Fabula
S3E9 · Bartlet for America (Restructured)

Leo Stonewalls Rathburn's Probes on Early MS Disclosure

Congressman Rathburn relentlessly questions Leo McGarry under the glare of the congressional hearing, pressing whether President Bartlet mentioned his health at all, specifically during their first office meeting or second at the Marriott. Leo delivers curt, unyielding 'No's each time, embodying his fierce loyalty and strategic denial. This terse exchange shields Bartlet from early cover-up charges, ratcheting tension by frustrating Rathburn's aggression and underscoring Leo's poised command amid existential political peril—a defensive turning point that pivots the inquiry toward hypotheticals.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Rathburn presses Leo about whether Bartlet disclosed his health condition during their initial meetings, and Leo firmly denies any such disclosure.

neutral to tension

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Exasperated impatience laced with concern for Leo's risky tactics.

Jordan huddles close as Leo covers his mic, responding to his absurd lunch banter with genuine confusion and insistence, urging him sharply to 'answer the question,' acting as his exasperated confidante and tactical check amid the hearing's tension.

Goals in this moment
  • Prompt Leo to directly address Rathburn's question
  • Support Leo's defense without enabling reckless stalling
Active beliefs
  • Direct answers minimize hearing risks more than evasion
  • Leo's loyalty must be tempered with strategic discipline
Character traits
assertive loyal pragmatic
Follow Jordan Kendall's journey
Shanahan
primary

Feigned casual composure masking fierce protectiveness and calculated resolve.

Leo sits composed at the witness stand, delivering curt 'No's to direct questions on Bartlet's health disclosures, covers his mic to whisper strategy with Jordan, stalls via lunch banter and feigned forgetfulness, repeating 'I don't know' to the hypothetical, masterfully controlling the exchange.

Goals in this moment
  • Shield Bartlet from early disclosure accusations
  • Delay and deflect Rathburn's line of inquiry through stalling
Active beliefs
  • Absolute loyalty to Bartlet demands total denial
  • Tactical evasion preserves political integrity under scrutiny
Character traits
composed strategic loyal witty
Follow Shanahan's journey
Rathburn
primary

Aggressively frustrated, barely containing irritation at Leo's evasions.

Rathburn relentlessly questions Leo from the committee dais, pressing on health disclosures in past meetings and a hypothetical about Bartlet's candidacy, growing impatient and calling out 'Mr. McGarry' as Leo stalls, embodying prosecutorial aggression in the hearing.

Goals in this moment
  • Elicit admission of early cover-up knowledge from Leo
  • Force Leo into damaging hypothetical concession on Bartlet's fitness
Active beliefs
  • Leo is withholding critical information about Bartlet's health
  • Persistent pressure will crack executive stonewalling
Character traits
aggressive persistent impatient
Follow Rathburn's journey

N/A (referenced only)

Jed Bartlet is invoked hypothetically by Rathburn's questions about health disclosures in past meetings and candidacy support, absent physically but central to the interrogation's stakes as Leo denies any mention.

Character traits
stoic assertive resolute loyal compassionate
Follow Leo McGarry's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Agent's Communication Mic

Leo covers the compact mic with his hand to create a private whisper channel with Jordan, enabling off-record strategy talk and lunch banter amid Rathburn's probing; it symbolizes fleeting privacy in the public hearing glare, functionally shielding sensitive counsel while heightening tension over potential leaks.

Before: Active and exposed at Leo's lips in the …
After: Covered briefly then uncovered, resuming open transmission position
Before: Active and exposed at Leo's lips in the witness stand
After: Covered briefly then uncovered, resuming open transmission position

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
House Hearing Room

The House Hearing Room hosts Rathburn's aggressive cross-examination of Leo at the witness stand, with Jordan huddled nearby; its formal setup amplifies the interrogation's intensity, camera glare underscoring public scrutiny as Leo's mic-covering stall unfolds, turning the space into a high-stakes gladiatorial arena for loyalty and evasion.

Atmosphere Tense and pressurized, thick with anticipation and frustrated interruptions.
Function Venue for congressional interrogation and testimony
Symbolism Microcosm of political accountability and executive defiance
Access Restricted to committee members, witnesses, staff, and press
Sunlight filtering through panels casting solemn glow Camera focused intently on witness stand Echoing voices and impatient calls across the room
Marriott

The Marriott is referenced by Rathburn as site of Leo and Bartlet's second meeting, invoked to probe for health disclosure; it lingers as a shadow of private political intimacy now weaponized in public scrutiny, contrasting the hearing room's exposure with past confidentiality.

Atmosphere N/A (referenced past location)
Function Recalled site of pivotal past conversation under question
Symbolism Emblem of concealed executive deliberations now exposed to inquiry
Access N/A (historical reference)
Upscale hotel corridors implied in backstory Private meeting space contrasting hearing publicity

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"RATHBURN: "He never mentioned his health?" LEO: "No.""
"RATHBURN: "Not during the first meeting in his office?" LEO: "No.""
"RATHBURN: "Not during the second meeting at the Marriott?" LEO: "No.""