Geordi's Fierce Farewell
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Data notices Geordi nursing a drink, moves to him and their easy friendship fractures into raw grief as Geordi confesses anger at Data being forced out and then embraces him fiercely.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Aggrieved and defensive—he belittles the ceremony both to assert control and to guard his professional reputation as Data's would-be researcher.
Maddox appears in the doorway, sarcastically minimizing the farewell and proposing demeaning 'carnival' uses for Data; his tone is dismissive and reveals professional frustration and investment in his own research agenda.
- • Undermine the idea of Data as a person to preserve his own scientific framing.
- • Reassert authority over Data's future and his research claims.
- • Provoke a reaction that shifts attention back to the intellectual debate he favors.
- • Data is a machine and should be understood scientifically.
- • Anthropomorphism clouds objective research and hinders progress.
- • His professional standing depends on keeping Data framed as an experimental subject.
Caring but brusque—she hides warmth beneath matter-of-fact counsel, attempting to prepare Data for real-world difficulties.
Pulaski interrupts the light ritual to deliver blunt, pragmatic advice about living off-ship, cutting ceremonial sentiment with a candid, no-nonsense tone and framed concern.
- • Impart concrete advice to help Data survive off-ship realities.
- • Pierce sentimental denial in the crew with realistic counsel.
- • Ensure Data contemplates pragmatic options rather than romanticizing freedom.
- • Sentiment is insufficient preparation for practical challenges.
- • Direct advice is sometimes the most caring response.
- • Starfleet life does not fully prepare one for groundside living.
Lighthearted and fond; he treats Data as a friend and pupil rather than an abstract subject.
Wesley teases Data about gift unwrapping with boyish good humor, receives an arm around his shoulders from Data, and participates as the affectionate, youthful witness to the crew's tenderness.
- • Affirm his bond with Data through small, familiar rituals.
- • Contribute to a warm, informal farewell atmosphere.
- • Relieve tension with humor.
- • Data is a friend and mentor figure deserving human treatment.
- • Social rituals (like ripping wrapping) matter for emotional expression.
- • Departure should be acknowledged with warmth rather than detachment.
Calm and gracious in demeanor, with a quiet, algorithmic sorrow implied rather than overtly felt; his comportment highlights the emotional gap others try to bridge.
Data engages the group with gentle literalness—ripping wrapping when prompted, reading the book title aloud, responding politely to Pulaski, comforting Wesley, and answering Geordi’s pain with an awkward, sincere farewell.
- • Acknowledge and accept the gifts and sentiments offered by the crew.
- • Maintain social rituals and not upset his friends by awkward behavior.
- • Express gratitude and reassure crew members of his intentions.
- • Social customs should be respected and performed correctly when possible.
- • His own choices are rational and defensible, even if others disagree.
- • Engaging with human rituals helps maintain bonds despite structural differences.
Matter-of-fact pride—he honors Data with an item of cultural weight, signaling respect in his own measured way.
Worf presents the antique book, comments on Klingon association, and participates in the quiet ritual as a proud, straightforward presence; his gift is ceremonial and culturally resonant.
- • Offer a meaningful, culturally inflected gift to Data.
- • Acknowledge Data's service with dignified respect.
- • Contribute to the group's farewell ritual.
- • Gifts can carry cultural and symbolic significance beyond surface use.
- • Respect is best expressed through concrete ceremonial acts.
- • Honoring comrades strengthens unit cohesion.
Externally professional; privately uneasy and protective—balancing loyalty to Data with obligation to chain-of-command and protocol.
Riker stands with Troi, initiating a clinical, private debate about whether Data possesses emotions; he answers the com summons, touches his insignia, and offers to escort Maddox toward the door, visibly torn between friendship and duty.
- • Shield his crew and Data where possible from institutional harm.
- • Maintain command decorum while managing an awkward, morally fraught situation.
- • De-escalate Maddox's intrusion and remove him from the farewell.
- • Personal loyalty to subordinates matters and should influence judgment.
- • Starfleet procedure and chain-of-command are binding obligations he must respect.
- • Data's value may extend beyond measurable programming.
Reflective and intellectually curious; she is uneasy about drawing premature moral conclusions but sympathetic to crew feelings.
Troi converses quietly with Riker about her inability to sense emotion from Data, cautioning against simplistic conclusions and arguing the absence of sensed feeling is not proof of absence.
- • Prevent emotional projection from turning into a false moral certainty.
- • Provide a measured, therapeutic frame for Riker and the group.
- • Preserve objectivity while holding space for the crew's grief.
- • Empathic readings have limits and must not be conflated with moral proof.
- • People may anthropomorphize non-human entities to satisfy emotional needs.
- • Caution is needed before declaring personhood based on sensed emotion alone.
Numb at first, then grief-stricken and angry; the hug is a release and an accusation against the system forcing Data out.
Geordi sits apart nursing a drink and visibly struggles with Data's forced departure; when Data speaks to him he rises and gives a fierce, wordless hug, externalizing grief and helpless anger at institutional injustice.
- • Express his personal loss and solidarity with Data.
- • Comfort Data and reaffirm their friendship in a way words cannot.
- • Register protest, privately, against the injustice he perceives.
- • Data is more than circuitry and deserves protection.
- • Institutional decisions can be unjust even when procedurally legitimate.
- • Personal loyalty obliges him to visibly stand with Data.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
A sheet of decorative wrapping paper covers a gift; Data initially considers preserving it but then rips it off to honor Wesley's social expectation. The paper's tearing punctuates the lighthearted ritual and marks the moment when ceremony yields to genuine sentiment.
A formal doorway/threshold object is referenced as Riker and Maddox move toward the exit; it marks the physical transition from Ten-Forward's intimate space toward the official domains of the ship and is the practical egress for Maddox to be escorted.
Assorted ceremonial drinks occupy Ten-Forward and function as tactile props: Geordi nurses one while brooding, the glasses indicate conviviality even as mood shifts and give characters small, human actions to perform through the scene.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
Transporter Room Five is evoked as the immediate destination for Riker and Picard's urgent meeting with Captain Louvois; narratively it functions as the practical threshold between Ten-Forward's personal sphere and the formal legal/institutional machinery about to intercede.
Captain Louvois's office is invoked by the com summons as the authoritative site expecting Riker and Picard; it stands for the official, adjudicative domain that will formalize the conflict over Data's status.
Ten-Forward functions as the ship's social hearth where crew rituals, casual intimacy, and small dramas unfold; in this event it stages a farewell that shifts from jocular gift exchange to personal grief and becomes the emotional crucible for the larger legal and moral conflict to come.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"The crew's farewell grief (Geordi, friends) thematically parallels Picard's later effort to humanize Data legally—both moments emphasize that Data's value is relational and experiential, not merely technical."
"The crew's farewell grief (Geordi, friends) thematically parallels Picard's later effort to humanize Data legally—both moments emphasize that Data's value is relational and experiential, not merely technical."
"The crew's farewell grief (Geordi, friends) thematically parallels Picard's later effort to humanize Data legally—both moments emphasize that Data's value is relational and experiential, not merely technical."
"The crew's farewell grief (Geordi, friends) thematically parallels Picard's later effort to humanize Data legally—both moments emphasize that Data's value is relational and experiential, not merely technical."
Themes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Key Dialogue
"GEORDI: Of course there is. You're going away."
"DATA: I shall... miss you."
"RIKER: There's got to be more to him than software, nets and chips."