Star Trek The Next Generation
S2E17
· Samaritan Snare

Grebnedlog's Demand — Geordi's Quiet Compliance

On the Mondor bridge Grebnedlog flips between cloying praise and blunt menace, training a phaser on Geordi and ordering him to "make us strong." Geordi masks fear with a wry, private smile and outwardly offers to work on a guidance system, deliberately playing along. The moment is a tactical pivot: outward compliance conceals Riker's reliance on deception rather than force and heightens urgency—Picard's precarious surgery and Pulaski's alarm make every second of this charade vital to the ship's fate.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Grebnedlog pivots toward Geordi, anointing him "smart" and elevating his value. Geordi parries with dry bite, reminding them he’s still their captive.

appraisal to sardonic resignation

Grebnedlog presses for power with a blunt command: "Make us strong." Geordi attempts a tactical redirect, steering them back to fixing the guidance system instead of arming them.

pressure to tactical deflection

Grebnedlog raises Geordi’s phaser and delivers a hard ultimatum—"Make us strong. Or die." The standoff spikes from bargaining to mortal threat.

negotiation to lethal coercion

Geordi swallows the threat, masks a mischievous spark, and yields—choosing outward compliance as cover for a smarter play.

fear to covert resolve

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

1
Geordi La Forge
Chief Engineer
 primary

Calm, feigned compliance masking tension and strategic calculation; anxious under threat but intentionally controlled and mildly sardonic inwardly.

Geordi verbally placates his captor while suppressing a mischievous smile, offering to work on a guidance system and outwardly submitting to demands to avoid violence and buy time.

Goals in this moment
  • • Survive the immediate threat without provoking violence.
  • • Buy time for his crewmates and the ship by stalling and appearing cooperative.
  • • Preserve access to systems or knowledge that can later be sabotaged or used to the Enterprise's advantage.
  • • Conceal his real intentions beneath an outwardly helpful demeanour.
Active beliefs
  • • The captors underestimate him and can be misled by flattery and technical offers.
  • • Open resistance will endanger him and the Enterprise more than temporary compliance.
  • • He can influence the situation through deception rather than force.
  • • Every second he delays increases the chance that others (Riker, security, or medical operations aboard Enterprise) can resolve parallel crises.
Character traits
wry resourceful measured deceptively compliant
Follow Geordi La …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Geordi La Forge's Phaser

A compact phaser — identified as Geordi's small handheld emitter — is used as the immediate instrument of coercion: it is leveled at Geordi by Grebnedlog to enforce compliance and underscore the lethal consequences of disobedience. The device transforms a verbal demand into a physical, life‑or‑death leverage point, making Geordi's compliance tactical rather than voluntary.

Before: In Geordi's possession at the bridge, ready and …
After: Leveled by Grebnedlog and effectively under the captor's …
Before: In Geordi's possession at the bridge, ready and operable on stun/kill settings.
After: Leveled by Grebnedlog and effectively under the captor's control as a coercive threat against Geordi.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Mondor Bridge

The Mondor bridge functions as a claustrophobic arena for this hostage exchange: its mismatched consoles, cramped layout, and harsh lighting concentrate attention on the captor and captive, amplifying menace and limiting escape or support. The bridge's physical and aesthetic limitations make it ideal for the Pakleds' crude intimidation tactics and for Geordi's ploy to delay and misdirect.

Atmosphere Tense and threatening, edged with uneasy, forced civility — small talk layered over immediate danger.
Function Stage for a hostage coercion and a pressured technical negotiation; battleground where psychological control is …
Symbolism Represents inverted command: a ship's bridge, normally a center of order, becomes a trap and …
Access Effectively controlled by the captors in the moment; confined space prevents easy intervention by outsiders.
Cramped, utilitarian consoles and jury-rigged panels. Harsh overhead lighting throwing stark shadows. A forward viewscreen framing the Enterprise and reinforcing the captives' isolation.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph

Key Dialogue

"GREBNEDLOG: You are smart."
"GREBNEDLOG: Make us strong."
"GREBNEDLOG: Make us strong. Or die."
"GEORDI: I thought you wanted me to help you... "go". Why don't we work on that guidance system, okay?"