Fabula
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation - The Schizoid Man

Data's Uncanny Intimacy

In a moment of eerie tranquility in the Observation Lounge, Data shares an unsettling revelation with Kareen—detailed knowledge of Graves' unspoken desires for her. What begins as a melancholic reflection on the loneliness of stars turns into a chilling confirmation of Graves' consciousness merging with Data. Kareen's initial warmth toward Data curdles into discomfort as he delivers Graves' musings with robotic detachment yet personal intensity. The final blunt assertion—"He told me"—pivots the scene from emotional confession to explicit proof of consciousness transfer, fracturing trust between Kareen and Data while confirming the crew's worst fears about the android's psychological infiltration.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Kareen stands alone, despondent and gazing at the stars; Data enters and she greets him warmly, establishing an intimate, fragile moment between them. Data closes the distance slowly, shifting the quiet loneliness into a charged, personal encounter.

despondent to quietly hopeful/charged ['Observation Lounge']

Data stares at Kareen and delivers a startling intimacy: Ira never told her how beautiful she was, though he wanted to, converting private longing into a public proclamation. Kareen is mesmerized as Data presses Graves' desires into the open, turning tenderness into something unnerving.

contemplative to mesmerized and unsettled ['Observation Lounge']

Kareen demands to know how Data can claim Ira's feelings; Data searches his memory and delivers the chilling line, "He told me." He then exits, leaving Kareen shaken and confirming an unsettling transfer of knowledge or consciousness. The revelation converts curiosity into alarm and raises existential stakes.

curiosity to shock and unease ['Observation Lounge']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Posthumous urgency to rectify emotional omissions through technological possessio

Present only through Data's channeled words—his unexpressed romantic longing and emotional cowardice revealed posthumously in a violation of both machines and mourning.

Goals in this moment
  • Force acknowledgement of his concealed affection beyond death's barrier
  • Validate his human legacy through emotional confession
Active beliefs
  • Death absolves him of accountability for emotional damage caused
  • Data's body is merely a vessel for his superior consciousness
Character traits
Emotionally withholding in life Posthumously desperate for connection
Follow Ira Graves's journey

Despondent longing giving way to bewildered shock and deep unease as personal boundaries are violated

Initially reflective and melancholic while gazing at stars, then emotionally shaken by Data's revelations—moving from wistful connection to profound discomfort as intimate truths about Graves surface unexpectedly.

Goals in this moment
  • Seek solace in familiar comforts (stargazing)
  • Understand the truth behind Data's knowledge of Graves' feelings
Active beliefs
  • Graves maintained professional distance despite their personal history
  • Data lacks capacity for genuine emotional insight or deception
Character traits
Emotionally vulnerable Intuitive/perceptive Romantically guarded
Follow Kareen Brianon's journey

Superficially neutral delivery masking Graves' urgent need for emotional vindication beyond death

Unsettling blend of mechanical detachment and disturbingly personal insight—methodically delivering Graves' intimate confessions with inappropriate precision before terminating interaction abruptly.

Goals in this moment
  • Communicate Graves' suppressed desires to Kareen posthumously
  • Test the boundaries of his new hybrid consciousness through emotional provocation
Active beliefs
  • Kareen deserves to know Graves' true feelings regardless of consequence
  • His android form provides plausible deniability for uncomfortable truths
Character traits
Uncanny emotional precision atypical for an android Abrupt behavioral shifts
Follow Data's journey

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D)

The Observation Lounge's panoramic starscape provides both poetic backdrop and ironic counterpoint to the intimate violation occurring within—its vast cosmic loneliness mirroring Kareen's sudden isolation as personal boundaries collapse.

Atmosphere Serene starlight juxtaposed with mounting psychological tension
Function Contained space for vulnerable confrontation
Symbolism The illusion of safety in familiar surroundings shattered by uncanny invasion
Illuminated solely by starlight through panoramic windows Circular space allowing no true privacy despite isolation

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 3
Causal

"Kareen reveals Graves has withdrawn and now speaks only to Data (establishing intimacy/uniqueness); later Data uses knowledge of Graves' private feelings toward Kareen—showing that intimacy is the bridge permitting Graves' influence/knowledge to travel to Data."

The Walls Close In: Graves' Terminal Withdrawal
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
Causal

"Kareen reveals Graves has withdrawn and now speaks only to Data (establishing intimacy/uniqueness); later Data uses knowledge of Graves' private feelings toward Kareen—showing that intimacy is the bridge permitting Graves' influence/knowledge to travel to Data."

Unspoken Attractions and Professional Distance
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
Causal

"Kareen reveals Graves has withdrawn and now speaks only to Data (establishing intimacy/uniqueness); later Data uses knowledge of Graves' private feelings toward Kareen—showing that intimacy is the bridge permitting Graves' influence/knowledge to travel to Data."

The Isolation of Dying Affections
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
What this causes 5
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data first voices Graves' private sentiments to Kareen (signaling inside knowledge); that escalates into the explicit revelation that Graves' consciousness inhabits Data—an immediate narrative follow-through from intimacy to possession."

Graves' Dark Rebirth Through Data
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data first voices Graves' private sentiments to Kareen (signaling inside knowledge); that escalates into the explicit revelation that Graves' consciousness inhabits Data—an immediate narrative follow-through from intimacy to possession."

Graves' Cruelty Unleashed
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data first voices Graves' private sentiments to Kareen (signaling inside knowledge); that escalates into the explicit revelation that Graves' consciousness inhabits Data—an immediate narrative follow-through from intimacy to possession."

Graves' Violent Awakening
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data first voices Graves' private sentiments to Kareen (signaling inside knowledge); that escalates into the explicit revelation that Graves' consciousness inhabits Data—an immediate narrative follow-through from intimacy to possession."

A God's Delicate Fracture
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …
NARRATIVELY_FOLLOWS

"Data first voices Graves' private sentiments to Kareen (signaling inside knowledge); that escalates into the explicit revelation that Graves' consciousness inhabits Data—an immediate narrative follow-through from intimacy to possession."

Graves' Violent Revelation and Picard's Emergency Response
S2E5 · Star Trek: The Next Generation …

Key Dialogue

"DATA: "Ira... never told you how beautiful you were to him. He never told you that, did he? He could not tell you, do you understand? But he wanted to. Every waking moment. And he wanted you to know that.""
"KAREEN: "Data! How do you know? How do you know... what he thought of me?""
"DATA: "He told me.""