Fabula
S3E22 · The Most Toys

The Convenience of Crisis: Riker’s Paranoia Takes Root

In the eerie, mineral-lit caves of Beta Agni Two, the Enterprise crew—Riker, Beverly, and Worf—materialize to investigate the neutralized tricyanate contamination. Worf’s tricorder reveals an unsettling truth: the substance was artificial, its rapid neutralization impossible under natural conditions. Beverly’s medical expertise confirms the absurdity of tricyanate as a sabotage tool—it’s slow, difficult to replicate, and impractical for poisoning. Yet its deliberate use suggests a calculated ruse, one designed to mimic a natural disaster. Riker’s sharp instincts zero in on the most damning detail: the timing of their hytritium discovery. The crew’s ‘luck’ in finding just enough of the rare mineral to resolve the crisis feels suspiciously precise, a red flag that this entire emergency was orchestrated. The air thickens with unease as the crew realizes they may have been manipulated into a trap, their actions dictated by an unseen hand. This moment isn’t just a revelation—it’s the first crack in the illusion of control, forcing the crew to question whether their mission was ever their own.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Riker points out the coincidence that they were able to find just enough hytritium to resolve the crisis, prompting a look between the crew.

realization to shared understanding

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

Suspicious and analytically focused, with a growing sense of unease as the crew realizes they may have been manipulated.

Riker materializes in the cave alongside Beverly and Worf, his posture tense as he processes the implications of the tricyanate contamination. He listens intently to Worf’s tricorder readings, his brow furrowing as the artificial nature of the contamination becomes clear. Riker’s dialogue drives the realization of sabotage, and his final observation about the 'lucky' timing of the hytritium discovery is the linchpin that exposes the manipulation. His presence is commanding, his questions sharp, and his instincts honed to detect inconsistencies in the narrative.

Goals in this moment
  • To uncover the truth behind the tricyanate contamination and determine if it was sabotage.
  • To connect the dots between the contamination, the hytritium discovery, and the possibility of an orchestrated crisis.
Active beliefs
  • That the contamination’s rapid neutralization is unnatural and suggests deliberate interference.
  • That the timing of the hytritium discovery is too convenient to be coincidental, implying a larger scheme.
Character traits
Analytical Suspicious Commanding Instinctive Persuasive
Follow William Riker's journey

Confused but analytically driven, with a growing realization that the contamination was not what it seemed.

Beverly materializes with her tricorder already in hand, scanning the water with clinical precision. She confirms the contamination has been neutralized but is quick to question the practicality of tricyanate as a sabotage tool, citing its slow assimilation and difficulty to replicate. Her medical expertise provides the crew with critical context, dismantling the plausibility of the contamination being a natural disaster. Her dialogue is methodical and insightful, grounding the crew’s suspicions in scientific reality.

Goals in this moment
  • To provide a medical and scientific perspective on the tricyanate contamination to help the crew understand its implications.
  • To challenge the assumption that the contamination was natural, highlighting its impracticality as a sabotage tool.
Active beliefs
  • That tricyanate is an unlikely choice for sabotage due to its slow action and difficulty to transport.
  • That the contamination’s neutralization suggests a deliberate and calculated interference.
Character traits
Methodical Analytical Insightful Skeptical Supportive
Follow Beverly Crusher's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
Medical Tricorder

Beverly’s tricorder is used to scan the water in the cave, confirming that the tricyanate contamination has been neutralized. While it doesn’t reveal the artificial nature of the contamination directly, it supports Beverly’s analysis of the impracticality of tricyanate as a sabotage tool. The tricorder’s readings provide the crew with a medical and scientific perspective, grounding their suspicions in data and reinforcing the idea that the contamination was not natural.

Before: Active and in Beverly’s possession as she materializes …
After: Still active and in Beverly’s possession, having confirmed …
Before: Active and in Beverly’s possession as she materializes in the cave, ready for immediate use.
After: Still active and in Beverly’s possession, having confirmed the water’s clean status and supported her analysis of the contamination.
Hytritium

Hytritium is the plot device that ties the contamination to the larger manipulation. Riker’s observation about the 'lucky' timing of its discovery—just enough to resolve the crisis—hints that the entire emergency was orchestrated to force the *Enterprise* into a vulnerable position. The hytritium’s role is symbolic, representing the hidden hand guiding the crew’s actions and exposing the crisis as a trap.

Before: Recently acquired from Kivas Fajo and stored on …
After: Confirmed as a key element in the orchestrated …
Before: Recently acquired from Kivas Fajo and stored on the *Enterprise*, its discovery now recontextualized as part of the sabotage.
After: Confirmed as a key element in the orchestrated crisis, its 'lucky' timing now seen as deliberate manipulation.
Tricyanate (Fajo's Contaminant)

The tricyanate crystals are the central clue in this event, their artificial composition and rapid neutralization exposing the sabotage. Worf scans them with his tricorder, revealing the absence of natural trace elements, while Beverly’s analysis highlights their impracticality as a sabotage tool. The crystals serve as physical evidence of the manipulation, their unnatural properties forcing the crew to question the contamination’s origins and realize it was part of a larger scheme.

