Fabula
S1E10 · The Battle
S1E10
· The Battle

Picard Details the Ingenious 'Picard Maneuver' to Outsmart the Enemy

In a tense conference room debriefing, Captain Picard recounts the desperate circumstances that led to the creation of the 'Picard Maneuver' — a clever tactical improvisation where he exploited warp speed to create the illusion of his starship simultaneously occupying two positions, deceiving the enemy into firing at empty space. This explanation reveals Picard's quick strategic thinking under pressure and emotional vulnerability as he revisits a traumatic moment from his past, highlighting the loss of the Stargazer and setting the stage for the crew's imminent attempt to reclaim it from the Ferengi. The scene deepens the stakes by blending past trauma with present urgency, underscoring Picard’s leadership and foreshadowing the coming confrontation.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Picard describes the improvised 'Picard Maneuver' that deceived the enemy by appearing in two places simultaneously before delivering a decisive attack.

desperation to tactical ingenuity

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Haunted by painful memories yet steeled with resolve to face new challenges.

Captain Picard recounts the desperate battle and tactical improvisation known as the Picard Maneuver with a mix of reflective vulnerability and resolute determination. He reveals both his strategic brilliance and the emotional scars from the loss of the Stargazer, bridging past trauma with present resolve.

Goals in this moment
  • Explain the origin and execution of the Picard Maneuver to the crew
  • Motivate and prepare the Enterprise team for the impending attempt to reclaim the Stargazer
Active beliefs
  • Strategic ingenuity can overcome dire situations
  • The crew must understand the stakes and history to act effectively
Character traits
reflective vulnerable determined strategic
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Detached yet focused, emphasizing facts over emotion to aid decision-making.

Data provides logical confirmation of the Picard Maneuver's tactical brilliance and updates the crew on the Ferengi's readiness to claim the Stargazer, underscoring the urgency of the situation with precise information.

Goals in this moment
  • Validate Picard's tactical explanation to reinforce crew understanding
  • Inform crew of Ferengi's anticipatory stance to frame operational urgency
Active beliefs
  • Accurate information is essential for effective command decisions
  • The Ferengi pose a clear and imminent threat
Character traits
logical informative calm objective
Follow Data's journey

Cautiously optimistic with undercurrents of concern, balancing professional duty with empathy for Picard's vulnerability.

Commander Riker leads the debrief with attentive curiosity, prompting Captain Picard with questions that elicit critical tactical and emotional revelations about the Stargazer battle. He maintains calm command presence while processing the gravity of Picard's story and preparing for the pending recovery operation.

Goals in this moment
  • Clarify the circumstances of the Stargazer attack to understand the tactical situation
  • Support Picard emotionally and operationally in preparation for reclaiming the Stargazer
Active beliefs
  • Understanding past events is critical to mission success
  • Picard's leadership and insight are vital assets for the crew
Character traits
curious attentive supportive analytical
Follow William Riker's journey

Concerned but composed, vigilant for signs of Picard's distress or crew health issues.

Doctor Beverly Crusher listens attentively during the debrief, embodying a steady, supportive presence, ready to provide medical and emotional assistance as the crew confronts the psychological weight of the past battle and the looming threat.

Goals in this moment
  • Monitor crew's emotional and physical wellbeing during tense briefings
  • Prepare for potential medical needs arising from renewed conflict
Active beliefs
  • Crew health is foundational for mission success
  • Emotional trauma can manifest as medical concerns and must be addressed
Character traits
supportive professional compassionate attentive
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

Gently curious and concerned, attentive to Picard's emotional state and the story's implications.

Counselor Troi interjects with curiosity about 'Vigo,' seeking clarity that bridges Picard's past and present, reflecting her role as the crew's empathic guide and psychological anchor.

