Fabula
S1E15 · Celestial Navigation

If the Shoe Fits” Goes to the Wire

A brisk hallway scramble crystallizes into a political problem when Josh and Toby race to the Communications Office after HUD Secretary Deborah O'Leary's explosive remark. Toby orders a wire pull while Josh's half-joking defensiveness masks both satisfaction and danger. Mandy arrives with a confirming wire — O'Leary's 'If the shoe fits' line — which converts a containable gaffe into a live media story. The scene functions as a turning point: an offhand insult becomes verified copy, forcing the communications team to shift from triage to full crisis mode and signaling the escalation that will imperil the administration's agenda.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

5

Josh and Toby discuss HUD Secretary Deborah O'Leary's controversial comments about Congressman Wooden, revealing the political firestorm brewing.

curiosity to frustration ['Hallway']

Toby urgently requests Bonnie and Ginger to gather any wire stories about O'Leary's comments, escalating the crisis response.

urgency to impatience ['Communications Office']

Josh and Toby debate the implications of O'Leary's remarks, with Josh defending her while Toby remains critical.

defensiveness to sarcasm ['Communications Office']

Mandy enters with a wire story detailing O'Leary's explosive exchange with Wooden, confirming the worst fears of the staff.

anticipation to dismay ['Communications Office']

Toby reacts with sarcastic frustration to O'Leary's 'if the shoe fits' retort, underscoring the political damage done.

frustration to sarcasm ['Communications Office']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4
Bonnie
primary

Slightly flustered but focused, feeling the pressure of an urgent request and trying to calibrate resources to deliver quickly.

Bonnie answers Toby's demand for wires with practical questions and readiness; she represents the logistical arm, asking clarifying timing questions and prepared to fetch or pull the requested copy immediately.

Goals in this moment
  • to locate and deliver any existing wire copy about O'Leary's remark
  • to keep operations flowing under a sudden demand
Active beliefs
  • that speed and access to primary material is essential in crisis response
  • that clear instructions are necessary for staff to act effectively
Character traits
efficient practical responsive
Follow Bonnie's journey

Controlled irritation that hardens into professional alarm; focused on mitigation rather than moralizing the quote.

Toby moves immediately into triage mode: he asks for wire copy, snaps orders to Bonnie and Ginger, and retreats into his office to process the confirmed wording after Mandy reads the line aloud.

Goals in this moment
  • to obtain authoritative wire verification of the quote
  • to control the White House response before the press narrative solidifies
Active beliefs
  • that precise wording determines political fallout
  • that the communications shop must act fast to prevent a story from spinning out
Character traits
disciplined message-focused urgent
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey

Purposeful and slightly triumphant—she knows the import of handing over the wire and relishes being the one who presents the proof.

Mandy enters carrying a machine-printed wire sheet and reads the relevant passage aloud, supplying the physical evidence that transforms rumor into a verifiable media item and forcing the communications team to react.

Goals in this moment
  • to surface the wire copy so the communications team recognizes the story's immediacy
  • to leverage her access to influence the team's awareness and reaction
Active beliefs
  • that tangible, printed wire copy converts rumor into a news event
  • that delivering a scoop elevates her profile and helps the administration respond
Character traits
opportunistic media-savvy decisive
Follow Madeline Hampton's journey

Lightly amused and proud of O'Leary's moral courage, while aware that the remark contains danger for the administration.

Josh walks briskly into the Communications Office, half-smiling and defensive; he downplays the alarm while conceding the literal truth of O'Leary's remark and frames her as both baited and correct.

Goals in this moment
  • to explain and contextualize O'Leary's comment as baited and morally justified
  • to minimize reputational damage by framing the remark rather than panicking
Active beliefs
  • that O'Leary was provoked and her response is defensible
  • that political disputes around poverty are morally freighted and can be rhetorically reframed
Character traits
wry politically shrewd deflective
Follow Joshua Lyman's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Newswire Printout of HUD Secretary Deborah O'Leary's "If the Shoe Fits" Quote

A single-page wire printout functions as tactile proof: Mandy carries it into the room and reads the exact phrasing aloud. The sheet converts rumor and banter into verified copy, forcing an immediate tactical shift from speculation to response and anchoring the team's next steps.

Before: In Mandy's hand as she walks into the …
After: Still in Mandy's possession after reading aloud; it …
Before: In Mandy's hand as she walks into the Communications Office, recently printed and timestamped by a wire service.
After: Still in Mandy's possession after reading aloud; it now exists as a physical record in the room to be copied, filed, or used for crafting statements.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
West Wing Corridor (Exterior Hallway Outside Leo McGarry's Office)

The Communications Office serves as the operational center where hallway gossip is turned into newsroom reality. Its compact, cluttered space concentrates urgency: staff are summoned, phones and wire machines are the tools of triage, and the room becomes the site where messaging decisions crystallize.

Atmosphere Tense, focused, and claustrophobic — a small operational hub suddenly alert and procedural under time …
Function Crisis-management workspace and immediate staging area for shaping the administration's public response.
Symbolism Embodies the collision of private staff dynamics with public accountability; the office symbolizes the institution's …
Access Informally restricted to communications staff and senior aides during the scramble; controlled by Toby's instructions.
Cluttered desk with phones and briefing folders Wall monitors/C-SPAN playing live feeds Low lighting from desk lamps concentrating attention on material Hushed, clipped movements of staff crossing the doorway

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"TOBY: She called him a racist?"
"JOSH: She didn't use that word. TOBY: What word did she use? JOSH: Well, yes, she used that word."
"MANDY (reading): 'If the shoe fits,' responded the secretary."