Preserve or Abandon: Authorization to Investigate the Ancient Satellite
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Geordi and Worf analyze the satellite's trajectory toward the Kazis Binary and warn it will be destroyed; Worf offers to alter its heading with a tractor beam, but Riker dismisses intervention as unnecessary debris management.
Data requests permission to investigate the derelict, arguing its historical value; Riker balks but ultimately grants a limited authorization—Data may examine the object but must return before the captain arrives.
Riker assigns Worf to accompany Data, and the two exit the bridge—transforming passive observation into immediate exploratory action and moving the plot off the bridge toward direct investigation.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Intellectually animated and calmly insistent—curiosity drives him but he respects command structure.
At Science One, Data interrogates sensor returns, identifies the object as an early twenty‑first‑century satellite with solar power and minimal life support, argues for its historical value, and formally requests permission to investigate.
- • Secure authorization to examine and potentially recover the satellite
- • Preserve and study an otherwise irreplaceable historical artifact
- • Maximize the limited time available before the captain's return
- • Historical artifacts have intrinsic scientific and cultural value
- • The Enterprise has a responsibility to preserve knowledge when feasible
- • Empirical investigation should be pursued when time permits
Assertive and focused; impatience beneath the tactical formality driven by the object’s imminent destruction.
Manning Tactical, Worf warns that the satellite will be destroyed by the Kazis Binary, recommends immediate tractor‑beam intervention, volunteers to accompany Data and operate the beam, and physically exits the bridge when ordered.
- • Prevent the satellite's destruction by physically altering its trajectory
- • Fulfill the ship's security and recovery responsibilities
- • Ensure any away action is executed quickly and efficiently
- • When a life or object is threatened, decisive action is required
- • Technical tools (tractor beam) can and should be used proactively
- • Delay increases the likelihood of irrevocable loss
Measured and mildly dismissive outwardly; privately cautious about altering ship posture in the captain's absence.
Acting as commanding officer on the bridge, Riker frames the situation with an opening log, adjudicates competing positions, rejects Worf's immediate rescue proposal, and compromises by authorizing a short timed recovery while ordering Worf to accompany Data.
- • Maintain ship readiness and routine while the captain is absent
- • Avoid unnecessary diversion of resources on uncertain salvage
- • Permit limited scientific inquiry without compromising command responsibilities
- • Derelict objects are typically expendable unless proven otherwise
- • Major decisions should be conservative when the commanding officer is absent
- • Time windows can balance curiosity and caution
Intrigued and mildly puzzled; engaged in quiet problem‑solving rather than emotional investment.
At the Conn, Geordi offers technical context, speculates about how an early‑era satellite could have traveled so far given impulse limitations, and frames the situation's improbability for the team.
- • Clarify the physical constraints that would allow the satellite to be where it is
- • Provide data to inform the bridge's decision about recovery
- • Help quantify the time/distance problem for operational planning
- • Physical laws (impulse limits) are a useful baseline for hypothesis
- • Anomalous findings deserve technical scrutiny
- • Accurate technical context will improve command decisions
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
Bridge displays and readouts provide specific telemetry—carrier frequency, power source, heading and the impending intercept with the Kazis Binary—feeding Data's analysis and Riker's time assessment that enables a compromise decision.
The Enterprise's main viewscreen projects the distant satellite as a small, focused blip and becomes the focal point for the bridge's debate—displaying carrier signals, trajectory, and relative motion that provoke both tactical and scientific responses.
Data references the satellite's ancient life support unit—its solar power and minimal environmental systems—as the crucial clue implying possible survivability and historical value, which prompts the decision to attempt a recovery despite risk.
The miniature tractor beam is verbally proposed by Worf as the technical means to attach and alter the satellite's heading; it functions narratively as the plausible tool to convert debate into action and is assigned to be used off‑bridge.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The Bridge Tactical Station anchors Worf's presence—where he reads the imminent threat, recommends a tractor‑beam response, and readies the tactical hardware that will be used if the away team proceeds.
Science One is where Data performs spectral analysis and interprets the carrier signal, identifying historical provenance and physical properties that reframe the bridge's consideration from debris to artifact.
The Kazis Binary is the remote, hostile stellar environment toward which the satellite is drifting; it supplies the time pressure and physical inevitability that convert an intellectual question into an urgent operational choice.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"Data's detection of the anomalous carrier (unused frequency) directly leads to classifying the object as a primitive 21st‑century satellite, reframing the bridge curiosity into historical salvage."
"Data's detection of the anomalous carrier (unused frequency) directly leads to classifying the object as a primitive 21st‑century satellite, reframing the bridge curiosity into historical salvage."
"Riker authorizes Data's investigation, directly leading to the discovery of a preserved survivor."
"Riker authorizes Data's investigation, directly leading to the discovery of a preserved survivor."
"An ancient Earth relic resurfacing mirrors the Romulans’ declarative return: 'We are back!'"
"An ancient Earth relic resurfacing mirrors the Romulans’ declarative return: 'We are back!'"
"An ancient Earth relic resurfacing mirrors the Romulans’ declarative return: 'We are back!'"
"An ancient Earth relic resurfacing mirrors the Romulans’ declarative return: 'We are back!'"
Key Dialogue
"WORF: "Sir, I could attach a tractor beam and adjust its heading.""
"DATA: "It is a piece of history. The opportunity to examine such an ancient vehicle does not come around very often, and as you pointed out, we do have the time.""
"RIKER: "All right, Data. But be ready to beam back before the captain returns.""