Goals in this moment
  • Clarify identity and role of 'Vigo' to better understand Picard's references
  • Support Picard by showing engagement and emotional attunement
Active beliefs
  • Understanding emotional context aids crew cohesion
  • The past trauma impacts current mission dynamics
Character traits
curious empathetic supportive inquisitive
Follow Deanna Troi's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Enterprise Defensive Shields

Enterprise shields are referenced as the first line of defense damaged during the initial Ferengi attack, framing the tactical pressure that necessitated the Picard Maneuver. Their failure underscores the vulnerability of the Stargazer and heightens the dramatic stakes during the recounting.

Before: Active and engaged during the initial attack on …
After: Compromised after sustaining damage from the Ferengi assault.
Before: Active and engaged during the initial attack on the Stargazer.
After: Compromised after sustaining damage from the Ferengi assault.
USS Stargazer Bridge Plaque

The Stargazer functions as the central object of conflict and trauma in this event. Picard’s recounting centers on the ship’s destruction and the tactical ingenuity required to survive its final battle, making the Stargazer a potent symbol of loss, resilience, and the impetus for the crew's urgent plans to reclaim it from the Ferengi.

Before: Derelict, adrift near the Maxia Zeta star system, …
After: Remains derelict; poised for Enterprise crew's attempted recovery …
Before: Derelict, adrift near the Maxia Zeta star system, controlled or contested by the Ferengi.
After: Remains derelict; poised for Enterprise crew's attempted recovery following safety confirmation.
Starfleet Shuttlecraft

The shuttlecraft is mentioned as the escape vessel that carried Picard and surviving crew after the Stargazer was critically damaged and abandoned, symbolizing vulnerability and survival. It highlights the grim aftermath and endurance amid hostile space conditions.

Before: In possession of the Stargazer crew, docked and …
After: Used to limp through space for weeks until …
Before: In possession of the Stargazer crew, docked and ready for emergency evacuation.
After: Used to limp through space for weeks until rescue.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

3
Deep Moon Crater

The deep moon crater is identified as the concealed ambush site used by the attacking starship, anchoring the tactical explanation. It symbolizes stealth, danger, and the unexpected nature of the assault that initiated the battle.

Atmosphere Dark, shadowed, and menacing, evoking covert threat.
Function Strategic hiding place for the enemy vessel at the moment of attack.
Symbolism Represents hidden dangers and the element of surprise in warfare.
Rugged lunar terrain providing natural camouflage Echoes of sudden, violent emergence during the attack
Xendi Sabu Star System

The Maxia Zeta star system is referenced as the battleground where the Stargazer was ambushed, its shadowy void representing both a physical location and a psychological scar for Picard. The system’s mention grounds the tactical discussion in space while evoking the trauma of past loss.

Atmosphere Cold, foreboding expanse evoked through narrative description.
Function Setting of the historic and traumatic battle central to the story.
Symbolism Embodies past trauma and the crucible of Picard’s leadership.
Vast, dark star system with dangerous, concealed ambush points Hostile environment marked by silence and sudden violence
Conference Room (USS Enterprise-D)

The Enterprise Conference Room serves as the formal and tense setting where the crew assembles to debrief on the Stargazer ambush. It acts as a crucible for sharing tactical knowledge, confronting past trauma, and strategizing future actions, encapsulating institutional command and personal vulnerability.

Atmosphere Tension-filled with focused, serious dialogue underscored by emotional undercurrents.
Function Meeting place for critical information exchange and strategic planning.
Symbolism Represents institutional power and the weight of command responsibility.
Access Restricted to senior officers and key personnel.
Sterile, high-tech chamber with subdued lighting Quiet except for deliberate, measured speech Presence of tactical displays and seating arranged for discussion

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 1
Thematic Parallel

"Picard’s recounting of the Battle of Maxia and the 'Picard Maneuver' parallels his current struggle to overcome mental manipulation by using decisive action to reclaim command."

Picard Breaks Mental Shackles and Reclaims Command
S1E10 · The Battle

Key Dialogue

"PICARD: We were traveling at warp two through the Maxia Zeta star system when an unidentified starship suddenly appeared and fired on us! From close range."
"DATA: ... you performed what Starfleet textbooks now call "The Picard Maneuver.""
"PICARD: I dropped into high warp... then stopped right off the target vessel's bow... and fired everything I had."