Fabula
S1E10 · In Excelsis Deo

Goldfish Food and Guarded Affections

In C.J.'s office at night a playful, intimate beat breaks through the day's political turmoil: C.J. mock-reads a careful list of reasons to avoid workplace romance while Danny presents a tiny, teasing Christmas gift — goldfish food — and blurts out that he has a crush on her. The moment exposes Danny's persistence and C.J.'s professional defenses, then pivots when Leo arrives to demand she temper her rhetoric on hate-crimes. The scene functions as both tonal relief and character definition: it sharpens C.J.'s moral fire, signals Danny's earnest vulnerability, and sets up Leo's political caution, reinforcing the story's tension between personal truth and public calculation.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

C.J. and Danny engage in flirtatious banter, with C.J. reading what she claims is her list of reasons to avoid a romantic entanglement, while Danny humorously dismisses it.

playful tension to lighthearted amusement

Danny surprises C.J. with a Christmas gift—goldfish food, teasing her about his crush despite her defensive list, revealing his persistent romantic interest.

surprise to reluctant amusement

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Professional alertness; unobtrusive, focused on passing along critical information rather than engaging socially.

Carol appears in the doorway to signal the arrival of Leo, interrupting the private exchange; she functions as the practical conduit of incoming authority and news rather than a participant in the flirtation.

Goals in this moment
  • Notify C.J. of Leo's presence quickly and quietly.
  • Maintain the flow of communications into the Press Office.
  • Protect the office's operational rhythm by controlling interruptions.
Active beliefs
  • Timely, discreet updates are essential to office function.
  • Hierarchy and protocol matter in managing incoming visitors.
  • Interruptions should be minimized but not withheld when important.
Character traits
efficient discreet attentive
Follow Carol Fitzpatrick's journey
C.J. Cregg
primary

Playful restraint giving way to righteous indignation; professionally guarded but personally amused; becomes swiftly serious and moral when Leo challenges her rhetoric.

C.J. stands leaning on her desk, mock‑reading a prepared list of reasons workplace romance is problematic, then reacts with amused reproach to Danny's gift and sits to continue the conversation while fielding Leo's political instruction.

Goals in this moment
  • Maintain professional boundaries between press and press secretary.
  • Deflect Danny's romantic advance without destroying rapport.
  • Articulate moral condemnation of the hate‑crime to shape narrative.
Active beliefs
  • Public roles require careful separation from personal entanglements.
  • Speaking forcefully about moral outrages is necessary to push policy and public opinion.
  • Personal warmth can coexist with professional firmness.
Character traits
professionally disciplined wryly humorous morally outraged (on hate crimes) defensive about boundaries
Follow C.J. Cregg's journey

Lighthearted flirtation that cracks into sincere vulnerability; slightly embarrassed but earnest when he confesses, then retreats politely when authority appears.

Danny sits in the visitor chair, teases C.J., produces a small wrapped cylinder from his coat as a gag gift, and unexpectedly confesses a crush before quickly taking his leave when Carol and Leo arrive.

Goals in this moment
  • Deliver a small, intimate gesture to create a private moment with C.J.
  • Test whether his attraction to C.J. is reciprocated.
  • Preserve his professional standing by exiting gracefully when intruded upon.
Active beliefs
  • Small, personal gestures can cut through institutional noise.
  • Honesty about personal feelings is worth the risk despite professional complications.
  • He can keep rapport with C.J. even while confessing.
Character traits
impulsive affectionate playful vulnerable
Follow Danny Concannon's journey

Calm, steady, gently admonishing; focused on minimizing risk and preserving operational flexibility rather than on moral grandstanding.

Leo enters and greets Danny, then redirects the room's tone by asking C.J. to 'dial down' her rhetoric on hate crimes — asserting institutional caution and managerial control over messaging strategy.

