Ambiguous Romulan Emissions Over Nelvana Three
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Data reveals the probe detected artificial subspace radio emissions near Nelvana Three, suggesting possible Romulan activity.
Geordi confirms the signals are too faint for ship sensors but likely Romulan, adding ambiguity.
Data suggests cloaked Romulan ships could explain the anomalies, heightening suspicions.
Geordi reports no surface readings but warns the probe's limitations leave room for hidden bases.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Contemplative and quietly concerned — outwardly composed while inwardly balancing moral duty against the risk of military escalation.
Captain Picard listens to technical briefings from Data and Geordi, asks clarifying questions, receives the limitations of the data, and withdraws the officers to deliberate alone — physically present and mentally weighing consequences.
- • Ascertain the reliability and implications of the probe data before ordering action
- • Avoid precipitous decisions that could provoke Romulan aggression while honoring humanitarian and investigative obligations
- • Uncertain intelligence demands prudence; actions should be justified by clear evidence
- • Romulan behavior is potentially provocative and must be met with restraint to prevent war
Objective and detached on the surface; engaged by the intellectual problem of reconciling imperfect data with plausible hypotheses.
Data presents analyzed telemetry from the Nelvana Three probe, asserts the emission patterns are artificial, and offers plausible technical explanations such as cloaked ships or a concealed base, speaking with clinical precision.
- • Convey the probe's findings accurately and without speculation beyond the data
- • Provide operational hypotheses to help command decide next steps
- • Telemetry patterns can reveal artificial signatures even when raw signal strength is weak
- • Multiple technical explanations should be presented to avoid premature attribution
Practical anxiety: aware of technical limits and unsettled by the possibility of concealed Romulan activity, pushing for the most reliable way to resolve uncertainty.
Geordi reports the probe's telemetry limits, emphasizes the faintness of the signal and failed decoding attempts, and pragmatically recommends an in-person inspection as the only definitive course of action.
- • Communicate the engineering and sensor limitations clearly to command
- • Advocate for an operational solution that yields decisive information (i.e., physical inspection)
- • Sensors and remote probes have limits; sometimes human/ship presence is required
- • Better to confirm directly than to act on ambiguous telemetry that could be misread
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Nelvana Three Class One maximum-scan probe is the source of the contested data: it returned low-strength subspace emissions and patterned telemetry that initiated the briefing. Narratively it functions as the inciting instrument converting remote suspicion into an operational dilemma.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The Surface of Nelvana Three is the investigative subject in this briefing: its apparent geological barrenness contrasts with the probe's detection of patterned subspace emissions, turning empty terrain into a possible hiding place for cloaked ships or a concealed installation.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
No narrative connections mapped yet
This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph
Key Dialogue
"DATA: As the probe went into orbit around Nelvana Three, it began to pick up low level subspace radio emissions..."
"GEORDI: We've tried. It's probably Romulan... but we can't be sure."
"PICARD: That will be all, gentlemen."