Bartlet's Confession and Reluctant Democratic Concession

In the President's bedroom, Bartlet confesses to C.J. that retaking the House isn't his focus—his moral outrage fixates on opponent Elliot Roush polling at 53% in a New Hampshire school board race, revealing principle trumping political calculus. C.J. counters with democratic ethos, insisting 'the other people win' sometimes. Bartlet yields after a weighted pause, resolving his impasse and greenlighting staff midterm strategies. This turning-point revelation exposes his ethical priorities, bridging personal conviction to collective action.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Bartlet declares his disinterest in winning back the House, exposing his moral preoccupation over Roush's lead in the polls.

defiance to confrontation

Bartlet reflects on Roush's character and polls, revealing personal stakes, while C.J. reinforces democratic principles, leading to Bartlet's reluctant concession.

intensity to resignation

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4
C.J. Cregg
primary

Composed insistence veiling strategic concern for institutional stability

Enters the bedroom after knock, closes door, sits across from Bartlet, firmly articulates ethical and political risks of intervening in local race, invokes democratic principles to reframe his outrage, secures his agreement, then departs gracefully.

Goals in this moment
  • Prevent presidential endorsement in local election to avoid backlash
  • Redirect Bartlet's focus from personal fixation to midterm House strategy
Active beliefs
  • Presidential neutrality in local races preserves fairness and democracy
  • Partisan unity demands prioritizing national over personal battles
Character traits
principled composed strategic eloquent
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Steadfast loyalty in routine service

Referenced briefly by C.J. as the aide who summoned her at Bartlet's request, underscoring his role in facilitating this critical late-night private counsel amid post-assassination staff dynamics.

Goals in this moment
  • Relay presidential summons efficiently
  • Maintain seamless staff communication
Active beliefs
  • Personal aide's duty binds inner circle operations
  • Prompt relay prevents operational delays
Character traits
dutiful reliable
Follow Charlie Young's journey

Object of Bartlet's seething moral outrage and disdain

Invoked repeatedly as Bartlet's fixation—the New Hampshire school board frontrunner polling at 53%, contrasted against ideals of faith and wisdom—driving the confrontation over national coverage and intervention.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure school board seat victory
  • Leverage frontrunner momentum
Active beliefs
  • Local races reward aggressive polling leads
  • Past rivalries fuel personal campaigns
Character traits
polarizing unprincipled (per Bartlet's view)
Follow Elliot Roush's journey

fixated and outraged, then resigned

sits reading papers, questions C.J. on lack of national press coverage for Elliot Roush's school board race, declares disinterest in winning back the House, yields after pause

Goals in this moment
  • escalate confrontation over Roush coverage to declaration of disinterest in House (escalation)
  • maintain obsession with Roush school board race (continuity)
Character traits
protective resolute self-aware principled
Follow Josiah Bartlet's journey

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
New Hampshire (Bartlet's home state — early primary political destination)

New Hampshire crystallizes as the emotional epicenter, site of Elliot Roush's school board race where his 53% lead ignites Bartlet's principled fury, elevating a local contest into a test of presidential restraint and democratic ethos during national midterm frenzy.

Atmosphere Remote arena of moral-political tension
Function Origin point of the inciting controversy
Symbolism Microcosm of democracy's unforgiving arithmetic clashing with personal conviction
Access Local electoral jurisdiction beyond presidential direct sway
Primary battleground for school board polls Echoes of past New Hampshire campaigns

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

5
U.S. House of Representatives

Bartlet explicitly declares disinterest in 'winning back the House,' clashing with staff strategy; C.J. reframes it as core democratic priority, highlighting the chamber as midterm battleground where distraction risks stasis despite post-assassination surge.

Representation As pivotal electoral prize in dialogue
Power Dynamics Institutional target subordinated to personal moral pivot
Impact Locks power in ironic equilibrium
Shift balance via 12 targeted races Leverage surge for Democratic flips Incumbent defense and flips Resource-intensive campaign triage
Democratic Party

C.J. invokes Democrats' fears of abandonment if Bartlet fixates on local race, underscoring party reliance on White House solidarity for midterm gains, where perceived disinterest erodes fragile alliances in razor-edge races.

Representation Via congressional members' anticipated disillusionment
Power Dynamics Dependent allies vulnerable to leadership distraction
Impact Threatens net-zero midterm outcome
Secure House majority through coordinated effort Maintain White House commitment to key races Electoral resource allocation pressure Party loyalty appeals to leadership
Republican Congressional Candidates

C.J. warns that presidential intervention will galvanize Republicans, supercharging their midterm opposition and risking House control, framing them as opportunistic foes ready to exploit ethical lapses amid post-assassination momentum.

Representation Through projected partisan reaction in C.J.'s caution
Power Dynamics Empowered adversaries poised to capitalize on White House vulnerability
Impact Heightens midterm trench warfare stasis
Claw back House seats in midterms Amplify Democratic missteps for advantage Partisan mobilization against overreach Congressional pressure via unified front
New Hampshire School Board

The New Hampshire School Board race anchors Bartlet's outrage, with Roush's candidacy as seat's frontrunner prompting demands for national spotlight, clashing against norms of non-interference in this hyper-local governance body.

Representation Via contested electoral seat in debate
Power Dynamics Local authority tempting undue executive overreach
Impact Tests boundaries of national-local interplay
Elect principled board members Conduct fair local elections Polling-driven frontrunner momentum Community policy jurisdiction
United States Department of Commerce

Congress emerges as collateral in C.J.'s warning—Republicans galvanized, Democrats alienated—positioning it as arena where local meddling fractures midterm discipline, testing White House influence over legislative power dynamics.

Representation Through partisan factions in political calculus
Power Dynamics Overarching body swayed by presidential focus
Impact Inertia amid ethical distractions
Internal Dynamics Partisan fissures over strategy
Partisan control via midterm results Resist or harness executive interventions Partisan bloc pressure Electoral survival incentives

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 3
Character Continuity medium

"Bartlet's obsession with the Elliot Roush school board race is consistent throughout, culminating in his discussion with C.J. about it."

Bartlet's Roush Obsession Ignites Staff Friction
S2E3 · The Midterms
Character Continuity medium

"Bartlet's obsession with the Elliot Roush school board race is consistent throughout, culminating in his discussion with C.J. about it."

C.J.'s Unvoiced Aftermath Worry Interrupted by Urgent Beeper
S2E3 · The Midterms
Escalation medium

"Bartlet's initial confrontation with C.J. about Roush escalates to his declaration of disinterest in winning back the House, showing his deepening moral preoccupation."

Bartlet Demands Roush Coverage, Dismisses House Strategy
S2E3 · The Midterms
What this causes 1
Escalation medium

"Bartlet's initial confrontation with C.J. about Roush escalates to his declaration of disinterest in winning back the House, showing his deepening moral preoccupation."

Bartlet Demands Roush Coverage, Dismisses House Strategy
S2E3 · The Midterms

Key Dialogue

"BARTLET: "I don't care about winning back the House!""
"BARTLET: "Elliot Roush... is polling at 53%. He's polling at 53%. He's the front runner.""
"C.J.: "Then that's the way it is. In a democracy, oftentimes, the other people win.""