Fabula
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION — Up the Long Ladder

Mariposa's Secret: The Clone Revelation

In Granger's office Pulaski cuts through ceremony with a blunt, clinical question that detonates the scene's tension: she asks whether Mariposa's entire population are clones. Her professional authority refocuses the room from polite diplomacy to an ethical emergency. Riker and Worf register stunned disbelief; Granger's simple confirmation collapses mystery into crisis. The beat crystallizes competing priorities — scientific diagnosis versus political survival — forces the crew to rethink intervention, and functions as the act break that propels the story into moral conflict.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Pulaski drives straight to the heart of the mystery, asking if Mariposa’s entire population consists of clones.

polite formality to incisive challenge

Shock snaps into clarity as Riker and Worf echo “Clones?” and Granger confirms it, cementing the revelation and slamming into the act break.

confusion to stunned clarity

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6

Measured calm with guarded attention — outwardly unflappable but alert to political implications.

Elizabeth Vallis is present after being introduced; she maintains formal composure and listens without volunteering information, signaling administrative steadiness while the exchange escalates.

Goals in this moment
  • Support the Prime Minister's diplomatic posture and control the information flow.
  • Monitor Starfleet reactions to advise on political damage control.
Active beliefs
  • Administrative poise helps manage crises.
  • Information release must be calibrated to protect the polity's interests.
Character traits
composed protocol-oriented reserved
Follow Elizabeth Vallis's journey

Cool, authoritative professionalism masking urgency — urgent to diagnose and remove ambiguity rather than to perform diplomacy.

Pulaski crosses the room with deliberate calm, performs a brief handshake, and then abandons pleasantry for a sharply phrased, diagnostic question that reframes the meeting as a medical/ethical inquiry.

Goals in this moment
  • Obtain immediate, unambiguous medical/biological information about Mariposa's population.
  • Shift the encounter from diplomatic formality to factual clarity to assess health/public-safety implications for the Enterprise.
Active beliefs
  • Accurate biological knowledge is prerequisite to any Starfleet intervention.
  • Politeness cannot be allowed to obscure a possible public‑health or ethical crisis.
Character traits
clinical directness procedural focus unflappable under tension
Follow Katherine Pulaski's journey

Externally neutral and observant — their presence reads as engineered calm or cultural training rather than spontaneous emotion.

Represented by the two women (3A and 3C) who enter: they move as decorous, neutral presences, one carrying a laptop, embodying Mariposa's uniform population and transforming the reception into evidence rather than mere ceremony.

Goals in this moment
  • Present a controlled, non-threatening public face for the polity.
  • Support the Prime Minister's ceremonial narrative by appearing ordinary and compliant.
Active beliefs
  • Uniform presentation protects social order and political messaging.
  • Visibility of the population should be managed to maintain legitimacy.
Character traits
uniformity ceremonial stillness nonreactive
Follow Mariposan Clones's journey

Controlled resignation — projecting calm and authority while bracing for the consequences of exposure.

Granger stands in his office, offers a hospitable greeting, receives Pulaski's handshake, then answers her blunt question with an economy of words — his confirmation collapses the mystery into crisis while maintaining a controlled, resigned bearing.

Goals in this moment
  • Contain political fallout and maintain sovereign control of Mariposa's narrative.
  • Preserve diplomatic relations while minimizing perceived threat to his administration.
Active beliefs
  • Disclosure must be managed to protect the polity's stability.
  • Formal diplomacy is the correct initial posture when hosting outsiders.
Character traits
protocol-minded measured politically self-protective
Follow Walter Granger's journey

Stiffened alertness with underlying unease — surprised but immediately ready to enforce security protocols if needed.

Worf stands beside Riker, echoes the single-word reaction 'Clones?', and displays a visible, brief expression of alarm consistent with a security officer reconciling unfamiliar risk with duty.

