Fabula
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye

Picard’s Final Farewell to McNary Amid Collapsing Reality

As the Dixon Hill Holodeck simulation deteriorates violently, Captain Picard commands Data and Beverly to evacuate the critically wounded Whalen to Sickbay, choosing to stay behind for a final, poignant goodbye with Lieutenant McNary. Their farewell—woven with deep mutual respect and unspoken fear—underscores the fragile boundary between this collapsing fictional world and harsh reality. Picard’s haunting question about the persistence of this world and the fate of his simulated family crystallizes the story’s core tension: the impermanence of constructed realities and the heavy cost of survival. This moment serves as an emotional turning point, highlighting Picard’s profound isolation and the uncertain future looming beyond the simulation’s shutdown.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Picard exchanges a heartfelt farewell with McNary, acknowledging their parting and the impossibility of taking McNary with him, as McNary commits to bringing a villain to justice.

gratitude to melancholy acceptance ['Office Floor']

The office floor trembles violently, underscoring the escalating danger as Picard delivers his emotional farewell, while they shake hands as old friends facing permanent separation.

rising danger to sorrowful finality ['Office Floor']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Worried and empathetic, masking a profound loneliness and existential uncertainty as he confronts the loss of his simulated reality and the dangerous return to harsh truth.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard commands the evacuation of the critically wounded Whalen and insists Data and Beverly leave immediately while he stays behind for a final, intimate farewell with Lieutenant McNary. He expresses deep gratitude, guarded sadness, and abiding concern about the fragile survival of the simulated world and the fate of his imagined loved ones before stepping through the collapsing threshold.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure safe evacuation of Whalen to Sickbay
  • Say a meaningful goodbye to McNary
  • Seek reassurance about the persistence of the Dixon Hill world
  • Protect his crew despite personal sacrifice
Active beliefs
  • The simulated world may cease to exist once they leave
  • His crew’s survival depends on rapid evacuation
  • Meaningful human connection transcends even fabricated realities
  • He must uphold duty even amid personal loss
Character traits
Resolute Empathetic Reflective Melancholic
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Concerned and focused, driven by duty to preserve life amid chaos with calm professionalism.

Data carries the critically wounded Whalen carefully through the destabilizing Dixon Hill office, responding immediately to Picard’s command to evacuate. He moves with precise concern and efficiency, ensuring Beverly accompanies him as they exit the collapsing simulation toward Sickbay.

Goals in this moment
  • Safely transport Whalen to medical care
  • Follow Picard’s command without hesitation
  • Maintain order during evacuation
  • Support Beverly in medical aid
Active beliefs
  • Whalen’s condition is critical requiring immediate medical intervention
  • Picard’s orders must be obeyed promptly
  • The simulation is failing and evacuation is urgent
  • Preserving crew safety is paramount
Character traits
Methodical Loyal Concerned Efficient
Follow Data's journey

Concerned and determined, balancing clinical urgency with emotional support for her patients and comrades.

Beverly Crusher accompanies Data in carrying the wounded Whalen out of the deteriorating simulation, prepared to provide urgent medical care. She shares Data’s concern and urgency, responding quickly to Picard’s order, embodying calm authority amid the escalating crisis.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure Whalen receives immediate medical attention
  • Follow Picard’s evacuation order
  • Maintain composure under pressure
  • Support Data during evacuation
Active beliefs
  • Whalen’s survival depends on swift treatment
  • The simulation’s collapse endangers crew safety
  • Medical command must act decisively
  • Teamwork optimizes crisis response
Character traits
Compassionate Professional Focused Resolute
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

In critical condition, likely unconscious or barely conscious, his fate hanging in the balance.

Charles Whalen lies critically wounded, being carefully carried by Data as Beverly attends to him. His condition heightens the urgency of the evacuation, embodying the episode’s escalating physical stakes and transforming him from jovial participant to vulnerable victim.

Goals in this moment
  • Survive his critical injury
  • Receive medical aid promptly
Active beliefs
  • He is in mortal danger
  • His comrades will save him if possible
Character traits
Vulnerable Dependent Frail Unconscious or semi-conscious
Follow Charles Whalen's journey

Resigned yet loyal, masking concern for the simulation’s stability and Picard’s fate with a dignified acceptance of duty.

Lieutenant McNary shares a sober handshake and heartfelt farewell with Picard, acknowledging the necessity of separation while maintaining a stoic, resigned demeanor. He gestures toward the thug to indicate pending justice and stays behind in the collapsing simulation, embodying the gritty dignity of duty amid loss.

Goals in this moment
  • See Picard safely depart
  • Maintain order amid chaos
  • Ensure the thug is booked
  • Uphold his role as law enforcement despite imminent danger
Active beliefs
  • Duty to law enforcement transcends personal safety
  • Picard must survive outside the simulation
  • The thug represents ongoing threat
  • This world is ending but responsibility remains
Character traits
Resigned Loyal Sympathetic Principled
Follow Lieutenant McNary's journey

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Dixon Hill's Waiting Room and Office

Dixon Hill's Waiting Room and Office serves as the intimate and claustrophobic stage for Picard's farewell to McNary amid the violent collapse of the Holodeck simulation. Its dim, worn surroundings heighten the emotional stakes, symbolizing the fragile boundary between fantasy and reality as the world flickers toward extinction.

Atmosphere Heavy with melancholy and impending loss, tension thickens the air as friendship is quietly severed …
Function Emotional farewell site and physical threshold between the simulated world and escape route.
Symbolism Represents moral isolation and the transience of constructed realities.
Access Restricted to characters currently within the Dixon Hill simulation; inaccessible once the simulation collapses.
Dim, low lighting Rumbling floor signaling collapse Sparse period furnishings Ambient silence punctuated by tremors

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 6
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard’s Farewell in the Collapsing Dixon Hill Office
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard’s Poignant Farewell to McNary as Fictional World Collapses
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard's Farewell and the Collapse of Illusion
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard’s Farewell in the Collapsing Dixon Hill Office
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard’s Poignant Farewell to McNary as Fictional World Collapses
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard's Farewell and the Collapse of Illusion
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
What this causes 6
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard’s Farewell in the Collapsing Dixon Hill Office
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard’s Poignant Farewell to McNary as Fictional World Collapses
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Emotional Echo

"Picard's farewell to McNary and his uncertainty about the fate of this world echo the theme of fragile boundaries between simulated and real worlds, underscoring the story's core tension."

Picard's Farewell and the Collapse of Illusion
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard’s Farewell in the Collapsing Dixon Hill Office
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard’s Poignant Farewell to McNary as Fictional World Collapses
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye
Foreshadowing

"Picard stepping through the portal and the subsequent darkness foreshadow the collapse of the simulated world and the finality of their separation from it."

Picard's Farewell and the Collapse of Illusion
S1E13 · The Big Goodbye

Key Dialogue

"PICARD: Pick him up. Get him to Sickbay."
"MCNARY: Someone's gotta book this creep. Once a cop always a cop, I guess."
"PICARD: Tell me something, Dixon. When you've gone.... will this world still exist?.. Will my wife and kids still be waiting for me at home?"
"PICARD: I honestly don't know. Good-bye my friend."