Fabula
S3E14 · A Matter of Perspective

Holodeck Deposition: The First Meeting Recreated

On the holodeck Picard, Krag and the others watch a forensically precise recreation of Riker's first meeting with Dr. Apgar. Riker delivers a flat, procedural deposition—insisting he is not a murderer—while holograms of Apgar, Tayna and a very seductive Manua enact the charged encounter. Subtext crackles: Apgar's defensiveness, Manua's obvious interest, and Riker's professional restraint. The sequence functions as a setup: it establishes competing versions of events, exposes interpersonal tension, and primes the audience for the later damning telemetry reconstruction Krag will produce.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Picard and Krag enter the meticulously recreated Tanugan laboratory, setting the stage for Riker's deposition.

neutral to anticipation ['space station laboratory']

Riker delivers a formal declaration of innocence and initiates his holographic deposition with clinical precision.

neutral to defensive

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

8

Calm and impressed; quietly calculating how to leverage the simulated sequence for jurisdictional leverage.

Krag enters with Picard, studies the holodeck deposition with a composed, poker-faced demeanor, and registers visible approval at the fidelity of the reconstruction while withholding judgment for evidentiary use.

Goals in this moment
  • Collect reproducible evidence to support Tanugan charges
  • Assess whether the simulation corroborates witness testimony
  • Preserve legal advantage by freezing decisive reconstruction points
Active beliefs
  • Technical reconstructions are decisive in adjudicating disputed sequence of events
  • Objective telemetry and reenactments will trump emotional testimony
  • Jurisdictional claims must be backed by demonstrable proof
Character traits
analytical procedural reserved methodical
Follow Krag's journey

Playful, bored and confident; she enjoys unsettling her husband and exercising social power over guests.

Manua's hologram enters like a theatrical disruptor: overtly seductive, bored with Apgar's defensiveness, she flirts with Riker, takes his arm and leads him to another room — creating a sexually charged beat that complicates motive and perception.

Goals in this moment
  • Charm and distract Riker
  • Belittle or embarrass Apgar in front of visitors
  • Exert social influence to shape how the meeting is remembered
Active beliefs
  • Her sexual charm is an effective social tool
  • Appling public embarrassment can assert moral control over Apgar
  • Riker's composure indicates he is unaffected by flirtation
Character traits
flirtatious bold socially adept provocative
Follow Manua Apgar's journey

Irritable and guarded; feels pressure from external oversight and embarrassment from his wife's behavior.

Apgar's hologram 'comes to life' as an older, brusque scientist: impatient, defensive, and mildly hostile to the early arrival of Starfleet officers while insisting the meeting proceed on his terms.

Goals in this moment
  • Control the meeting's pace and tone
  • Deflect pressure concerning his research setbacks
  • Protect his professional autonomy from Starfleet intervention
Active beliefs
  • External assessment threatens his ownership of the work
  • He must downplay setbacks or risk interference
  • His wife's social behavior undermines his credibility
Character traits
prickly proud impatient defensive
Follow Nel Apgar's journey

Businesslike and slightly anxious; intent on ensuring data access and following Apgar's direction.

Tayna's hologram performs the role of helpful assistant: she leads Geordi to the condenser array, explains the Lambda Field generator's logistical constraint, and offers access to experimental records in a deferential, professional tone.

Goals in this moment
  • Provide accurate technical information to La Forge
  • Facilitate a smooth inspection of experimental hardware
  • Support Apgar while obeying visiting officers' requests
Active beliefs
  • Transparency with data will satisfy visiting officers
  • Following Apgar's instructions preserves her position
  • Technical specifications (like the five-thousand-kilometer limit) are central to dispute resolution
Character traits
deferential competent compliant technical
Follow Tayna's journey

Calm, approving outwardly; quietly focused and mildly protective of Riker while committed to an impartial investigation.

Picard steps to the center of the holodeck recreation, nods approval, prompts Riker to speak, and watches the deposition with judicial attention — simultaneously evaluating evidence and protecting his first officer.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure the deposition runs cleanly and follows Starfleet procedure
  • Observe the simulation for factual inconsistencies that will defend Riker
  • Maintain command credibility while negotiating with Krag
Active beliefs
  • Due process and objective reconstruction are the best paths to truth
  • Riker deserves the benefit of procedural protections
  • Holodeck reconstructions can reveal actionable discrepancies
Character traits
authoritative measured procedural protective
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Defensive and composed on the surface; inwardly uncomfortable and anxious about implications but determined to stick to duty-bound truth.

Riker initiates and narrates the deposition program in a deliberately flat, businesslike voice: he states he is not a murderer and frames his visit as official Starfleet duty, remaining restrained even as Manua's flirtation embarrasses him.

Goals in this moment
  • Assert and preserve his innocence
  • Frame his presence as official evaluation of the converter
  • Avoid appearing personally involved with Apgar or Manua
Active beliefs
  • He acted properly and according to Starfleet protocol
  • A clear, unemotional statement will best protect him
  • Technical facts will vindicate his account
Character traits
professional restrained defensive straightforward
Follow William Riker's journey

Curious and clinically engaged; focused on correlating physical evidence with the timeline Riker provides.

