Fabula
S1E2 · Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc

Leo's Call — 'Anyone but Mandy'

A light, human moment between Donna and Josh is punctured when C.J. enters with urgent news: Leo will be ready in half an hour. The bullpen instantly snaps into West Wing mode. Josh probes C.J. about her call with Vice President Hoynes; C.J.'s clipped, repeated "We're fine" reads as careful diplomatic cover for a political bruise. Josh's single-line veto — "Anyone but Mandy" — converts a professional briefing into a charged personnel decision, exposing personal friction and setting the team's posture for the incoming presidential call. It functions as a tonal pivot from levity to crisis and a setup for ensuing conflict over Mandy's role.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

C.J. interrupts with a message about Leo’s readiness, pivoting the scene toward urgent West Wing business.

casual to professional

Josh probes C.J. about her conversation with Hoynes, revealing underlying tension and political concerns.

professional to uneasy

Josh emphatically opposes Mandy’s involvement, reintroducing personal conflict into the professional setting.

uneasy to defiant

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6
C.J. Cregg
primary

Surface calm and concise; internally guarded and practicing containment to prevent staff alarm.

C.J. approaches with procedural news — Leo will be ready in thirty minutes — and responds tersely to Josh's probes about Hoynes with repeated, clipped reassurances ('We're fine'), signaling deliberate containment and diplomatic cushioning of a likely bruising exchange.

Goals in this moment
  • Convey necessary logistics without escalating staff anxiety.
  • Reassure colleagues that the Hoynes discussion is not an immediate crisis while preserving confidentiality.
Active beliefs
  • Information should be calibrated to avoid unnecessary panic among staff.
  • The vice president's sensitivities can be managed with careful messaging and limited disclosure.
Character traits
controlled economical with words damage-aware
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Wry and mildly exasperated during banter; becomes guarded and controlling when the prospect of a sensitive call arises.

Josh starts in light banter about wagers and quickly flips into business mode: he interrogates C.J. about a call with Hoynes, presses for reassurance, and issues a decisive personnel veto — 'Anyone but Mandy' — signaling both tactical preference and personal distrust.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure the incoming presidential-related call is handled without creating new political damage.
  • Control staffing on the call to protect the administration's messaging and personnel dynamics.
Active beliefs
  • Personnel choices materially affect political outcomes and optics.
  • Mandy's presence on a high-stakes call would increase risk rather than mitigate it.
Character traits
decisive politically attentive protective of optics
Follow Joshua Lyman's journey
Donna Moss
primary

Amused and relaxed during banter; quietly alert and deferential when the work matter intrudes.

Donna moves through the bullpen bantering with Josh about the weekend pool, offering betting choices and trying to keep the mood light; she is present and listening when C.J. interrupts, registering the shift from levity to business rather than driving it.

Goals in this moment
  • Keep the social banter going and maintain camaraderie with Josh.
  • Remain available and composed once the office transitions into work mode.
Active beliefs
  • Small workplace rituals (like a betting pool) build morale and are worth preserving.
  • When senior staff intervene, protocol and chain-of-command will take precedence over casual conversation.
Character traits
playful sociable situationally aware
Follow Donna Moss's journey
John Hoynes

Hoynes is not in the room but is invoked as the other endpoint of C.J.'s earlier call; his presence is …

Leo Thomas McGarry (Chief of Staff)

Leo is not physically present but is the pivot of C.J.'s announcement; he is characterized as 'readying' himself and will …

Madeline Hampton

Mandy is not present in the scene but is explicitly vetoed by Josh as someone he does not want on …

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
West Wing Communications Bullpen (White House Communications Office)

The open-plan bullpen is both social space and operational hub: Donna and Josh move through it joking about a betting pool, and C.J.'s brief arrival transforms the same area into a staging ground for an imminent presidential-related call, concentrating attention and prompting staff readiness.

Atmosphere Shifts from light, convivial banter to taut, pragmatic focus; casual noise drops as staff prepare …
Function Meeting place and staging area for internal communications and rapid response coordination prior to the …
Symbolism Represents the porous boundary between staff informality and institutional seriousness—how personal moments are quickly subsumed …
Access Informally open to staff but functionally restricted by rank and the circle assembled for executive …
Open-plan desks and low partitions that make private moments public. Ambient television/briefing chatter and the hum of the West Wing, punctured by terse, work-focused dialogue.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Escalation medium

"Josh's lighthearted watching of C.J.'s briefing escalates to a more serious discussion about the need for strategic action regarding the media fallout, showing the progression from personal reactions to professional concerns."

Containment vs. Exposure: Josh, Sam and C.J. Collide
S1E2 · Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc
Escalation medium

"Josh's lighthearted watching of C.J.'s briefing escalates to a more serious discussion about the need for strategic action regarding the media fallout, showing the progression from personal reactions to professional concerns."

Sam's Call-Girl Confession — A Personal Problem Becomes Political Risk
S1E2 · Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: "Excuse me. Leo will be ready for us in about a half hour.""
"JOSH: "Did you talk to Hoynes?""
"JOSH: "Anyone but Mandy.""