Fabula
S1E3 · A Proportional Response

From Coffee to 'Total Disaster'

A breezy, collegial Situation Room moment—Admiral Fitzwallace jokes about the coffee—collapses the instant President Bartlet and Leo enter. Fitzwallace presents three measured, proportional retaliation plans; Bartlet, grieving and furious over a downed airliner, brutalizes the logic of proportionality, demanding a disproportional strike and slamming his fist for a response that means 'total disaster.' Leo and the military counsel try to steady him and insist on restraint, but Bartlet orders them to produce a far more consequential option within an hour. The scene is a tonal pivot and turning point that crystallizes the moral and political rift between military prudence and presidential retribution.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Admiral Fitzwallace and the National Security team discuss the coffee, setting a casual tone before the President's arrival.

casual to formal ['The Situation Room']

President Bartlet and Leo enter, shifting the focus to the military response scenarios.

formal to urgent ['The Situation Room']

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

Restrained alarm; recognizing the operational implications of an order for overwhelming force and the gravity of civilian cost.

The General (senior military voice) affirms operational readiness—'We're there'—and responds when Bartlet's impulse to carpet-bomb Damascus is suggested, signaling both shock and the military's reckoning with political appetite for escalation.

Goals in this moment
  • Clarify the feasibility and consequences of military options.
  • Protect service members and maintain disciplined, lawful use of force.
Active beliefs
  • Military must be able to execute orders but must also counsel restraint where civilian leadership's intentions risk excessive escalation.
  • Clear, realistic briefing prevents miscalculation.
Character traits
grave procedural realist
Follow General Clancy's journey

Grieving and enraged; grief translates into punitive fury that overrides procedural restraint.

President Jed Bartlet enters the Situation Room, listens, interrogates the logic of proportionality, slams his fist on the table, rises and storms out after ordering a dramatically larger response within an hour.

Goals in this moment
  • Demand a military response that communicates utter deterrence and moral outrage.
  • Force his advisors to produce an option he perceives as meaningfully punitive within a strict timeframe.
Active beliefs
  • Proportional responses can be read as predictable and therefore impotent.
  • Some actions require a demonstrative, disproportional reply to deter future attacks and honor victims.
Character traits
righteous incandescent anger moral absolutism
Follow Josiah Edward …'s journey

Worried and duty-focused; anxious about political/media fallout while determined to keep the President focused and the process intact.

Leo McGarry attempts to steady the exchange, prompts attention to Pericles One, and parries Bartlet's rhetorical escalation with reminders of precedent and procedure, then reluctantly accepts Bartlet's directive to produce a different option in an hour.

Goals in this moment
  • Protect the President from rash decisions that could create strategic or political disaster.
  • Translate the President's anger into achievable, controlled options for the team.
Active beliefs
  • Process and checks exist to prevent catastrophic mistakes.
  • The President must be heard, but his anger should be channeled into executable policy.
Character traits
steadying procedural protective
Follow Leo Thomas …'s journey

Focused and neutral; slightly tense as the room's tone shifts toward confrontation.

Officer First supports the briefing with concise confirmations and procedural readiness cues, enabling the Admiral's presentation and maintaining the Situation Room's technical rhythm as the argument intensifies.

Goals in this moment
  • Provide accurate, immediate information to senior leaders.
  • Keep procedural channels open so options can be executed if ordered.
Active beliefs
  • Timely, clear reporting is essential to decision-making.
  • Operational readiness depends on disciplined information flow rather than rhetoric.
Character traits
precise quietly competent procedural
Follow Officer First's journey

Calm, procedural composure fraying into concern as the President rejects established military logic.

Admiral Fitzwallace opens with light banter about the coffee, presents the three strike scenarios including Pericles One, answers Bartlet's probing questions with measured professional detail, and is visibly challenged when Bartlet demands a disproportional strike.

Goals in this moment
  • Convey workable, legally and operationally responsible response options.
  • Preserve military credibility while minimizing risk to U.S. personnel and assets.
Active beliefs
  • The military's obligation is to provide feasible, proportional options that limit escalation.
  • Escalatory or disproportional orders carry unacceptable operational and political costs.
Character traits
measured professional wry under pressure
Follow Percy Fitzwallace's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

6
Abandoned Railroad Bridge — Pericles One Target (Derelict Span)

The abandoned railroad bridge is another enumerated Pericles One target; its inclusion as a derelict, low-civilian-risk target sharpens Bartlet's complaint that predictable, limited strikes won't satisfy the moral demand for retribution.

Before: Marked on briefing materials as a target coordinate.
After: Still listed but rhetorically dismissed by the President …
Before: Marked on briefing materials as a target coordinate.
After: Still listed but rhetorically dismissed by the President as evidence Pericles One is insufficiently consequential.
Ammo Dumps (Ammunition Caches)

Ammo dumps are named components of Pericles One and serve narratively as concrete, low-risk targets that highlight proportionality's predictability; Bartlet argues those targets are abandoned and therefore insufficiently punitive, provoking his call for greater action.

Before: Pinned on Pericles One's map as designated targets.
After: Remain on the map but are rhetorically diminished …
Before: Pinned on Pericles One's map as designated targets.
After: Remain on the map but are rhetorically diminished by the President as inadequate; their strategic utility is questioned.
Pericles One (Retaliatory Strike Plan, printed brief)

Pericles One is presented as the primary, prepared retaliatory package: slides, mapped targets and an operational framing. It functions as the foil for Bartlet's critique — the embodiment of proportional doctrine he finds inadequate and wants superseded by a more devastating plan.

