Fabula
S2E8 · Shibboleth
S2E8
· Shibboleth

Bartlet's Turkey 'Pardon' Reversal and Education Sermon

Emerging into the Outer Oval Office, President Bartlet meets farmhand Morton and the homely turkey Troy, flanked by C.J. and Donna. He impulsively pardons the bird before revoking it with a passionate lecture to Morton on public education's necessity, decrying ignorance that mistakes tradition for law. Bartlet humorously 'drafts' Troy into military service and pledges compensation via signed check, blending farce with moral fervor. This levity humanizes Bartlet amid refugee crisis tensions, reveals his educator's zeal and wit as deflection, and transitions seamlessly as Josh and Sam arrive for urgent business, with C.J. managing the turkey's awkward exit.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

5

Bartlet meets Morton and Troy the turkey, initially pardoning the turkey with casual authority.

casual to authoritative ['Outer Oval Office']

Bartlet reverses his stance, declaring he cannot pardon a turkey, using the moment to lecture Morton on the importance of education.

authoritative to didactic ['Outer Oval Office']

Bartlet humorously drafts the turkey into military service, resolving the turkey pardon dilemma with a pragmatic solution.

didactic to humorous ['Outer Oval Office']

C.J. instructs Donna and Morton to handle Troy the turkey, showcasing her organizational role amidst the chaos.

humorous to practical ['Outer Oval Office']

Bartlet inquires about the turkey's condition, revealing his underlying concern amidst the absurdity.

practical to curious ['Outer Oval Office']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6
Troy
primary

Instinctively agitated amid human handling

Troy stands positioned before Donna and Morton near Charlie's desk, becomes direct object of Bartlet's pardon-then-draft decree and Constitution-invoked farce, handled by Morton with hindquarters supported during extraction to pen, embodying disruptive holiday whimsy.

Goals in this moment
  • Evade restraint and handling
  • Survive Beltway poultry ordeal
Active beliefs
  • Flight trumps captivity
  • Barnyard chaos defies protocol
Character traits
wing-flapping disruptiveness passive photogenic underdog touch-averse instincts
Follow Troy's journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Exasperated professionalism masking frustration with unfolding farce

C.J. introduces Morton to Bartlet, gestures urgently to intervene in the pardon, instructs Donna to escort Troy away while stressing hindquarter support, remains behind as Bartlet enters Oval, then heads to colonnade quipping about 'singing and lute playing' to defuse absurdity.

Goals in this moment
  • Contain the turkey pardon disruption swiftly
  • Transition Bartlet to urgent refugee briefing without delay
Active beliefs
  • Presidential rituals must adhere to protocol, not impulse
  • Staff must shield commander-in-chief from trivial distractions amid crises
Character traits
exasperated poise quick-witted protocol enforcer managerial competence
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Focused impatience tempered by deference

Sam enters Outer Oval with Josh as turkey farce peaks, holds up folder in response to Bartlet's prompt 'I'm still waiting for the thing,' follows into Oval Office, signaling seamless pivot from levity to refugee crisis urgency.

Goals in this moment
  • Deliver critical refugee documents promptly
  • Advance to Oval for high-stakes briefing
Active beliefs
  • Crisis demands precedence over ceremony
  • Preparation ensures presidential decisiveness
Character traits
urgent professionalism concise readiness loyal deference
Follow Sam Seaborn's journey

Surprised pleasure yielding to respectful acceptance

Morton huddles with Donna and Troy by Charlie's desk, reacts with awed 'Wow' to Bartlet, beams pleased at initial pardon, absorbs the education lecture stoically, agrees 'Okay' repeatedly, then picks up Troy supporting hindquarters and departs with Donna.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure fair compensation for farm losses
  • Fulfill delivery duty despite complications
Active beliefs
  • Presidential word carries compensatory weight
  • Tradition bends to authority's wisdom
Character traits
stoic rural determination pleased deference resigned accommodation
Follow Morton Horn's journey

playful then passionately fervent

Emerges from the Oval Office, greets Morton, impulsively pardons then revokes the pardon for turkey Troy while lecturing Morton on public education and ignorance of traditions versus law, humorously drafts the turkey into military service, promises a signed compensation check, and enters the Oval Office with Sam and Josh.

Goals in this moment
  • Impulsively engage in turkey pardon farce
  • Deliver impassioned lecture on public education to Morton
  • Transition to urgent business with Josh and Sam
Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey
Donna Moss
primary

Genuine surprise blending with steady compliance

Donna stands flanking Morton near Charlie's desk with Troy in front, confirms the turkey's identity when queried, expresses surprise at no-pardon revelation, then escorts Morton carrying the supported bird away per C.J.'s directive amid the chaotic exchange.

Goals in this moment
  • Verify turkey details accurately
  • Execute C.J.'s extraction order efficiently
Active beliefs
  • Presidential actions follow unexpected logics
  • Team coordination resolves West Wing absurdities
Character traits
unflappable logistics wide-eyed surprise dutiful assistant
Follow Donna Moss's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Donna's Folder

Sam holds up Donna's Folder—bulging with urgent refugee dispatches—as the key prop signaling transition from turkey absurdity to geopolitical gravity, embodying the narrative pivot where holiday farce yields to moral imperative, its heft underscoring refugee peril's pull on presidential focus.

Before: Held by Sam upon entry to Outer Oval …
After: Carried by Sam into Oval Office for briefing
Before: Held by Sam upon entry to Outer Oval Office
After: Carried by Sam into Oval Office for briefing

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
East Colonnade

East Colonnade looms as C.J. points to it for her wry 'singing and lute playing' exile of turkey chaos, injecting barnyard release into stone-pillared exhale; it beckons as liminal escape where released tension mingles laughter with Oval's shadowing refugee gravity.

Atmosphere Wry anticipation of absurd continuation
Function Anticipated site for farce offloading
Symbolism Exhale valve for White House pressure cooker
Access Semi-public staff thoroughfare
Filtered daylight shafts Weathered flagstone echoes Stately pillars framing urgency
Charlie's Desk

Charlie's Desk serves as proximity anchor where Donna and Morton huddle with thrashing Troy, feathers adrift across briefs amid flickering urgency; it frames the collision of rural delivery duty and Beltway protocol, heightening farce's intrusion on staff heartbeat.

Atmosphere Feathered frenzy clashing with polished protocol tension
Function Staging ground for turkey confrontation
Symbolism Sentinel of aide-level chaos amid presidential power
Access Restricted to West Wing staff and invitees
Polished wood amid stacked briefs Drifting feathers from Troy Flickering phone lines

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: (to the turkey) You're pardoned."
"BARTLET: Morton, I can't pardon a turkey. If you think I can pardon a turkey, then you have got to go back to your school and insist that you be better prepared to go out in the world."
"BARTLET: No. I tell you what I can do. I'm drafting this turkey into military service. In the meantime, somebody will be drafting a check, which will have my signature on it, so the folks can buy themselves a Butterball."