This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"PULASKI: "Kyle... I don't need to hear what you don't need to say.""
"DATA: "You seem to have lost the will to communicate with others.""
"WORF: "Sir... with all due respect... BE GONE!""