Fabula
S3E12 · The Two Bartlets

Toby's Cringe at Bartlet's Evasive Presser

Outside the University of Iowa amid Iowa caucus fervor, Toby Ziegler paces tensely before a TV in a campaign van, cigar smoldering, as he watches President Bartlet's press conference. After a technical environmental response, reporter Donald Atwell probes Bartlet's stance on rival Ritchie's affirmative action ban support. Bartlet dodges with platitudinous vagueness—urging discrimination's abolition in 'hearts and minds'—then abruptly exits amid clamor. Toby freezes, hand to head in raw dismay, crystallizing his frustration with Bartlet's restrained 'professor' mask over his lethal intellect, priming the explosive Oval Office clash ahead.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

3

Toby paces anxiously outside the University of Iowa, watching Bartlet's speech on a nearby TV screen while smoking a cigar, visibly tense about the President's performance.

anticipation to frustration ['Outside University of Iowa campus']

Bartlet deflects a reporter's question about Governor Ritchie's support for banning affirmative action with a vague non-answer about abolishing discrimination 'in our hearts and minds'.

hopeful inquiry to disappointed evasion ['University of Iowa press conference']

Toby reacts with visible dismay to Bartlet's evasive answer, physically stopping mid-pace as the President concludes the press conference with hollow platitudes.

controlled tension to frustrated realization

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

7

Frustrated urgency amid unsatisfied curiosity

Clamor collectively for questions during Bartlet's press conference on TV, surging in noise after environmental answer and intensifying around Atwell's affirmative action probe as Bartlet abruptly departs podium.

Goals in this moment
  • Press for more answers on policy contrasts
  • Amplify pressure on evasive responses
Active beliefs
  • Public deserves unfiltered presidential positions
  • Evasions signal deeper strategic weaknesses
Character traits
Relentlessly demanding Pack-mentality aggressive
Follow Unnamed White …'s journey

Professionally alert and composed

Posted steadfastly outside University of Iowa campus building, maintaining security perimeter during Bartlet's indoor presser visible on nearby van TV, ensuring controlled environment amid caucus fervor.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure presidential press event perimeter
  • Facilitate safe extraction post-conference
Active beliefs
  • Unseen threats demand constant vigilance
  • Campaign optics require flawless protection
Character traits
Vigilant and disciplined Impassive protectors
Follow Secret Service …'s journey

Determined and probing, undeterred by evasion

Identifies as Iowa City Standard reporter on TV during Bartlet's presser; directly questions President on Ritchie's affirmative action ban support, attempts persistent follow-up amid reporter clamor before Bartlet exits.

Goals in this moment
  • Elicit specific policy stance from Bartlet on hot-button issue
  • Expose contrasts between candidates for public scrutiny
Active beliefs
  • Presidents owe precise answers on divisive referendums
  • Ritchie's position demands direct White House rebuttal
Character traits
Persistent and incisive Journalistically aggressive
Follow Donald Atwell's journey

Raw dismay masking boiling frustration with strategic evasion

Paces tensely in front of campaign van TV screen, cigar clenched and smoking furiously while intently watching Bartlet's press conference; abruptly stops pacing and touches his head in stark dismay as Bartlet evades Atwell's key question.

Goals in this moment
  • Monitor Bartlet's public response to Ritchie's policy aggressively
  • Gauge effectiveness of President's messaging in real-time
Active beliefs
  • Bartlet must unleash sharp intellect to counter Ritchie decisively
  • Evasive platitudes undermine re-election against conservative surge
Character traits
Intensely focused Viscerally frustrated Loyal but hawkish
Follow Toby Ziegler's journey

evasive

delivering a press conference speech inside the campus building, providing a technical response to an environmental question, vaguely dodging a follow-up on affirmative action with platitudes, pointing to a reporter, then abruptly exiting the podium amid reporter clamor

Goals in this moment
  • deliver evasive, non-committal responses on policy issues during the Iowa press conference
Character traits
supportive poised strategically vital
Follow Abigail Bartlet's journey
Woman
primary

Inquisitive and policy-oriented

Appears on TV feed during Bartlet's Iowa presser, voicing question on environmental water impacts, prompting President's detailed technical response before Atwell's pivot to affirmative action.

Goals in this moment
  • Secure presidential comment on watershed pollution
  • Highlight non-point source environmental threats
Active beliefs
  • Agriculture runoff critically affects water quality
  • Presidential input shapes public environmental awareness
Character traits
Direct and issue-focused Environmentally concerned
Follow Woman's journey

Confidently assertive (inferred from policy stance)

Invoked directly in Atwell's on-TV question to Bartlet about his morning endorsement of Pennsylvania's affirmative action ban referendum, casting omnipresent shadow over presser without physical presence.

