Fabula
S1E11 · Hide and Q
S1E11
· Hide and Q

Data Unveils the Lifeless Child Beneath the Rubble

In the devastated corridors of Quadra Sigma III, the Away Team, led by Data's clinical precision, discovers a small group of survivors trapped by the disaster. Geordi’s urgent detection of a faint presence beneath rubble leads Data to expose the limp, lifeless body of a child. Beverly's grave medical assessment extinguishes any hope of revival, casting a heavy pall over the team. This heart-wrenching reveal crystallizes the profound human cost of the catastrophe, forcing Riker to confront the limits of even 'Q’s godlike power and the immutable reality of loss, deepening the emotional stakes and underscoring the tragic fragility of life amid cosmic turmoil.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Geordi spots a figure trapped beneath rubble, prompting Data to swiftly clear debris and reveal the limp body of a dead child, crushing the team’s hope.

alertness to grief

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Solemn and composed, masking underlying recognition of loss's gravity.

Data leads the Away Reserve Team with clinical precision, using his tricorder to scan the damaged corridor, physically tearing off the jammed door, swiftly clearing rubble, and lifting the dead child's body with solemn strength, embodying calm focus amid tragedy.

Goals in this moment
  • Locate survivors beyond obstruction
  • Assess and aid any living victims
Active beliefs
  • Every life is precious and worth saving
  • Even godlike power cannot always undo tragedy
Character traits
focused methodical stoic compassionate beneath the surface
Follow Data's journey

Distressed and conflicted, wrestling between hope and acceptance of loss.

Commander Riker questions the survivors about others, then confronts the devastating death of the child with visible emotional struggle, ultimately refusing Beverly’s implicit plea to alter fate, standing firm despite the temptation of Q’s power.

Goals in this moment
  • Ascertain survivors’ status
  • Protect crew’s humanity against godlike interference
Active beliefs
  • Some realities are immutable
  • Power should not override natural order
Character traits
conflicted loyal resilient morally grounded
Follow William Riker's journey

Grave sadness mingled with professional resignation and urgency.

Beverly kneels beside the injured survivor, offering comfort, then quickly but gravely examines the lifeless child, her medical expertise confirming the death and conveying profound sorrow and professional frustration.

Goals in this moment
  • Triage and comfort survivors
  • Determine the possibility of rescuing or reviving others
Active beliefs
  • Medical skill can save lives but has limits
  • The living require immediate care and hope
Character traits
compassionate precise resolute grief-stricken
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

Urgent and focused, motivated by responsibility to save lives.

Geordi stands alert, scanning the disaster area with urgency, detecting a faint presence beneath rubble, and promptly alerting Riker and the team to the hidden survivor, driving the rescue action forward.

Goals in this moment
  • Detect any survivors hidden by debris
  • Inform and coordinate team response swiftly
Active beliefs
  • Every sign of life must be pursued
  • Team coordination is vital for rescue success
Character traits
vigilant alert responsive pragmatic
Follow Geordi La …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
Medical Tricorder

Data uses the Starfleet Tricorder to methodically scan the disaster-ravaged passageway for survivors and environmental hazards, enabling tactical movement and victim location during the rescue operation.

Before: In Data's possession, fully functional and scanning the …
After: Remains in Data's possession, continuously used for environmental …
Before: In Data's possession, fully functional and scanning the environment.
After: Remains in Data's possession, continuously used for environmental and survivor assessment.
Jammed Door to Auxiliary Control Room

The jammed door obstructs access to survivors, representing a physical and symbolic barrier. Data forcibly removes it to clear the way for rescue efforts, marking a transition from obstruction to hope amid devastation.

Before: Jammed and firmly obstructing the passageway.
After: Removed from hinges and cleared, allowing passage for …
Before: Jammed and firmly obstructing the passageway.
After: Removed from hinges and cleared, allowing passage for the team and survivors.
Flood-Damaged Rocks and Rubble

A pile of flood-damaged rocks and rubble conceals the presence of a trapped child. Data rapidly displaces this debris to reveal the harsh reality beneath, symbolizing the physical and emotional obstacles the team confronts in rescue.

Before: Blocking the corridor, hiding the child beneath.
After: Moved aside, clearing the path and exposing the …
Before: Blocking the corridor, hiding the child beneath.
After: Moved aside, clearing the path and exposing the child.
Lifeless Child's Body Amidst Rubble on Quadrant Sigma III

The limp, lifeless body of a child is uncovered beneath rubble, its death confirmed by Beverly. This tragic object embodies the event's emotional core, the crushing cost of disaster and the limits of intervention.

Before: Concealed beneath rubble, lifeless but undiscovered.
After: Held by Data, examined by Beverly, acknowledged as …
Before: Concealed beneath rubble, lifeless but undiscovered.
After: Held by Data, examined by Beverly, acknowledged as beyond saving.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Flooded Passageway Beneath Farpoint Station

The underground passageway beneath Farpoint Station serves as the grim stage for the rescue attempt, its devastated state filled with ankle-deep water, debris, and structural damage amplifying the peril and sorrow faced by the Away Team.

Atmosphere Oppressively bleak and soaked with despair, echoing loss and urgency.
Function Critical battleground and refuge where survivors are sought and tragedy is confronted.
Symbolism Represents the crushing weight of catastrophe and the fragile boundary between life and death.
Access Accessible only to rescue personnel equipped for hazardous disaster zones.
Ankle-deep water pooling on the floor Water spraying intermittently from damaged ceiling Damaged walls and debris scattered throughout Dim, precarious lighting accentuating ruin and danger

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 6
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Riker’s Trial: The Burden and Humility of Omnipotence
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Riker’s Omnipotent Trial: Gifts, Temptation, and the Human Soul
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Riker’s Godlike Gifts Expose Crew’s True Selves and Teach Humility
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Riker’s Humbling Trial of Power and Humanity
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Picard Ends Q’s Cosmic Gambit, Restores Humanity's Soul
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Thematic Parallel

"The tragedy of the dead child contrasts with Riker's later refusal to use Q power to reverse death or grant gifts, exploring themes of human limitations and accepting reality."

Riker's Trial of Power and the Restoration of Humanity
S1E11 · Hide and Q

Key Dialogue

"DATA: This way."
"GEORDI: Commander!"
"BEVERLY: She's dead. If we'd only gotten here a little sooner... !"
"BEVERLY: I don't understand. Can you bring her back to life?"
"RIKER: (long beat) No!"