Goals in this moment
  • Curb potential political fallout from C.J.'s public rhetoric.
  • Preserve the administration's strategic options on hate‑crimes policy.
  • Reassert the chain of command and messaging discipline.
Active beliefs
  • Political messaging must be calibrated to preserve options and avoid alienating uncertain allies.
  • Strong moral language may have unintended policy consequences.
  • Staff should be counseled privately to manage public perception.
Character traits
authoritative pragmatic protective politically wary
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
C.J. Cregg's Press Office Desk

C.J.'s press office desk functions as the physical hub: she leans against it while reading the list, the gift and its wrapping are opened on or in front of it, and it carries the small domestic detail that makes the moment feel intimate amid official business.

Before: Cleared enough to lean against and use as …
After: Remains the staging ground for the torn wrapping …
Before: Cleared enough to lean against and use as a surface for the exchange; holds routine office clutter as implied.
After: Remains the staging ground for the torn wrapping and the shifted focus toward policy discussion after Leo's arrival.
Danny's Cylinder Goldfish Food Container (pocket gift, S1E10 'In Excelsis Deo')

Danny produces a palm-sized cylinder from his coat as a joking Christmas gift; it is unwrapped to reveal goldfish food, converting a small prop into a vehicle for intimacy and comic relief that punctures the weight of the preceding subject matter.

Before: Concealed in Danny's coat pocket as a small …
After: Unwrapped and revealed on C.J.'s desk/hand; functions as …
Before: Concealed in Danny's coat pocket as a small wrapped cylinder.
After: Unwrapped and revealed on C.J.'s desk/hand; functions as the punchline of the private exchange before Danny departs.
Crinkled Gift Wrapping Paper (wrapping for Danny's goldfish gift)

A crinkled square of wrapping paper encases the tiny gift and is torn open by C.J. so the reveal (goldfish food) can land as a physical gag that underscores the playful intimacy between the characters.

Before: Wrapped around the small cylinder in Danny's possession.
After: Torn open and discarded or left on the …
Before: Wrapped around the small cylinder in Danny's possession.
After: Torn open and discarded or left on the desk after the reveal.
Visitor Chair in C.J. Cregg's Office

A modest visitor chair holds Danny during the exchange, visually framing him as the less 'official' presence and creating a physical intimacy when he stands to produce the gift and to leave after Leo's arrival.

Before: Occupied by Danny, positioned near C.J.'s desk.
After: Vacated after Danny stands and exits; continues to …
Before: Occupied by Danny, positioned near C.J.'s desk.
After: Vacated after Danny stands and exits; continues to signal the informal nature of the visit.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Doorway to C.J. Cregg's Office (West Wing)

The office itself (implicit in the scene anchored by the doorway and desk) is where private and professional collide: C.J.'s defensive list is read here, a personal gift is opened, and a senior staffer issues policy cautions — all within one confined domestic-professional space.

Atmosphere Warmly lit and intimate at first, then taut and transactional as policy talk takes over.
Function Sanctuary for private moments and a stage for internal policy negotiation.
Symbolism Embodies the dual role of the West Wing as both workplace and crucible for personal …
Access After-hours but accessible to staff and visitors; Carol manages entry.
C.J. leaning against a cluttered desk; chair and small gift present on desk surface. The quiet of night amplifies the intimacy of the confession and the abruptness of the policy shift.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1
Causal

"The news of Lowell Lydell's hate crime motivates C.J.'s passionate advocacy for hate-crime legislation, which Leo then attempts to temper, creating a direct cause-and-effect chain."

Holiday Briefing Interrupted — Hate-Crime's Arrival
S1E10 · In Excelsis Deo

Key Dialogue

"C.J.: "They made him say 'Hail Mary's' as they beat him to death. This was a crime of entertainment.""
"DANNY: "I'm gonna ignore your list 'cause I think it's ridiculous. Also 'cause I got a crush on you.""
"LEO: "Listen, dial down the rhetoric on hate crimes would you?""