Fabula
S2E13 · Bartlet's Third State of the Union

C.J. Ambush-Interrogates Sloane on Buried Excessive Force Scandal

In Carol's office amid post-SOTU chaos, C.J. abruptly confronts hero cop Jack Sloane about his undisclosed 17-year-old reprimand for allegedly kicking handcuffed suspect Walter Tapus repeatedly, fracturing his leg. Sloane, stricken and defensive, insists it was self-defense against a larger, athletic robber who injured him first, pleading his recent heroism, family needs, and assumption of amnesty. C.J., embodying press secretary pragmatism, rejects his denials and mercy pleas, vowing proactive disclosure to preempt media discovery and seize narrative control— a pivotal ethical standoff heightening the administration's crisis vulnerability.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

6

C.J. confronts Officer Sloane about a 17-year-old reprimand for excessive force, initiating a tense exchange about his past actions.

professional to tense ["C.J.'s office"]

Sloane defends himself, claiming self-defense against a physically formidable suspect, Walter Tapus, and questions the motivation behind reviving the old accusations.

defensive to desperate

C.J. presses Sloane on why he didn't disclose his record before being honored at the White House, highlighting a breach of trust.

accusatory to regretful

Sloane, visibly shaken, pleads his innocence and expresses dismay that his past is resurfacing, emphasizing his current status as a community hero.

desperate to resigned

C.J. firmly informs Sloane that she must disclose the information to the press to control the narrative, despite his protests.

resolute to somber

Sloane, defeated, mentions his family at the party, highlighting the personal cost of the impending scandal, as C.J. advises him to return to them silently.

resigned to despair

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

6
Jack
primary

Stricken discomfort blending defensive fury and plaintive desperation.

Waits in adjacent office, responds uncomfortably to greeting, shakes hands, sits, recounts chase details defensively emphasizing self-injury and Tapus's size/athleticism, pleads recent heroism, family at party, and assumed amnesty, looks stricken at disclosure news, agrees to silence.

Goals in this moment
  • Convince C.J. of self-defense to avoid disclosure
  • Preserve hero status and family evening amid scrutiny
Active beliefs
  • Recent school heroism erases past allegations
  • Physical mismatch proves no excessive force occurred
Character traits
defensive plaintive uncomfortable earnest
Follow Jack's journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Pragmatic resolve masking urgency, steely focus on crisis management.

Sweeps into office, confirms Sloane's presence, shakes hands, sits abruptly, interrogates about Tapus incident with pointed accusations, rejects denials and pleas, vows proactive press disclosure for narrative control, instructs silence and return to party.

Goals in this moment
  • Preempt press discovery of Sloane's past
  • Control the scandal narrative through proactive disclosure
Active beliefs
  • Non-disclosure amplifies vulnerability to media exploitation
  • Presidential spotlight demands full transparency on exemplars
Character traits
pragmatic resolute direct unyielding
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey
Carol
primary

Calm and neutral professionalism.

Stands vigilantly in her office as C.J. passes, crisply confirms Sloane's presence with 'Yeah,' facilitating the ambush confrontation.

Goals in this moment
  • Relay access for C.J.'s urgent interrogation
  • Maintain operational flow in press office
Active beliefs
  • Prompt confirmation enables crisis response
  • Discretion protects White House processes
Character traits
professional poised efficient
Follow Carol's journey

Portrayed historically as combative during arrest.

Heavily invoked in dialogue as the athletic armed robbery suspect Sloane pursued and allegedly kicked repeatedly while cuffed, fracturing his leg; cited in lawsuit and motive to lie.

Goals in this moment
  • null
  • null
Active beliefs
  • null
  • null
Character traits
aggressive athletic vindictive
Follow Walter Tapus's journey

referenced as having pointed to Sloane as an example

Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

referenced as unable to bring a case against Sloane; civil suit dismissed

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Carol's Office

Dimly lit night bastion hosts the abrupt ambush: Carol stands sentinel, Sloane waits in adjacent inner sanctum, C.J. surges in for handshake, chair-scraping sit-down, tense interrogation over scandal; shadows amplify ethical clash, funneling post-SOTU chaos into intimate crisis choreography.