Goals in this moment
  • Force rivals into defensive policy clarifications
  • Mobilize base via cultural wedge issues
Active beliefs
  • Affirmative action bans advance meritocracy
  • Electoral momentum demands unapologetic conservatism
Character traits
Politically bold Conservatively provocative
Follow Rob Ritchie's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

4
Open Campaign Van (Mobile Observation Post)

Serves as mobile observation post parked curbside outside University of Iowa, its open back housing TV screens broadcasting Bartlet's presser; Toby paces its threshold tensely, cigar smoke curling within as he witnesses the evasive exchange, amplifying isolated frustration amid caucus chaos.

Before: Parked and operational with TVs active
After: Remains parked, screens still glowing post-presser fade
Before: Parked and operational with TVs active
After: Remains parked, screens still glowing post-presser fade
Campaign Van TV Screen (Bartlet Iowa Press Conference)

TV screen inside campaign van pulses with live Iowa press conference feed, relaying Woman's environmental query, Atwell's Ritchie probe, Bartlet's platitude dodge, and chaotic exit; Toby's frozen dismay reaction hinges on its unfiltered broadcast, bridging remote viewing to raw emotional impact.

Before: Displaying ongoing presser environmental response
After: Showing Bartlet's departure and reporter clamor
Before: Displaying ongoing presser environmental response
After: Showing Bartlet's departure and reporter clamor
University of Iowa Press Conference Podium (President Bartlet)

University of Iowa press podium anchors Bartlet's on-TV appearance, from which he fields water pollution query, points to Atwell, delivers hearts-and-minds platitude, then steps off abruptly amid clamor; symbolizes restrained leadership's stage, exit catalyzing Toby's remote horror.

Before: Occupied by Bartlet mid-presser
After: Vacated as Bartlet departs
Before: Occupied by Bartlet mid-presser
After: Vacated as Bartlet departs
Toby's Cigar

Toby's cigar smolders fiercely between his fingers as he paces van forefront, ember flaring with agitated drags during presser watch; embodies unraveling control, smoke twisting skyward as dismay peaks at Bartlet's evasion, visceral prop underscoring strategic torment.

Before: Lit and actively smoked during pacing
After: Still clenched, smoke lingering post-dismay gesture
Before: Lit and actively smoked during pacing
After: Still clenched, smoke lingering post-dismay gesture

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
University of Iowa Campus Building

University of Iowa campus building hosts Bartlet's high-stakes press conference inside, microphones thrusting amid reporter swarm; exterior features main stairs and Secret Service posts, with nearby van enabling Toby's charged observation—caucus fervor infuses patriotic flags and tension, contrasting evasive rhetoric with heartland scrutiny.

Atmosphere Charged with caucus frenzy, reporter clamor echoing off walls
Function Venue for pivotal campaign presser
Symbolism Heartland battleground exposing leadership fractures
Access Secured by Secret Service, press-only inner access
Daylight under open skies Clamoring reporters and patriotic flag distribution

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

2
U.S. Secret Service

Secret Service maintains ironclad perimeter outside University of Iowa campus building during Bartlet's presser, agents posted vigilantly; enables secure event flow from questions to abrupt podium exit, shielding vulnerability amid caucus crowds and reporter intensity.

Representation Via on-site agents enforcing security cordon
Power Dynamics Exercising protective authority over presidential proceedings
Impact Underpins campaign continuity despite electoral pressures
Ensure threat-free press environment Facilitate swift principal extraction Physical perimeter control Coordinated escort protocols
Iowa City Standard

Iowa City Standard empowers Atwell's pointed on-TV interrogation of Bartlet regarding Ritchie's affirmative action stance during Iowa presser; regional outlet thrusts national campaign rift into local spotlight, Atwell's credentials amplifying demand for specifics amid evasion.

Representation Through reporter Donald Atwell's direct questioning
Power Dynamics Challenging presidential opacity with journalistic authority
Impact Heightens press-White House tensions over policy candor
Extract precise policy contrasts from Bartlet Elevate local coverage of national primaries Persistent follow-up questions Affiliation lending credibility to probes

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 2
Temporal medium

"Bartlet's evasive Iowa press conference immediately precedes Toby's Oval Office confrontation, creating a narrative chain of political avoidance leading to personal explosion."

Charlie Overcomes Bartlet's Refusal to Admit Toby
S3E12 · The Two Bartlets
Temporal medium

"Bartlet's evasive Iowa press conference immediately precedes Toby's Oval Office confrontation, creating a narrative chain of political avoidance leading to personal explosion."

Toby Exposes Bartlet's Abusive Past, Provoking Presidential Eruption
S3E12 · The Two Bartlets

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Key Dialogue

"DONALD ATWELL: "Mr. President, Donald Atwell, Iowa City Standard. Governor Ritchie came out this morning in support of the Pennsylvania Referendum banning affirmative action, with regards to college admissions, and I was wondering if you'd comment.""
"BARTLET: "Well, you know what, now that we've abolished discrimination in our laws, we need to abolish it in our hearts and minds.""
"DONALD ATWELL: "But specifically with regards to...""