Before: Scattered across the cave floor and walls, contaminated …
After: Confirmed as artificial and a key piece of …
Before: Scattered across the cave floor and walls, contaminated and partially neutralized, awaiting analysis.
After: Confirmed as artificial and a key piece of evidence in the crew’s realization that the contamination was sabotage.
Worf's Personal Tricorder

Worf’s tricorder is the critical tool that reveals the artificial nature of the tricyanate contamination. He uses it to scan the crystals, confirming the absence of natural trace elements and the unnaturally rapid neutralization process. The tricorder’s readings provide the crew with the technical evidence they need to question the contamination’s origins and realize it was sabotage. Its role is pivotal in exposing the manipulation behind the crisis.

Before: Active and in Worf’s possession as he materializes …
After: Still active and in Worf’s possession, having provided …
Before: Active and in Worf’s possession as he materializes in the cave, ready for immediate use.
After: Still active and in Worf’s possession, having provided the crew with the evidence needed to confirm the contamination was artificial.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Beta Agni II

The cave on Beta Agni II is the setting for the crew’s realization that the tricyanate contamination was sabotage. Its shimmering mineral walls and scattered purple crystals create an eerie, otherworldly atmosphere, amplifying the tension as the crew uncovers the truth. The cave’s isolation and the contamination’s unnatural properties make it the perfect stage for exposing the manipulation, symbolizing the hidden forces at play in the crisis.

Atmosphere Eerie and tense, with the shimmering mineral walls and scattered crystals creating an otherworldly glow …
Function Investigation site where the crew uncovers the artificial nature of the contamination and realizes they …
Symbolism Represents the hidden and unnatural forces behind the crisis, its isolation mirroring the crew’s growing …
Access Restricted to the *Enterprise* away team; the cave is otherwise uninhabited and part of an …
Shimmering mineral walls reflecting ambient light. Scattered purple crystals (golf ball-sized) creating an eerie glow. A stream of water running through the cave, once contaminated but now clean.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Starfleet

Starfleet is indirectly involved in this event through the *Enterprise* crew’s actions and the mission parameters they follow. The crew’s investigation into the contamination is driven by Starfleet’s directives to secure resources and resolve crises, even as they realize the crisis may have been orchestrated. Starfleet’s role is institutional, representing the broader context in which the crew operates and the expectations they must fulfill, even as they uncover manipulation.

Representation Via institutional protocol and mission parameters guiding the crew’s actions.
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over the crew’s actions, though the crew’s realization of manipulation challenges the assumption …
Impact The crew’s realization of manipulation forces them to question Starfleet’s role in the crisis, highlighting …
Internal Dynamics The crew’s growing suspicion of the crisis challenges their trust in Starfleet’s mission parameters, creating …
To resolve the tricyanate contamination crisis and secure the necessary resources (hytritium). To maintain operational integrity and adhere to Starfleet protocols, even as the crew questions the legitimacy of the crisis. Through mission directives and resource acquisition protocols. Via the crew’s adherence to institutional expectations, even as they uncover manipulation.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1
Foreshadowing medium

"The Enterprise's mission to procure hytritium is foreshadowed by Riker, after it is revealed they had precisely enough hytritium to resolve the crisis, implying Fajo orchestrated the entire crisis."

Picard’s Log: The Enterprise’s Desperate Gamble and the Shadow of Data’s Fate
S3E22 · The Most Toys
What this causes 3
Causal

"Worf's determination that the tricyanate contamination was artificially introduced, combined with Fajo's convenient arrival, directly leads to the Enterprise crew realizing Fajo orchestrated the crisis to acquire Data."

The Enterprise's Revelation: Fajo’s Gambit and Data’s Captivity
S3E22 · The Most Toys
Causal

"Worf's determination that the tricyanate contamination was artificially introduced, combined with Fajo's convenient arrival, directly leads to the Enterprise crew realizing Fajo orchestrated the crisis to acquire Data."

Varria’s Humiliation and the Birth of a Fragile Alliance
S3E22 · The Most Toys
Causal

"Worf's determination that the tricyanate contamination was artificially introduced, combined with Fajo's convenient arrival, directly leads to the Enterprise crew realizing Fajo orchestrated the crisis to acquire Data."

Varria’s Humiliation and Fajo’s Cruelty: The Collapse of Seduction and the Reinforcement of Control
S3E22 · The Most Toys

Key Dialogue

"WORF: ((adjusts tricorder)) There are no natural trace elements present in these tricyanate crystals."
"RIKER: If it's artificial, then we're talking about sabotage."
"BEVERLY: It might pass for a natural disaster. And since there's only one way to treat it... with hytritium, maybe someone figured we wouldn't locate any... it is hard to come by."
"RIKER: You know it really was lucky, wasn't it...? That we were able to find hytritium when we did. Just enough hytritium for this crisis."