The West Wing
S1E2
· Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc

Hoynes Tests Leo — A Quiet Power Play

In Leo's office at night Vice President John Hoynes pays a civil visit that quickly curdles into a test of authority. When Leo confronts him for snubbing C.J., Hoynes pushes back, airing long-smoldering resentment about his diminished role. Leo answers not with persuasion but with a stark, political ultimatum: full-throated support or exile to irrelevance. The exchange crystallizes their power dynamic — brittle, personal, and politically dangerous — and functions as a turning point that raises the stakes for loyalty within the administration.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

5

Leo and Hoynes's initial exchange begins with forced politeness as Hoynes arrives at Leo's office, hinting at underlying tension.

neutral to tension ["Leo's office"]

Leo directly confronts Hoynes about blowing off C.J., escalating the tension between them.

tension to confrontation ["Leo's office"]

Hoynes challenges Leo's authority, questioning the office's right to direct him, leading to a heated exchange.

confrontation to conflict ["Leo's office"]

Leo warns Hoynes about the consequences of not supporting the President, asserting his dominance in the power struggle.

conflict to warning ["Leo's office"]

The confrontation ends with Hoynes leaving, and Leo returning to his paperwork, unresolved but with the power dynamics clearly established.

warning to unresolved tension ["Leo's office"]

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

3
John Hoynes
primary

Smoldering indignation erupting into open challenge

Enters casually, banters lightly about New York and Margaret, then stands defensively to vent resentment, mocks Leo's authority with constitutional jab, rises to leave twice amid escalating barbs, exits after final warning.

Goals in this moment
  • • Assert personal autonomy against perceived slights
  • • Vent long-held grievances over diminished role
Active beliefs
  • • Vice-presidential stature demands equal deference
  • • Bartlet-Leo duo unjustly sidelines his influence
Character traits
Defensive resentment Sarcastic defiance Entitled frustration Calculated retreat
Follow John Hoynes's journey
Leo Thomas McGarry (Chief of Staff)
primary

Controlled fury laced with resolute certainty

Seated and reading paperwork initially, Leo rises to confrontation, delivers pointed rebuke over C.J., invokes presidential authority with rising intensity, issues stark ultimatum, then resumes reading stoically after Hoynes departs.

Goals in this moment
  • • Enforce chain-of-command respect for C.J. and staff
  • • Secure Hoynes' unqualified loyalty to Bartlet
Active beliefs
  • • White House directives carry unbreakable weight
  • • Disloyalty invites swift political destruction
Character traits
Unyielding authority Institutional loyalty Calculated intimidation Blunt pragmatism
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey
Margaret Hooper
primary

Calm and neutral

Enters briefly to announce Hoynes' arrival with polite interruption, exits promptly at Leo's thanks, facilitating the private confrontation without further involvement.

Goals in this moment
  • • Execute Leo's scheduling logistics seamlessly
  • • Preserve confidentiality of high-level meeting
Active beliefs
  • • Routine announcements enable senior operations
  • • Intrusions must be minimal in power spaces
Character traits
Efficient professionalism Discreet loyalty
Follow Margaret Hooper's journey

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
New York City

New York City is referenced by Hoynes to frame his trip as important (Standard & Poor's raising the city's credit rating), serving as offstage prestige that Hoynes uses to assert relevance and deflect Leo's interrogation. The city functions as contextual leverage for Hoynes' ego and standing.

Atmosphere Implied external prestige and bustle intruding into a private confrontation—an offstage spectacle that heightens Hoynes' …
Function Contextual amplifier—provides Hoynes rhetorical cover and underscores the political stakes of his schedule and reputation.
Symbolism Represents external validation and metropolitan prestige that Hoynes leans on to shore up his status.
Verbal mention of Standard & Poor's upward action Implied fundraiser/press circuit momentum Offstage city prestige used rhetorically
West Wing Service Corridor Men's Restroom (S01E02)

The West Wing men's room is invoked by Hoynes as a sarcastic rhetorical device (Article Two / men's room quip) to ridicule Leo's attempt to treat C.J.'s information as a directive. The reference functions as a comic undercut and a means for Hoynes to challenge institutional overreach.

Atmosphere Momentarily flippant and irreverent—Hoynes uses humor to mask deeper grievance and to puncture Leo's authority.
Function Rhetorical touchstone and boundary marker—Hoynes' joke reframes the power conversation as petty and questions Leo's …
Symbolism Undermines institutional formality; symbolizes Hoynes' attempt to reduce the confrontation to absurdity rather than confront …
Sarcastic invocation of Article Two of the Constitution Casual, irreverent language about a private facility Verbal jibe used to deflect an assertion of authority

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph

Key Dialogue

"Did you blow off C.J. Cregg this morning?"
"You want me to consider it a directive from this office?"
"Give this President anything less than your full-throated support, and you're going to find out exactly how long."