S1E11
· Hide and Q

Riker Confronts the Temptation and Burden of Omnipotence

In the Captain's Ready Room, Riker faces the heavy weight of the godlike power granted by Q. Picard, with anger and urgency, challenges Riker’s confidence in resisting temptation, emphasizing the near-immortality and cosmic scale of the gift. Riker asserts his resolve to resist the corrupting influence despite the immense pressure. This intense exchange crystallizes the profound moral and existential stakes at play, revealing the fragile human spirit tested by omnipotence. The scene closes as their focus abruptly shifts back to the critical rescue mission, underscoring the tension between power and responsibility.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

4

Riker approaches Picard's desk as Picard angrily challenges him, expressing frustration over how to advise him about his new godlike powers.

tension to confrontation

Riker probes Picard by asking if anyone has offered him godlike power, prompting Picard to respond with a sharp warning about the overwhelming nature of 'Q's offer and its implications of immortality and control over space and time.

curiosity to grave warning

Picard leans forward, expressing deep concern and questioning whether Riker can resist the temptation to use his immense power despite 'Q's manipulations.

concern to challenge

Riker confidently assures Picard of his resolve to resist temptation, giving his word despite the difficulty posed by 'Q'.

challenge to firm resolve

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Frustrated and deeply concerned, grappling with the heavy responsibility of leadership amid a cosmic test.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard sits at his desk, visibly angry and urgent. He challenges Riker's confidence, emphasizing the near-immortality and cosmic scale of Q's gift and questioning Riker's strength to resist temptation, embodying the burden of command and concern for his first officer's moral compass.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure Riker fully comprehends the peril of godlike power
  • To prevent Riker from succumbing to temptation
  • To maintain focus on the critical rescue mission
Active beliefs
  • That Q's power can corrupt absolutely
  • That it is a captain's duty to protect his crew from such corruption
Character traits
authoritative concerned angry urgent protective
Follow Jean-Luc Picard's journey

Neutral and focused, embodying an unflappable professionalism that contrasts with the charged emotional exchange.

Data's voice interjects through the com system, providing a calm, factual update about the rescue team's readiness in orbit of Quadra Sigma III. Although physically absent, Data's communication momentarily shifts the scene's tension toward operational urgency.

Goals in this moment
  • To update command on the rescue mission status
  • To maintain operational readiness and communication flow
Active beliefs
  • That clear, precise communication is critical in crisis
  • That the mission's success depends on coordinated effort
Character traits
calm precise duty-bound analytical
Follow Data's journey

Determined and resolute, with a calm exterior masking the weight of temptation and responsibility he faces.

Commander William Riker enters the Ready Room decisively and halts before Picard's desk. He engages in a tense, resolute dialogue affirming his ability to resist the corrupting godlike power granted by Q, demonstrating firm confidence and readiness despite the underlying pressure.

Goals in this moment
  • To reassure Picard of his resolve against using Q's godlike power
  • To maintain moral integrity and loyalty to Starfleet principles
  • To prepare mentally for the upcoming rescue mission
Active beliefs
  • That omnipotent power risks corrupting even the strongest
  • That resisting temptation is essential to preserving humanity and duty
Character traits
resolute firm confident loyal morally steadfast
Follow William Riker's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Captain Picard's Desk

Captain Picard's desk serves as the focal point of this intense exchange, physically anchoring the confrontation. It symbolizes Picard's authority and the heavy burden of command as he leans forward to challenge Riker, embodying the weight of leadership amid cosmic stakes.

Before: Clean, polished, located in the center of the …
After: Remains physically unchanged and central, continuing to frame …
Before: Clean, polished, located in the center of the Ready Room, under Picard's possession.
After: Remains physically unchanged and central, continuing to frame the charged dialogue and command presence.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Captain's Ready Room

The Captain's Ready Room acts as the private, tense arena for this confrontation. It provides a psychologically charged setting where leadership, loyalty, and cosmic temptation collide. The room's atmosphere underscores the gravity of the moral trial and the weight of command decisions.

Atmosphere Tense, urgent, and emotionally charged, with an undercurrent of conflict and moral dilemma.
Function Meeting place for a private yet critical confrontation between Picard and Riker regarding the temptation …
Symbolism Represents the locus of command authority and the isolation inherent in leadership facing impossible choices.
Access Restricted to senior Starfleet officers; private and secure.
Polished wood surfaces reflecting authority Low ambient lighting emphasizing focus on speakers Quiet except for intense dialogue and intermittent com voice

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1
Character Continuity

"Riker's questioning of Picard about godlike power leads to Picard's deep concern about the temptation and implications, shaping their dialogue about power's dangers."

A Stark Promise Before the Rescue
S1E11 · Hide and Q
What this causes 3
Character Continuity

"The confrontation between Picard and Riker regarding the burden of godlike power continues into Troi's apprehensive observation of Riker's dangerous transformation."

Riker's Command Challenge and Picard’s Steadfast Rebuff
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Character Continuity

"The confrontation between Picard and Riker regarding the burden of godlike power continues into Troi's apprehensive observation of Riker's dangerous transformation."

Troi’s Foreboding Sense of Riker’s Dark Transformation
S1E11 · Hide and Q
Character Continuity

"Riker's questioning of Picard about godlike power leads to Picard's deep concern about the temptation and implications, shaping their dialogue about power's dangers."

A Stark Promise Before the Rescue
S1E11 · Hide and Q

Key Dialogue

"PICARD: Will, how the hell do I advise you what to do?!"
"RIKER: No one has ever offered to turn you into "God?""
"PICARD: (snaps) Don't joke with me! What the Q has offered you has got to be close to "immortality," Will. They're not lying about controlling space and time; we've seen it in what they can do. But..."
"PICARD: Of all things, that troubles me most, Will. Are you strong enough to refuse to use that power?"
"RIKER: Certainly!"
"PICARD: No matter how tempted? No matter how difficult "Q" makes it?"
"RIKER: (beat; then firmly) You have my word."