Khundunese

Description

The Khundunese serve as the foreign population President Bartlet cites to probe U.S. intervention ethics in his inaugural speech draft. He asks Will Bailey why a Khundunese life matters less than an American one; Will agrees and admits voicing this directly to the President. Toby Ziegler rebukes Will's candor in his office, arguing it undermines doctrinal discipline and risks political fallout amid speech revisions. They represent lives weighed in American policy debates, with no shown structure or agency.

Affiliated Characters

Event Involvements

Events with structured involvement data

7 events
S4E14 · Inauguration Part I
Banter, Then Bare Truth

The Khundunese are invoked rhetorically as the human subjects whose worth is compared to Americans; their plight is the moral hinge of the event, turning a policy draft into an ethical indictment of unequal valuation.

Active Representation

Manifested indirectly through Bartlet's rhetorical question and Will's admission rather than any on-screen spokesperson.

Power Dynamics

Positioned as powerless and in need, their lack of institutional voice contrasts with U.S. rhetorical and policy power; they become objects of moral calculus rather than agents of influence.

Institutional Impact

Their invocation forces institutional actors to confront the bias in valuing lives and pushes the administration to reconcile human costs with national interest.

Organizational Goals
(Narrative role) To highlight humanitarian need and raise the moral stakes of policy language To serve as the barometer against which the administration's values are measured
Influence Mechanisms
Moral pressure via rhetoric and public conscience Potential to provoke humanitarian or policy action if recognized as equal in value
S4E14 · Inauguration Part I
The Moral Question in Will's Draft

The Khundunese — as the population under threat — are the ethical object of the debate. Their presumed diminished political value is named by Will's draft and challenged by Bartlet, turning them into the human measure for policy choices in this moment.

Active Representation

Through rhetorical invocation in the draft and directly in Bartlet's aloud question, rather than by physical presence.

Power Dynamics

Powerless in this scene: they are subject to decisions and discourse between powerful American actors who assign value to their lives.

Institutional Impact

Their invocation forces a confrontation between rhetorical doctrine and lived human suffering, exposing the administration's moral responsibilities.

Organizational Goals
To survive and to have their lives recognized equally in international moral calculus. To be the subject of international intervention or humanitarian response.
Influence Mechanisms
Moral pressure via public rhetoric and appeals from advocates. Media and humanitarian reporting that bring their plight into policymaking conversation.
S4E14 · Inauguration Part I
Ballsy Admission and the Question of Lineage

The Khundunese (as an organization/people) are the subject whose worth is compared to American lives; their plight is the moral engine prompting the president's question and revealing the draft's ethical implication.

Active Representation

Referenced indirectly through the speech's language and Bartlet's spoken question.

Power Dynamics

Powerless in the room; their suffering is being discussed and valued by powerful U.S. actors who determine intervention or indifference.

Institutional Impact

The invocation of Khundunese suffering exposes how institutional language can obscure unequal valuations and may force policy re-evaluation later.

Organizational Goals
To serve as the moral constituency whose lives demand consideration (narrative goal). To catalyze a debate about the U.S. responsibility toward foreign civilian casualties (inferred).
Influence Mechanisms
Moral suasion via rhetorical invocation. Political leverage through being the human stake at the center of policy rhetoric.
S4E14 · Inauguration Part I
Abrupt Exit — Doctrine Questioned, Answers Deferred

The Khundunese (as the people of Khundu) are the human subject of the inaugural draft's moral claim; their suffering anchors the ethical test Bartlet poses. The organization/people are invoked rather than represented by spokespeople, serving as the moral measuring-stick for U.S. values.

Active Representation

Through rhetorical invocation in the President's reading of the draft.

Power Dynamics

Marginalized and powerless in the exchange; their plight is used to test the priorities of U.S. decision-makers.

Institutional Impact

Their invocation exposes the administration's dilemma: rhetorical commitments to values collide with political calculations about whose lives are prioritized.

Internal Dynamics

Not depicted in the scene; represented externally as a single moral constituency whose needs conflict with institutional inertia.

Organizational Goals
To have their suffering recognized in international rhetoric and policy. To prompt moral and possibly material intervention from powerful actors.
Influence Mechanisms
Moral suasion through public rhetoric and speeches. Humanitarian urgency that pressures policymakers and public opinion.
S4E15 · Inauguration Part II: Over There
Ball Against the Window / Will's Casual Confession

The Khundunese (Khundunese civilians) are the moral referent around which the argument orbits: Will's blunt admission that a Khundunese life 'is worth less' triggers the ethical debate and forces staff to wrestle with the human cost implicit in policy and rhetoric.

Active Representation

Present only as the subject of conversation and the moral object of the President's question — represented through Will's and Toby's dialogue.

Power Dynamics

They are politically disenfranchised actors whose suffering serves as the moral pressure on U.S. politicians; they hold moral but not political power in this scene.

Institutional Impact

Their mention exposes the administration's tension between humanitarian responsibility and domestic political constraints, shaping speech language and potential policy posture.

Internal Dynamics

Not applicable as they are not agents with internal processes in this scene.

Organizational Goals
(Implicit) Seek protection and recognition of their suffering Serve as a moral touchstone prompting U.S. policy deliberation
Influence Mechanisms
Moral suasion through staff and the President's conscience Narrative framing within the inaugural speech
S4E15 · Inauguration Part II: Over There
Window into Conviction: Will's Unfiltered Answer

The Khundunese (as an organization/collective identifier) function as the human subject of the debate. Their mass slaughter is the moral emergency that prompted the President's question and that haunts staff deliberations about intervention and rhetorical responsibility.

Active Representation

Through the President's question, Will's admission, and Toby's rebuke; they are represented indirectly, through staff moral argument.

Power Dynamics

The Khundunese are powerless within the scene's dynamics — their suffering motivates action but they lack agency in the White House's deliberations.

Institutional Impact

Their crisis forces the administration to confront the limits of rhetorical commitment versus operational risk, revealing how human lives become calculus in policy.

Internal Dynamics

The Khundunese situation exposes an internal staff split between moral urgency and message discipline; no internal hierarchy of the Khundunese is presented.

Organizational Goals
Survive the ongoing atrocities (narrative imperative) Appear in U.S. rhetoric and policy as a legitimate object of humanitarian protection
Influence Mechanisms
Moral pressure on decision-makers (humanitarian argument) Public opinion potential if their suffering becomes front-stage rhetoric
S4E15 · Inauguration Part II: Over There
Toby Reins In Will's Idealism

The Khundunese are the human referent whose slaughter and worth are debated; their suffering is the moral fulcrum that compels the President's question and makes the staff's rhetorical choices weighty and consequential.

Active Representation

Referenced through the President's pointed question and Will's admission of what he told the President.

Power Dynamics

Powerless in the scene but central morally; their plight exerts moral pressure on powerful actors who must translate compassion into policy.

Institutional Impact

Their victimhood forces the administration to weigh humanitarian responsibility against political cost, exposing the limits of rhetorical commitment.

Organizational Goals
Implied goal: survival and protection (contextual, not acted upon here) Implied goal: to have their suffering acknowledged by international actors
Influence Mechanisms
Moral force exerted via public sympathy and rhetorical framing Political leverage as justification for potential intervention

Related Events

Events mentioning this organization

6 events