Stubbs' Ultimatum — Picard Holds the Line
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Stubbs interrupts the briefing, masking desperation with casual arrogance as he demands mission updates.
Stubbs weaponizes the two-century experiment window against Picard's safety priorities, escalating their ideological clash.
Troi attempts emotional intervention before Stubbs brutally rejects her empathy, revealing his psychological fractures.
Worf's incoming call breaks the standoff, forcing narrative momentum toward impending crisis decisions.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Desperate and defensive — his bravado masks fear of loss and resentment at any attempt to restrain him.
Bursting into the meeting, he deploys charm as a veneer over brittle desperation; insists that missing the experiment would foreclose a two-century opportunity and uses Starfleet accountability to pressure Picard. When counseled, he answers with anger and guarded self-justification.
- • Convince command to proceed with the experiment despite risks.
- • Protect his reputation and secure the scientific legacy tied to the experiment.
- • This scientific opportunity is an almost sacred, once-in-many-lifetimes event that justifies extreme risk.
- • Starfleet and Picard will ultimately be judged by whether they allow discovery to proceed.
Calmly resolute with an undercurrent of concern — prioritizing duty while holding back frustration at Stubbs' recklessness.
Commands the meeting with measured firmness, refuses to allow mission prestige to override crew safety, verbally rebukes Stubbs and reframes the choice as one between discovery and survival.
- • Protect the lives of crew and maintain ship safety.
- • Prevent command from being forced into a reckless, politically dangerous experiment.
- • Command responsibility overrides individual scientific ambition.
- • Risking the ship for one experiment is unacceptable and indefensible before Starfleet and crew.
Detachedly confident — presents facts to stabilize the discussion and counter alarmist interpretations.
Provides clinical technical context: asserts that the system is designed to self-correct and that starship-wide computer failures are historically rare, attempting to reduce panic and frame the problem analytically.
- • Clarify the technical reality of the computer's condition to inform command decisions.
- • Reduce emotional escalation by providing objective grounding.
- • Systems are engineered with redundancies that make catastrophic failure unlikely.
- • Rational, evidence-based discourse will lead to better decisions than emotional appeals.
Urgent and focused — operating as the bridge between developing crisis and command, insisting on immediate attention.
Interrupts the ethical standoff via a terse com — his voice functions as an external, operational reminder that something immediate requires command attention, cutting the debate short.
- • Alert command to an operational development requiring immediate action.
- • Refocus senior staff from theoretical debate to immediate ship procedures.
- • Operational facts supersede philosophical debate when crew safety or ship functioning is at stake.
- • Clear, immediate communication to command is his responsibility.
Uneasy and conflicted — respects both the scientific stakes and Picard's duty, but visibly unsettled by the prospect of failure.
Present and receptive to the argument; expresses skepticism and discomfort at the situation, acting as an interlocutor who acknowledges the difficulty of accepting that the computer might fail.
- • Support the captain's decision-making process.
- • Help translate technical and moral concerns into practical options for command.
- • A senior officer must balance operational risk against mission goals.
- • The crew will look to command for a safe, defensible choice under pressure.
Compassionate and unsettled — sincere in her attempt to reach Stubbs but surprised and wounded by his rejection of her insight.
Enters concerned, attempts to mediate and soothe Stubbs by appealing to his feelings and the human cost of the decision; visibly taken aback when Stubbs answers angrily and dismissively.
- • Soften Stubbs and open him to alternatives that preserve life and dignity.
- • Help command understand the personal stakes and emotional context of Stubbs' obsession.
- • Emotional attunement can defuse conflict and reveal motives.
- • Understanding a person’s feelings can change their choices and reduce harm.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
Stubbs' experimental 'egg' functions as the implied object of contention — the scientific prize whose once-in-two-centuries timetable Stubbs invokes to pressure Picard. Even if not physically described in the lounge, the experiment's existence frames the moral stakes and motivates Stubbs' desperate rhetoric.
The USS Enterprise main computer is the subject of the briefing: its potential breakdown initiates the debate. Officers argue over risk decisions with the computer malfunction as the technical fulcrum that determines whether the experiment proceeds or the ship withdraws.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The double-star system is invoked verbally by Picard as the imminent external hazard that gives the decision its life-or-death weight — the star 'exploding' frames the time pressure and physical consequence if command allows the experiment to proceed.
The Observation Lounge functions as the enclosed senior-staff forum where moral, technical, and personal stakes collide. Its privacy allows blunt exchanges; the room contains Picard, Riker, Data, Troi and the intrusive presence of Stubbs — an intimate arena for accountability and confrontation.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
No narrative connections mapped yet
This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"STUBBS: Captain, if we miss our chance now we don't get another for two centuries. There will be many questions asked by Starfleet if the Enterprise fails in its duty..."
"PICARD: Nevertheless, my first and foremost concern will be to insure the safety of this ship and its crew..."
"STUBBS: My dear Counselor, no insult intended but please turn off your beam into my soul. I will share the feelings I wish to share..."