Fabula
S3E14 · Hartsfield's Landing

Josh Dispatches Reluctant Donna to Reclaim Flender Votes

In a tense late-night summons, Josh reveals Jennifer Flender's email confirming her parents' defection to Ritchie in the prophetic Hartsfield's Landing primary. Amid Donna's sharp jealousy over Josh's flirtation and ethical qualms about voter pressure, he relentlessly pushes her to call them, emphasizing the symbolic stakes of those 42 votes dominating news cycles. Equipping her with his coat for a cell-phone call in Lafayette Park, this beat exposes Josh's obsessive drive for micro-victory amid national crisis, straining their dynamic while setting up Donna's pivotal outreach and his eventual growth in respecting democracy.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

6

Josh calls for Donna urgently, revealing his frustration as she takes her time to respond.

frustration to urgency ["Josh's office"]

Josh informs Donna that the Flenders, a family they know, are voting for Ritchie, which alarms him given the symbolic importance of Hartsfield's Landing.

concern to alarm

Donna questions why Jennifer Flender emails Josh, leading to a brief, tense exchange about his past interactions with her.

suspicion to tension

Josh emphasizes the critical nature of the Flenders' votes in Hartsfield's Landing and pressures Donna to intervene.

urgency to pressure

Donna reluctantly agrees to contact the Flenders but points out the logistical and ethical constraints of using government resources for this purpose.

reluctance to resolve ['Lafayette Park']

Donna insists on taking Josh's coat for her mission, ending the scene with a light-hearted yet determined exchange.

determination to light-heartedness

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5
Josh Lyman
primary

Determined intensity laced with frustrated urgency

Seated at his desk by the computer writing, Josh summons Donna twice, reveals the Flender email betrayal, hands her the contact paper, relentlessly insists she call them from a cell in Lafayette Park to flip their votes, corrects her on details with wry humor, and yields his coat as she exits.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure the Flenders' votes to win Hartsfield's Landing
  • Overcome Donna's resistance to execute the outreach
Active beliefs
  • Every single vote in a symbolic primary can define the national narrative
  • Retail politics demands personal connection over ethics in tight races
Character traits
determined insistent witty manipulative principled under pressure
Follow Josh Lyman's journey
Flenders
primary

Grievance-driven disloyalty (inferred)

Mack and Roberta Flender invoked as tackle shop owners whose defection to Ritchie—revealed via daughter's email—spurs the outreach mission; prior hospitality to Donna noted as leverage.

Goals in this moment
  • Vote against Bartlet due to personal issues
Active beliefs
  • Administration policies harm local economy
Character traits
defiant locally rooted anti-northerner
Follow Flenders's journey

Vulnerable to micro-defections (inferred)

The President referenced as target of Flenders' grievances, whose two votes Josh desperately seeks to reclaim for symbolic primary win.

Goals in this moment
  • Dominate Hartsfield's Landing for narrative momentum
Active beliefs
  • Small victories portend national triumph
Character traits
besieged incumbent
Follow Abigail Bartlet's journey

Jealous sharpness yielding to reluctant resolve

Bursts into Josh's office nearly hitting him with the door, probes jealously about Jennifer's crush and sleeping with her, raises ethical qualms on voter intimidation via government phone, reluctantly agrees after his pressure, grabs his coat, and heads out to make the cell call.

Goals in this moment
  • Avoid crossing ethical lines in voter contact
  • Support Josh's campaign imperative despite personal qualms
Active beliefs
  • Government resources cannot be used for voter pressure
  • Personal connections from prior visits can sway the Flenders
Character traits
jealous sharp-witted ethical loyal resigned
Follow Donnatella Moss's journey

Threatening momentum (inferred)

Referenced repeatedly as the rival gaining the Flenders' votes in Hartsfield's Landing, fueling Josh's urgency without physical presence.

Goals in this moment
  • Capture symbolic Hartsfield's Landing victory
Active beliefs
  • Local defections signal broader primary weakness
Character traits
aggressive challenger
Follow Rob Ritchie's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Donna's Cell Phone

Josh mandates Donna use her personal cell phone for the Flender call to evade government logs, elevating it as the covert instrument of political salvage in this ethics-skirting gambit for Hartsfield's edge.

Before: With Donna or unspecified
After: Designated for immediate use in Lafayette Park
Before: With Donna or unspecified
After: Designated for immediate use in Lafayette Park
Josh's Piece of Paper with Flender Contact Information

Josh hands Donna this creased paper bearing Mack and Roberta Flender's contact numbers, transforming it from desk prop to mission-critical tool for voter reconquest, symbolizing the granular stakes of retail politics in a high-wire primary.

Before: On Josh's desk in his office
After: In Donna's possession as she exits to Lafayette …
Before: On Josh's desk in his office
After: In Donna's possession as she exits to Lafayette Park
Josh's Government Phone

Donna identifies Josh's government phone as unusable for voter pressure due to traceability rules, prompting the pivot to cell phone; it underscores ethical boundaries and institutional constraints amid frantic politicking.

Before: In Josh's office, available on desk
After: Untouched in office, rejected for mission
Before: In Josh's office, available on desk
After: Untouched in office, rejected for mission

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Hartsfield's Landing Polling Counter

Hartsfield's Landing looms as the prophetic polling ground where Flenders' two votes could tip 21 hours of national coverage; Josh obsesses over its 12:01 cast and 12:07 count, making it the event's symbolic battleground.

Atmosphere Frost-edged, high-stakes small-town forge (anticipated)
Function Symbolic primary victory site
Symbolism Microcosm of national election peril
Midnight voting under 'America's first primary' banner Live TV cheers for each ballot
Lafayette Park (adjacent to the White House, protest site)

Josh directs Donna to Lafayette Park for the cell call, its public anonymity shielding the voter outreach from White House scrutiny; evokes exposure and improvisation, contrasting office intensity with street-level grit amid night chill.

Atmosphere Shadowy, wind-lashed exposure near media glare
Function Secure, traceless calling spot
Symbolism Bridge between institutional power and raw retail politics
Access Public but surveilled by proximity to White House
Nighttime chill requiring coat Proximity to reporters and traffic roar

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 1
Character Continuity medium

"Josh's initial alarm over the Flenders voting for Ritchie evolves into his acceptance of their democratic right, showing his character growth."

Josh Interrupts: Let the Flenders Vote Freely
S3E14 · Hartsfield's Landing

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"JOSH: "The daughter just e-mailed me and told me her parents are voting for Ritchie.""
"DONNA: "You didn't sleep with the Flender girl, did you?" JOSH: "She's twenty years old.""
"JOSH: "Cell phone, Lafayette Park, and a warm coat.""