Fabula
S2E16 · Q Who?
S2E16
· Q Who?

Q's Taunt — The Ship Outmatched

As photon torpedoes flash uselessly against the Borg, the bridge watches helplessly while Engineering reports the ship at maximum warp. Q suddenly appears and delivers a cold, incurable verdict: the Borg will pursue until the Enterprise is exhausted and then it will belong to them. His gloating reframes the crisis as not merely tactical failure but a moral reckoning, ratcheting the stakes and forcing Picard toward a desperate choice in the next act.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Q appears at Science One, his sudden presence shattering the crew’s focus as he coldly predicts their annihilation—no fuel, no shields, no survival.

tension to existential dread

Q’s taunt—'You're out of your league, Picard. You should have stayed where you belonged.'—slashes through Picard’s command dignity, reducing starfleet resolve to reckless ambition.

resignation to humiliation

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Humiliated and pressured on the surface; privately grave, calculating options while forced to maintain command composure.

Picard shifts his attention between Q and the viewscreen, absorbing the tactical report and Q's taunt; his posture registers the squeeze of responsibility and humiliation while he conceals the immediate trauma from the crew.

Goals in this moment
  • Protect the ship and crew by finding an operational response.
  • Maintain command authority and composure in front of the crew despite personal insult.
Active beliefs
  • The safety of the Enterprise and crew is primary.
  • Q's interference is manipulative and must not derail command decisions.
Character traits
dignified stoic authoritative internally conflicted
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Controlled alarm—professionally restrained but clearly concerned about the tactical situation.

As tactical/security officer, Worf reports the torpedoes had no effect and informs command that the Borg ship is still gaining, delivering blunt, urgent battlefield data that sharpens the bridge's alarm.

Goals in this moment
  • Provide clear, actionable tactical information to command.
  • Prompt immediate defensive or evasive measures to protect the ship.
Active beliefs
  • The Borg are a real and immediate tactical threat.
  • Clear, unvarnished reporting is necessary to enable command decisions.
Character traits
disciplined direct procedural alert
Follow Worf's journey
Q
primary

Amused and contemptuous—takes obvious pleasure in humiliating Picard and framing the crisis as a moral test.

Reveals himself at Science One, abandoning any pretense of duty; delivers a cold, theatrical pronouncement that the Borg will pursue until the Enterprise is exhausted, then gloatingly demeans Picard's competence and place.

Goals in this moment
  • Humiliate and unseat Picard psychologically.
  • Reframe the technical crisis as a moral/verdict-driven lesson about limits and hubris.
Active beliefs
  • Human command is fragile and deserving of correction.
  • Demonstration and theatrical judgment are effective pedagogical tools.
Character traits
cruel smug theatrical omniscient
Follow Q's journey

Anxious and stunned—fear undercuts routine discipline, but they remain ready to follow orders.

The bridge crew collectively lock onto the main viewer, reacting with stunned silence and visible anxiety as torpedoes fail and the Borg continues closing; they hold posture and await instruction.

Goals in this moment
  • Support bridge command and execute orders as given.
  • Maintain operational readiness and monitor systems for changes.
Active beliefs
  • Their effectiveness depends on Picard's decisions and the ship's systems.
  • The Borg threat is existential and must be treated with utmost seriousness.
Character traits
professional tense cohesive vigilant
Follow Unnamed Bridge …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Enterprise Bridge Main Viewer

The main viewer displays the incoming torpedoes and their ensuing explosion, then the continuing image of the Borg vessel closing distance. It functions as the bridge's information focus, making the tactical failure visible and amplifying the crew's helplessness while Q delivers his verdict.

Before: Active and showing tactical targeting data as photon …
After: Shows the torpedo explosion and the Borg ship …
Before: Active and showing tactical targeting data as photon torpedoes head toward the Borg vessel.
After: Shows the torpedo explosion and the Borg ship still gaining, casting cold diagnostic light across the bridge and underscoring the futility of the attack.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Main Bridge

Science One, the aft science station on the main bridge, is the point of the reveal when the crewman turns and is recognized as Q. It serves as both a technical console and the stage for Q's theatrical interruption, collapsing routine science duty into personal judgment.

Atmosphere Tight, clinical, and humming with instrumentation until the reveal; shifts to taut, unnerving theater as …
Function Reveal point and technical observation post; a fulcrum where data-driven instruments meet theatrical moral pronouncement.
Symbolism Represents the collision of empirical evidence and capricious power—technology's authority undermined by Q's judgment.
Access Operated by bridge science personnel; typically restricted to bridge crew and senior officers.
LCARS displays in amber and blue framing the console. A steady processor hum and the swivel of a seated crewman.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"WORF: "They had no effect.""
"GEORDI COM VOICE: "Bridge, this is Engineering. We are at warp nine point six five.""
"Q: "They will follow this ship until you exhaust your fuel. They will wear down your defenses. Then you will be theirs.""