Geordi's hologram materializes and follows Tayna to inspect the condenser array and experimental readouts, listening to technical exposition and silently cataloging the laboratory's capabilities and constraints.

Goals in this moment
  • Verify the experimental setup and telemetry possibilities
  • Collect technical details that might explain the accident
  • Support Riker by assessing Apgar's claims
Active beliefs
  • Instrument readouts will reveal causal mechanisms
  • Precise technical details are essential to prove or disprove culpability
  • His examination can help vindicate the Enterprise crew
Character traits
technical observant focused loyal
Follow Geordi La …'s journey

Clinical and impersonal; no emotion, strictly functional.

The Shipboard Computer responds to Riker's command, loading and running the deposition program and animating holographic participants; it behaves as the unemotional conductor of the reconstruction.

Goals in this moment
  • Execute the commanded holodeck deposition faithfully
  • Present data and holographic reenactment without bias
  • Preserve logs and telemetry for later review
Active beliefs
  • Program inputs define output fidelity
  • Objective playback assists investigative processes
  • All actions must be logged and repeatable
Character traits
precise procedural neutral reliable
Follow USS Enterprise's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

5
Apgar Lab Converter Reactor

The medium-sized power reactor occupies a corner of the simulated lab and functions as environmental context — suggesting the power requirements for Apgar's apparatus and framing the meeting's technical stakes.

Before: Simulated in place, emitting a low hum as …
After: Remains simulated and unchanged at the end of …
Before: Simulated in place, emitting a low hum as part of the holodeck environment.
After: Remains simulated and unchanged at the end of the deposition segment.
Apgar's Lambda Field Generator (Krieger Wave Converter)

Apgar's Lambda Field generator is referenced explicitly by Tayna to explain experimental constraints (notably the five-thousand-kilometer collimation requirement), anchoring the technical narrative and undermining simplistic motive or accidental-weapon theories.

Before: Represented holographically or verbally as the central piece …
After: Remains a referenced element in the simulation and …
Before: Represented holographically or verbally as the central piece of research, not physically present on the station (noted as located on the planet in the simulation).
After: Remains a referenced element in the simulation and in the investigators' mental model; its status unchanged but its logistics noted as evidentiary.
Field Coils (Experimental Magnetic Coil Array)

The compact field coils are visible in the holodeck lab as part of the condenser array; they serve as tactile, visual anchors for the reconstruction and technical exposition, drawing Geordi and Tayna to inspect experiment hardware details that feed the investigation.

Before: Present as holographic renderings within the holodeck simulation, …
After: Unchanged; remain part of the simulated array available …
Before: Present as holographic renderings within the holodeck simulation, visually intact and quietly humming.
After: Unchanged; remain part of the simulated array available for further diagnostic playback.
Holodeck Laboratory Computer Consoles and Readouts

Holodeck laboratory consoles and readouts are instrumental: they host the deposition program, display telemetry and records, and permit participants to 'freeze' or replay segments — functioning as the literal interface between memory, evidence, and adjudication.

Before: Initially inactive in the holodeck set before Riker's …
After: Remain active with the deposition data available for …
Before: Initially inactive in the holodeck set before Riker's command; then engaged to run the deposition.
After: Remain active with the deposition data available for further inspection and playback.
Laboratory Energy Refractors

The refractors form part of the background energy-focusing array in the simulated lab, providing environmental credibility to the reconstruction and helping illustrate where energy was directed during Apgar's experiments.

Before: Rendered as background hardware in the holodeck reconstruction, …
After: Still rendered; unchanged and available for supplemental playback …
Before: Rendered as background hardware in the holodeck reconstruction, dormant but visually active.
After: Still rendered; unchanged and available for supplemental playback or freeze-frames.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Tanugan Lab (holodeck forensic reconstruction)

The Tanugan laboratory is recreated inside the holodeck as the setting for the deposition: clinical benches, banks of consoles, humming condensers and a medium reactor are rendered to produce a faithful forensic stage where interpersonal dynamics and technical data intersect.

Atmosphere Clinical and tension-filled: fluorescent glare, low mechanical hums, and an undercurrent of social awkwardness create …
Function Stage for evidentiary reenactment and cross-examination; a neutralized 'crime scene' where testimony can be replayed …
Symbolism Represents contested truth — where private intimacy (Manua) and public science (Apgar's work) collide; the …
Access Presented as a restricted research environment in the narrative; simulation still limits access to those …
Large array of energy-focusing condensers and field coils that quietly hum Holistic glow from lab readouts and a medium-sized reactor providing low ambient sound Harsh fluorescent lighting lending an antiseptic, exposed feeling Consoles and readouts displaying experimental data and the deposition timeline

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 1
Thematic Parallel medium

"Manua's dramatic entrance in Riker's deposition contrasts with her supportive role in Apgar's simulation, both exploring how perspective changes truth."

Holographic Intimacy: Manua Consoles Apgar
S3E14 · A Matter of Perspective

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Key Dialogue

"PICARD: Is there anything you'd like to say before we begin, Number One?"
"RIKER: Just this. I'm not a murderer. I went to the Tanugan lab as an official representative of Starfleet. ... Computer. Load deposition program, Riker One."
"MANUA: Don't be in such a hurry, dear..."