Pentagon Leaks and Collective Responsibility

In the Oval Office at night Bartlet frames the Khundu intervention in moral terms—reciting Isaiah and softening tension with a private toast—while Leo brings the hard political reality: the Pentagon will leak casualty estimates and a found wreckage fragment to drive a narrative about lost lives. Bartlet acknowledges the likely fallout but reframes the choice as a shared burden—'we should all have a little skin in this'—and they lock a Sunday-noon timetable. The exchange cements political and operational commitment while setting up public credibility and casualty stakes.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Leo warns about impending Pentagon leaks regarding potential casualties in Khundu, escalating the stakes.

seriousness to resolve

Bartlet accepts the potential fallout, asserting collective responsibility for their decisions.

resolve to mutual understanding

Leo confirms the timeline for military action, solidifying their commitment to the plan.

understanding to resolution

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3

Morally resolved and quietly amused; uses wit to mask gravity while acknowledging potential political costs.

President Bartlet recites scripture to moralize intervention, pours and offers a drink, answers Leo with wry levity, accepts the political risk, and formally agrees to a Sunday-noon timetable, anchoring moral purpose to a concrete decision.

Goals in this moment
  • Frame Khundu intervention as a moral imperative rather than political maneuver.
  • Secure staff buy-in and a concrete timeline to move from private conviction to operational action.
Active beliefs
  • Moral arguments (scripture) can legitimize risky foreign policy choices.
  • Shared sacrifice is necessary to sustain the policy politically and ethically.
Character traits
moralistic wry resolute ceremonial in private moments
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Concerned and focused; anxious about leaks but composed enough to translate risk into actionable demands (a timetable).

Leo interrupts levity with blunt political reality: warning that Pentagon sources will leak casualty estimates and that search-and-rescue will 'find' a Gulfstream fragment; he presses the President for a timeline and secures a Sunday-noon commitment.

Goals in this moment
  • Expose and blunt anticipated Pentagon-driven narratives before they can define the debate.
  • Lock down a specific timetable to coordinate political and operational responses.
Active beliefs
  • The Pentagon (or its sources) will proactively shape public perception to favor its institutional interests.
  • Concrete deadlines and preparation reduce the damage of inevitable leaks and political attacks.
Character traits
pragmatic protective direct procedural
Follow Leo McGarry's journey
Isaiah
primary

Not an emotional actor here—serves as a steadying, righteous voice that Bartlet leans on to counter political calculation.

Isaiah is invoked by Bartlet as the moral authority framing the intervention; though not present, the prophet's words provide the ethical language that anchors Bartlet's justification.

Goals in this moment
  • Provide moral sanction for intervention decisions.
  • Shift the conversation from politics to duty and compassion.
Active beliefs
  • Scripture can legitimize state action in the face of atrocity.
  • Evocative religious language persuades both conscience and public opinion.
Character traits
authoritative (scriptural) moralizing timeless
Follow Isaiah's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Shareef's Gulfstream

A 'piece of a Gulfstream' is invoked by Leo as the physical evidence a search team will allegedly recover; narratively it functions as the promised, tangible hook the Pentagon will use to create a casualty story and undercut the administration's control of the narrative.

Before: Unknown fragment submerged or scattered in Khundu waters, …
After: Described as likely to be 'found' by rescuers …
Before: Unknown fragment submerged or scattered in Khundu waters, part of wider wreckage the Pentagon will later reference.
After: Described as likely to be 'found' by rescuers and used publicly to imply a coincident U.S. loss; in-scene it moves from hypothetical evidence to an imminent leak vector.
Bartlet and Leo's Lost Helicopter

The 'lost helicopter' is referenced as the search-and-rescue target whose operations provide cover for discovery of the Gulfstream fragment; it functions as the operational context that will be narrated to suggest American casualties and complicate public support.

Before: Missing in Khundu waters and the focus of …
After: Remains the nominal focus of search efforts; operational …
Before: Missing in Khundu waters and the focus of ongoing search-and-rescue operations.
After: Remains the nominal focus of search efforts; operational searches provide the plausible mechanism by which the Gulfstream piece is purportedly recovered and publicized.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Republic of Equatorial Kuhndu

Khundu is the distant theater whose human catastrophe motivates Bartlet's moral rhetoric and whose chaotic realities create the political leverage the Pentagon can exploit; it is the absent battleground that shapes the Oval Office exchange.

Atmosphere Implied chaos and urgency — ethnic violence and military operations create humanitarian imperative and political …
Function The crisis locus that justifies intervention and supplies the material (wreckage, casualty figures) that will …
Symbolism Represents moral obligation and the human stakes that force the administration's hand.
Access Military and humanitarian operations limit direct access; information flows are mediated through military and intelligence …
Imagined battlefield conditions: wreckage in water, active search-and-rescue efforts. Media attention and military movement making events there the focal point of international and domestic scrutiny.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
Pentagon

The Pentagon functions as the off-stage actor threatening to shape the public narrative: Leo warns that Pentagon sources will leak inflated casualty estimates and that operational actors will surface a wreckage fragment, thereby forcing the White House to respond politically and operationally.

Representation Through anonymous 'Pentagon sources' quoted in media and through the actions of military search-and-rescue teams …
Power Dynamics Acts as a semi-autonomous institutional counterweight to the White House, able to influence public perception …
Impact Highlights civil-military tension: the Pentagon's media maneuvers can force political reactions, complicating civilian command and …
Internal Dynamics Implied fractures between military actors and civilian leadership; factional behavior within the Pentagon leads to …
Protect institutional credibility and justify military perspectives and actions. Control the narrative around any American involvement or loss to shape policy and public opinion. Leaking casualty estimates and 'sources' to sympathetic reporters. Allowing or orchestrating operational findings (recovered wreckage) to be reported publicly as evidence.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Causal

"Leo's warning about political threats and NSC directives directly leads to his later discussion with Bartlet about Pentagon leaks and potential casualties, showing the escalating stakes of their decisions."

Bibles, Freemasons and a Warning Across the Bow
S4E15 · Inauguration Part II: Over There
Causal

"Leo's warning about political threats and NSC directives directly leads to his later discussion with Bartlet about Pentagon leaks and potential casualties, showing the escalating stakes of their decisions."

Midnight Warning: Leo Flags NSC PDD Vulnerability
S4E15 · Inauguration Part II: Over There

Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: Set free the oppressed, break every yoke, clothe the naked and your light shall break forth like the dawn, and the glory of the Lord shall be your rear guard."
"LEO: You can expect to see pieces quoting Pentagon sources on how many lives we'd lose in Khundu. And a search and rescue group, diving for a lost helicopter prop, is going to find a piece of a Gulfstream."
"BARTLET: I think you're wrong. But if you're right, then okay. We should all have a little skin in this."