Goals in this moment
  • Protect the away team and ship from any potential biological or operational threat.
  • Gather cues about whether the situation requires immediate defensive measures.
Active beliefs
  • Anomalous social structures can mask threats requiring containment.
  • Clear facts are necessary before escalating security action.
Character traits
vigilant blunt discipline-bound
Follow Worf's journey

Stunned incredulity moving toward professional concern — his surprise is tactical, not theatrical.

Riker stands with Worf, exchanging a sharp glance; he vocalizes the crew's incredulity ('Clones?') and his expression registers alarm and rapid reassessment of course-of-action options.

Goals in this moment
  • Assess immediate threat level to the away team and the Enterprise.
  • Determine whether to push for more information or withdraw to follow Starfleet protocols.
Active beliefs
  • Unusual biological facts often indicate hidden dangers or ethical complications.
  • The safety of his crew and adherence to procedure must be prioritized.
Character traits
practical skepticism protective authority quick-to-act concern
Follow William Riker's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Granger's Laptop Computer

The portable clamshell laptop is carried into the office by one of the Mariposan women and functions as a prop of bureaucratic normalcy and administrative competence; its presence underscores that this is a functioning government rather than an abstract experiment and hints at documentary records that might explain or conceal cloning practices.

Before: Closed or carried by 3C as part of …
After: Remains in the possession of the Mariposan attendant …
Before: Closed or carried by 3C as part of the delegation entering Granger's office, positioned as an innocuous administrative prop.
After: Remains in the possession of the Mariposan attendant (3C), unchanged physically but narratively reframed as a potential source of information once the diplomatic façade collapses.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Granger's Office

Prime Minister Granger's office functions as the formal stage for diplomacy where hospitality is performed; in this event it becomes a crucible where polite ritual is pierced by clinical inquiry, converting a ceremonial space into the site of an ethical and political rupture that propels subsequent action.

Atmosphere Initially cordial and ceremonious, instantly shifting to taut, charged tension — a politeness that curdles …
Function Meeting place for diplomatic reception that unexpectedly becomes the locus of interrogation and crisis.
Symbolism Embodies institutional authority now compromised by hidden truths; the office's decor and protocol contrast sharply …
Access Formally restricted to official delegations and senior visitors — the room is being used for …
A polished desk and arranged seating providing ceremonial formality. A door through which attendants enter, highlighting staged hospitality. Sunlight or artificial light casting a neutral, official sheen over participants.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 7
Causal

"Riker’s observation of duplicate citizens prompts Pulaski to challenge Granger, leading to the clone revelation."

Ceremonial Welcome, Unsettling Multiples
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
Causal

"Riker’s observation of duplicate citizens prompts Pulaski to challenge Granger, leading to the clone revelation."

Identicals: Riker's Alarm, Pulaski's Challenge
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
Foreshadowing

"Granger’s 'Not quite a descendant' remark hints at cloning, which Pulaski soon confirms explicitly."

Granger's Thin Denial
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
Foreshadowing

"Granger’s 'Not quite a descendant' remark hints at cloning, which Pulaski soon confirms explicitly."

Formal First Contact — Prime Minister Granger's Invitation
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
Foreshadowing

"Granger’s 'Not quite a descendant' remark hints at cloning, which Pulaski soon confirms explicitly."

From Ceremony to Deployment — Assembling the Away Team
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
Foreshadowing

"Granger’s 'Not quite a descendant' remark hints at cloning, which Pulaski soon confirms explicitly."

Mariposa's Warm Invitation — An Uneasy First Contact
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"The uneasy meeting with Granger leads directly to Pulaski’s explicit question and the revelation that the population is clones."

Warm Welcome, Cold Diagnosis
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …
What this causes 1
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS medium

"The uneasy meeting with Granger leads directly to Pulaski’s explicit question and the revelation that the population is clones."

Warm Welcome, Cold Diagnosis
S2E18 · STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION …

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"PULASKI: "So, is your entire population made up of clones, Prime Minister?""
"RIKER: "Clones?""
"GRANGER: "Clones.""