Before: Briefing packet/slide set ready on the table, described …
After: Remains the starting point but is explicitly challenged; …
Before: Briefing packet/slide set ready on the table, described and explained by Fitzwallace.
After: Remains the starting point but is explicitly challenged; staff are ordered to devise an alternative within sixty minutes.
Roosevelt Room Double Doors (West Wing hallway → Roosevelt Room; brass knobs)

The West Wing double doors stage the arrival and exit that frame the scene: they open to admit Bartlet and Leo and close behind Bartlet as he leaves in anger, marking the movement from ordinary briefing to charged presidential directive.

Before: Closed, then opened to admit the President and …
After: Left open/closed as characters move; function as the …
Before: Closed, then opened to admit the President and his chief of staff.
After: Left open/closed as characters move; function as the physical threshold signaling a tonal shift.
Roosevelt Room Oval Conference Table

The Roosevelt Room oval conference table is the central focus: documents and maps are arrayed on it, Fitzwallace gestures from it, and Bartlet bangs his fist on it to punctuate his repudiation of proportionality — turning furniture into a stage for presidential command and emotional release.

Before: Set with briefing memos, maps, and built-in microphones; …
After: Physically impacted by Bartlet's blow (bangs fist); the …
Before: Set with briefing memos, maps, and built-in microphones; staff seated around it.
After: Physically impacted by Bartlet's blow (bangs fist); the table remains the locus of the order to produce a new option and the reverberation of institutional rupture.
Situation Room Coffee Cup (Admiral Fitzwallace's cup)

Fitzwallace's coffee cup is the tactile prop that opens the beat — a small, domestic detail that frames an initially collegial mood and underscores how quickly normalcy collapses when the President enters. The coffee remark humanizes the room before grief converts it into policy fury.

Before: On the table or held by Admiral Fitzwallace; …
After: Left idle as the room's mood hardens; remains …
Before: On the table or held by Admiral Fitzwallace; steaming and in active use as a social prop.
After: Left idle as the room's mood hardens; remains an unremarked domestic object once the briefing becomes a confrontation.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

4
White House Situation Room

The Situation Room is the operational theater where doctrine, intelligence and emotion collide: screens, maps and secure lines surround the table while staff deliver options. Its confined, procedural setting makes Bartlet's emotional rupture more jarring and forces institutional processes to absorb private rage.

Atmosphere Initially collegial and businesslike, quickly hardening into tense, electrified confrontation and moral urgency.
Function Meeting place and decision node for national security deliberation and presidential authorization.
Symbolism Embodies the tension between institutional restraint and the presidency's personal authority to convert grief into …
Access Restricted to senior national security staff and military advisers; secure, limited access.
Low, focused lighting with projection screens and maps Built-in microphones and briefing packets spread across a polished oval table Audible hush when the President enters; the sound of a fist on wood punctuates the room
Damascus, Syria

Damascus functions offstage as the implied escalatory target invoked when the General asks if the President means carpet-bombing; the city's name compresses strategic, humanitarian, and diplomatic consequences into one volatile signifier.

Atmosphere Not physically present but atmospherically charged — a looming, dangerous possibility that raises the stakes …
Function Potential target and rhetorical device representing maximal escalation.
Symbolism Symbolizes the moral and geopolitical abyss that disproportionate retaliation would open.
Invoked through maps and target lists on briefing slides Referenced verbally as a hypothetical site for massive retaliation
Pericles One — Two Ammo Dumps

Pericles One — Two Ammo Dumps is the specific mapped location-set forming the backbone of the presented proportional option; its schematic nature allows staff to discuss casualty estimates and feasibility clinically, which Bartlet rejects as morally insufficient.

Atmosphere Clinical and schematic on paper; dismissed emotionally by the President as inadequate retribution.
Function Operational target set for a measured retaliatory strike.
Symbolism Represents routinized military problem-solving that can look morally hollow in the face of personal loss.
Map pins and plotted coordinates on briefing slides Casualty and risk calculations presented verbally
Syrian Intelligence Headquarters (IHQ)

The Syrian Intelligence Agency appears on the Pericles One target list as a high-rated institutional target; its inclusion frames the action as strategically meaningful but also politically hazardous, prompting Bartlet to question whether limited strikes hit the real moral target.

Atmosphere Institutional, ominous on the map — a node of intelligence and regime power that evokes …
Function Named high-value target within the proportional plan.
Symbolism Embodies the opponent's apparatus and the temptation to punish institutions rather than individuals.
Appears as a labeled icon on slides and briefing maps Discussed in the context of target selection and political fallout

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 2
Causal

"The bombing that destroys Syrian Intelligence (in beat_b9919a0f87204720) is a direct result of the President's demand for a disproportional response (in beat_e1fe84c660037c14), showing the consequences of his initial impulse."

Charlie Supplies the Phoenix Context
S1E3 · A Proportional Response
Causal

"The bombing that destroys Syrian Intelligence (in beat_b9919a0f87204720) is a direct result of the President's demand for a disproportional response (in beat_e1fe84c660037c14), showing the consequences of his initial impulse."

Leo Reclaims Control: Quietly Redirecting the President
S1E3 · A Proportional Response
What this causes 1
Escalation medium

"Bartlet's demand for a disproportional response (in beat_0776413780209e6e) escalates to Fitzwallace presenting the catastrophic Hassan airport strike option (in beat_529b901bffc3ca71), showing the progression of military considerations."

Reluctant Launch — Pericles One Authorized
S1E3 · A Proportional Response

Key Dialogue

"FITZWALLACE: "This is different coffee than we usually have.""
"BARTLET: "What's the virtue of a proportional response?" FITZWALLACE: "It isn't virtuous Mr. President. It's all there is sir.""
"BARTLET: "A disproportional response. Let the word ring forth from this time and this place... we come back" [bangs fist on table] "with total disaster! ... put together a U.S. response scenario that doesn't make me think we are just docking somebody's damn allowance!""