Fabula
S1E3 · A Proportional Response

Laughter Between Thunder: Bartlet and Leo Recalibrate

In Leo's office, Bartlet's grief-tinged fury about the downed airliner erupts into a moral argument about retribution versus responsible power. Leo grounds him with pragmatic restraint, trading hard-edged historical and political counterpoints that defuse the President's desire for overwhelming force. Their clash culminates in a spontaneous, disarming laugh when Leo reads Congressman Bertram Coles' absurdly threatening radio remarks — a human moment that lightens the room, reasserts their intimacy, and steadies Bartlet. The beat also functions as a quiet setup: their attention shifts to the young man who found the President's glasses, planting the seed for a new aide's arrival.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Bartlet and Leo share a moment of levity over Bertram Coles' absurd comments, easing the tension.

challenge to levity

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

Raw grief erupting into righteous indignation, tempered by frustrated resignation and relieved levity

Seated in Leo's office, Bartlet erupts in impassioned rhetorical fury, invoking Roman citizenship and historical precedents to demand overwhelming military retribution; he concedes with bitter sarcasm, threatens playful violence, laughs heartily at Coles' threat, and inquisitively shifts focus to his lost glasses and potential new aide.

Goals in this moment
  • Vent personal anguish over Morris Tolliver's death to forge moral clarity
  • Provoke Leo into endorsing disproportionate force as national policy
Active beliefs
  • Unchecked restraint invites further American vulnerability abroad
  • True deterrence demands visible, overwhelming retribution like ancient Rome
Character traits
Intellectually ferocious Grief-stricken yet professorial Vulnerable in intimacy Quick to cathartic humor
Follow Josiah Edward …'s journey

Steadfast composure veiling empathetic resolve, lightened by shared ironic amusement

Leo seals the office for privacy, methodically counters Bartlet's rage with pragmatic historical analogies and superpower ethics, absorbs the baseball bat jest without flinching, pivots to Coles' radio absurdity for comic relief, and offers Charlie Young as the President's new body man with casual authority.

Goals in this moment
  • Steer Bartlet from vengeful overreach toward politically sustainable proportionality
  • Rebuild personal rapport through candor and levity amid crisis
Active beliefs
  • Superpower responsibility mandates measured, rebuildable responses over escalatory conquest
  • Historical interventions like Beirut prove rage-fueled force backfires catastrophically
Character traits
Unyieldingly principled Tactically paternal Dryly humorous under pressure Strategically deferential
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
Imaginary Baseball Bat

The baseball bat exists as a rhetorical, jocular threat when Bartlet says he could 'pommel [Leo] with a baseball bat.' It serves to dissolve severity into intimacy — a domestic, hyperbolic image that triggers shared laughter rather than violence.

Before: Not physically present; invoked verbally as a metaphorical …
After: Remains rhetorical; the line functions to relieve tension …
Before: Not physically present; invoked verbally as a metaphorical prop.
After: Remains rhetorical; the line functions to relieve tension and is not acted upon.
Roosevelt Room Double Doors (West Wing hallway → Roosevelt Room; brass knobs)

West Wing double doors are functionally present: Leo walks around and closes all the doors while talking, sealing the private conversation. The doors physically mark the transition from public crisis to a contained, senior-staff deliberation.

Before: Open or semi-open as staff move through West …
After: Closed and latched, creating privacy for the President …
Before: Open or semi-open as staff move through West Wing corridors.
After: Closed and latched, creating privacy for the President and Leo to argue candidly.
President Josiah 'Jed' Bartlet's Metal-Rim Reading Glasses

The President's metal-rim reading glasses function narratively as the small, human hinge that prompts the offstage 'kid' cameo and the closing exchange. Mentioning who found the glasses moves the scene from strategizing back to intimacy and personnel detail, symbolizing the return from grand moral argument to quotidian human concern.

Before: Absent from Bartlet's face (not immediately found), prompting …
After: Located (the kid has found them); possession implied …
Before: Absent from Bartlet's face (not immediately found), prompting earlier search and discovery by Mrs. Landingham/offstage staff.
After: Located (the kid has found them); possession implied to be returned to the President or nearby staff.
Coles District Radio Broadcast (Threat Program)

The Coles District radio broadcast is quoted by Leo as evidence of political threat and childish grandstanding. The radio remark transforms abstract threat into a concrete, quotable provocation that reorients the conversation toward damage control and legal/political response.

Before: Aired on a local station (existence reported to …
After: Becomes part of the administration's dossier on public …
Before: Aired on a local station (existence reported to staff); a printed/transcribed version is in-hand or in memory.
After: Becomes part of the administration's dossier on public provocation; prompts action from staff (Toby 'on it').

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

4
Leo McGarry's Office (Chief of Staff's Office)

Leo's Office is the intimate tactical chamber where strategy, grief and blunt counsel collide. Its closed doors, deep desk and close quarters allow private, emotionally frank exchange; the room converts Bartlet's private pain into operational decisions and lets Leo perform damage control.

Atmosphere Tension-heavy but disciplined; grief-laced urgency that eases into private camaraderie.
Function Meeting place for high-level counsel and containment of presidential impulse.
Symbolism Embodies institutional gravity and the domestic/operational boundary where personal grief must be translated into policy.
Access Effectively restricted to senior staff in this moment; doors are closed to exclude others.
Doors closed by Leo (audible latch) Low, private lighting implied (office at night feel) Paperwork and briefings present; coffee scent and leather chairs implied
Beirut, Lebanon

Beirut is invoked as a charged referent — the site of 286 fallen marines — used by Bartlet to argue that previous U.S. actions have cost lives and therefore demand moral accounting, not simply military calculus.

Atmosphere Evoked as a painful, accusatory memory rather than physically present.
Function Moral ledger and rhetorical touchstone in debate over proportionality.
Symbolism Represents prior failure and the human cost of foreign policy decisions.
Name spoken aloud as a wound Carries the weight of past casualty figures
Somalia

Somalia is cited as an example of messy intervention, a cautionary tale that Leo and Bartlet both use to illustrate the limits of force and the perils of rash escalation.

Atmosphere Summoned as a gritty, cautionary memory.
Function Historical counterweight shaping the argument for restraint.
Symbolism Signifies the cost and complexity of intervention.
Name used to evoke failed outcomes Functions as shorthand for geopolitical blowback
Nairobi, Kenya (city)

Nairobi is verbally referenced alongside Beirut and Somalia to compound Bartlet's point about repeated bloody outcomes; its mention cools the urge for instant, totalizing retribution.

Atmosphere A memory-laden invocation that dampens rhetorical heat.
Function Evidence in the moral argument against indiscriminate force.
Symbolism Marks the recurring, unresolved costs of American military action.
Name dropped as shorthand for past casualties Evokes international geography without physical description

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: In other words, Leo, what the hell are we doing here?"
"LEO: We are behaving the way a superpower ought to behave."
"BARTLET: Why didn't you say so? Oh man Leo. When I think of all the work you put in to get me to run... I could pommel your ass with a baseball bat."