Fabula
S2E8 · Shibboleth
S2E8
· Shibboleth

CJ Snatches Donna as INS Alert Drops Amid Turkey Chaos

In Josh's bullpen, CJ urgently borrows Donna from her desk, brushing past Josh amid banter over the turkey pardoning schedule and CJ's looming children's song lead—revealing her flustered vulnerability. As they're pulled away, Donna casually warns Josh of imminent INS agents, injecting refugee crisis urgency into the holiday farce. At CJ's door, CJ confesses ignorance of 'We Gather Together,' bantering self-deprecatingly about her credentials before prioritizing a final turkey audition inside her office. She picks unflappable Eric over Troy's flapping, muttering unsettlingly to the birds, as Donna returns with practical handling tips. This beat masterfully juxtaposes White House absurdities against brewing diplomatic peril, humanizing CJ while teeing up the INS confrontation.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

C.J. urgently pulls Donna away from her desk, revealing her need for immediate assistance with an upcoming turkey pardoning event.

routine to urgency ["Josh's bullpen area"]

Josh interrupts with logistical confusion about the turkey pardoning schedule, highlighting the chaotic overlap of White House obligations.

urgency to exasperation

Donna drops a bombshell about imminent INS agents while being dragged away, creating narrative tension between ceremonial duties and political crisis.

exasperation to tension

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4
Eric
primary

Stoically indifferent to flashing chaos

Eric endures the final camera flash test inside CJ's office without flapping, securing victory as CJ announces him the pardon pick, then resists dismounting from chair as CJ and Donna wrangle him toward Rose Garden fate.

Goals in this moment
  • Survive audition stresses without panic
  • Maintain perch amid human prodding
Active beliefs
  • Stillness trumps frenzy in selection
  • Chair offers secure vantage
Character traits
unflappable composed resistant
Follow Eric's journey
Troy
primary

Agitated by lights and exclusion

Troy undergoes flash audition alongside Eric but disqualifies via frantic flapping noises, sidelined by CJ during Eric's handling as she blocks his advance, embodying the chaotic energy CJ rejects.

Goals in this moment
  • Compete aggressively in audition
  • Push forward despite rejection
Active beliefs
  • Flapping asserts dominance
  • Proximity to chair ensures chance
Character traits
frantic flapping disruptive
Follow Troy's journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Flustered poise cracking into self-deprecating vulnerability under multilayered pressures

CJ barrels into the bullpen to borrow Donna, banters teasingly with Josh about turkey schedule and her song-leading dread, confesses hymn ignorance with self-deprecating wit at her door, then enters office to flash-audition turkeys, selects Eric decisively while blocking Troy, wrangles the winner off chair amid awkward mutterings.

Goals in this moment
  • Finalize turkey pardon selection to avoid Oval mishaps
  • Secure quick song lesson covertly before CNN exposure
Active beliefs
  • Holiday rituals demand unflappable performers like Eric
  • Her intellect doesn't extend to folksy traditions like hymns
Character traits
flustered witty self-deprecating decisive vulnerable
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey
Donna Moss
primary

Calmly pragmatic amid encroaching chaos

Donna stands rifling her folder at desk, agrees to be borrowed by CJ, warns Josh of INS arrival en route, suggests 'We Gather Together' and alternatives with a sigh, later returns to office offering hindquarter-handling tips while aiding Eric's dismount.

Goals in this moment
  • Assist CJ with immediate crises from song to turkey
  • Alert Josh to INS urgency before it escalates
Active beliefs
  • Everyone should know basic hymns like 'We Gather Together'
  • Practical handling prevents turkey mishaps
Character traits
helpful practical patient knowing
Follow Donna Moss's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

3
Donna's Folder

Donna's Folder serves as her desk prop during initial rifling, grounding her in routine admin amid CJ's interruption; its dense papers symbolize layered crises clashing with turkey farce, yanking her into the event's frenzy before she's pulled away.

Before: On Donna's desk in bullpen, being examined standing
After: Left unattended on desk as Donna departs
Before: On Donna's desk in bullpen, being examined standing
After: Left unattended on desk as Donna departs
C.J.'s Turkey Audition Camera Flash

CJ waves and triggers the camera flash as the decisive audition tool inside her office, blasting Eric and Troy to test photo composure; its blinding bursts expose Troy's flapping disqualification, heightening CJ's vulnerability while propelling pardon ritual forward.

Before: In CJ's possession, ready in office
After: Held by CJ post-audition, flashes ceased
Before: In CJ's possession, ready in office
After: Held by CJ post-audition, flashes ceased
C.J.'s Office Chair

CJ's Office Chair becomes Eric's defiant perch for the flash test and subsequent wrangling battle; CJ snaps fingers and prods while Donna supports hindquarters, transforming it into a chaotic arena where avian poise is extracted amid feathers and frustration.

Before: Occupied by Eric in CJ's office
After: Vacated as Eric is removed, Troy restrained nearby
Before: Occupied by Eric in CJ's office
After: Vacated as Eric is removed, Troy restrained nearby

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Josh's West Wing Bullpen

Josh's Bullpen Area launches the event as Donna's desk anchors her folder perusal, CJ's recruitment, and banter-passing of Josh with INS warning drop; its cluttered desks pulse with West Wing frenzy, bridging holiday levity to diplomatic peril.

Atmosphere Bustling with casual interruptions and underlying urgency
Function Starting hub for recruitment and crisis alert
Symbolism Embodies staff chaos where farce meets policy thunder
Access Open to West Wing staff circulation
Desks scarred by policy wars Ambient staff bedlam and turkey echoes

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
CNN International

CNN amplifies CJ's dread as she snaps about conducting a 'musical on CNN' during song confession, framing her vulnerability; the network's broadcast glare elevates turkey/song rituals into national spectacle, clashing with INS shadows.

Representation Through looming live coverage invoked in dialogue
Power Dynamics Dictating public optics over White House ceremonies
Impact Forces polished farce amid crisis under media microscope
Capture feel-good holiday moments Scrutinize staff performances live Broadcast exposure pressure Public verdict via airtime
Immigration and Naturalization Service (I.N.S.)

INS looms as Donna casually warns Josh of their imminent arrival amid turkey banter, injecting refugee crisis gravity into the bullpen's holiday absurdity; their procedural shadow foreshadows briefings, heightening stakes as staff juggles pomp with peril.

Representation Via off-screen agents invoked by Donna's alert
Power Dynamics Exerting impending authority over White House schedule
Impact Amplifies tension between mercy optics and smuggling realities
Deliver urgent refugee updates Enforce credible fear protocols on Chinese evangelicals Procedural handoff pressure Imminent physical arrival disrupting routine

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Temporal medium

"Josh's deflection with Thanksgiving plans is immediately followed by Donna's bombshell about the INS agents, highlighting the overlap of crises."

Leo Urgently Briefed on Stowaway Crisis, Orders C.J. Alert
S2E8 · Shibboleth
Temporal medium

"Josh's deflection with Thanksgiving plans is immediately followed by Donna's bombshell about the INS agents, highlighting the overlap of crises."

Josh Briefs C.J. on Refugee Crisis and Toby's Prayer Fight Gambit
S2E8 · Shibboleth

Key Dialogue

"DONNA: (to Josh) The INS guys will be here in a minute."
"C.J.: I don't know it. DONNA: (sighs) Didn't you go to elementary school? C.J.: Yes, right before being a National Merit Scholar."
"C.J.: Troy, I want you know it was neck-and-neck but I'm giving it to Eric. You were in it right to the end but it's the flapping thing you've got going on."