Atmosphere Heavy shadows and thickening tension, night pressing with stark relief and ethical urgency.
Function Private confrontation and interrogation site.
Symbolism Ethical firewall and vulnerability nexus in White House comms.
Access Restricted to press staff and summoned guests like Sloane.
Night shadows carving stark relief Chairs scraping into position Intimate confines amplifying personal stakes
Warehouse Rear Storage Areas

Vividly recalled by Sloane in defensive recount: chain-link fences, storage areas behind warehouse as savage chase site where he pursued Tapus, grappled during cuffing, amid self-injury claims blurring heroism and excess into 17-year echo.

Atmosphere Evoked as gritty, sweat-thick urban frenzy with diesel tang and concrete scars.
Function Referenced past incident locus anchoring dispute.
Symbolism Brutal threshold of contested violence haunting present optics.
Cracked pavement and chain-link fences Rusted crates looming in warehouse rear

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
Bartlet Administration (Executive Office of the President)

Embodies the administrative crucible where C.J. enforces protocol on unvetted SOTU guest Sloane, protecting presidential example from scandal bleed; pulls hero from party for interrogation, balancing heroism optics against transparency imperatives in post-address frenzy.

Representation Via Press Secretary C.J. Cregg executing crisis choreography.
Power Dynamics Exerting institutional authority over individual Sloane, prioritizing narrative shield.
Impact Highlights comms firewall strains amid heroic invitations.
Internal Dynamics Press office relaying Oval strategies through gatekept confrontations.
Safeguard Bartlet's SOTU triumphs from scandal erosion Maintain proactive control over emerging vulnerabilities Press disclosure protocols Senior staff access and summons
Press Corps

Looms as predatory external force driving C.J.'s disclosure vow; their inevitable discovery threatens to twist Sloane's heroism into brutality narrative, forcing White House preemption to 'stay ahead of the pitch' and control story spin.

Representation Referenced as headline-hungry swarm C.J. must brief proactively.
Power Dynamics Challenging White House opacity, compelling reactive transparency.
Impact Underscores media's power to fracture policy victories.
Unearth hidden scandals for maximum impact Amplify partisan rifts in SOTU afterglow Investigative scrutiny and rapid dissemination Optics pressure on public exemplars

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 3
Causal

"Josh's revelation of Jack Sloane's past reprimand sets the stage for C.J.'s confrontation with Sloane about the same issue."

Josh Drops Sloane's Excessive Force Bombshell
S2E13 · Bartlet's Third State of the …
Causal

"Josh's revelation of Jack Sloane's past reprimand sets the stage for C.J.'s confrontation with Sloane about the same issue."

Josh's Polling Impatience Clashes with Donna's Matchmaking
S2E13 · Bartlet's Third State of the …
Causal medium

"C.J.'s deflection of Mark's inquiry about the First Lady's activities leads to her eventual confrontation with Sloane about his past reprimand, as she seeks to control the narrative."

C.J. Deflects Sloane Probe, Crisis Summons
S2E13 · Bartlet's Third State of the …

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: "So you fractured his leg." SLOANE: "I didn't fracture his leg.""
"SLOANE: "He was 19 years old. 6'2"...190 pounds. And he won 2 bronze medals at the State High School Track and Field Championships. Miss Cregg, look at me. Do you think there's any way I catch up to this guy if his leg isn't fractured already? It didn't happen.""
"C.J.: "No, but I have to tell them." SLOANE: "Why?" C.J.: "Cause they'll find out and I have to stay ahead of the pitch. If I issue it in a brief statement then it looks like we're not trying to hide anything and I get to control the story for a while.""