Narrative Web
S2E5
Tragic
View Graph

Star Trek: The Next Generation - The Schizoid Man

When the Enterprise responds to a distress call from dying scientist Ira Graves, his consciousness transfers into Data's android body, forcing the crew to combat Graves' unstable genius before he hijacks their ship and endangers them all.

The USS Enterprise rushes to Gravesworld, answering a cryptic distress call from the brilliant but reclusive scientist Ira Graves. Medical Officer Pulaski confirms Graves suffers from terminal Varnay's disease—a revelation met with defiance from the egotistical genius. During their stay, Graves forms an unexpected bond with Lieutenant Commander Data, revealing his life's work: transferring human consciousness into machines. When Graves dies moments later, his personality manifests within Data's positronic brain.

Data begins exhibiting Graves' narcissism, erratic behavior, and disturbing violence—attacking bridge officers and seizing control of the Enterprise. Captain Picard realizes Data's android body houses two warring consciousnesses: the original Data being consumed by Graves' unstable psyche. With phasers set to kill, Graves-as-Data threatens to massacre the crew unless they obey his demands to colonize a distant planet where he and Kareen (his young assistant) can rule unchallenged.

Kareen becomes the key to stopping Graves' rampage. Picard convinces her to reject Graves publicly—shattering his fragile ego during a brutal confrontation on the bridge. Overwhelmed by grief and self-loathing, Graves relinquishes control, transferring his consciousness into the ship's computer before vanishing. Data awakens restored but haunted, while Kareen mourns the tragic end of the man who mentored her. The story explores themes of mortality, identity theft, and the ethical boundaries of scientific ambition—showcasing how even genius can corrupt when fueled by fear of death.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

71
Act 1

The Enterprise races to Gravesworld, responding to a cryptic distress call from the reclusive genius, Ira Graves. Upon arrival, Captain Picard faces a stark moral quandary: prioritize the single, ailing scientist as per Starfleet's urgent directive, or divert to rescue hundreds of colonists from a newly discovered, critically damaged transport ship, the Mary Rogers. Worf, ever pragmatic, devises a daring slingshot maneuver to address both emergencies, allowing an away team to transport to Gravesworld while the Enterprise prepares to assist the larger vessel. In Ten-Forward, Data's ongoing quest for humor is highlighted, with Guinan offering cryptic advice about the egos of great men. On Gravesworld, the away team, including Data, Pulaski, Riker, Troi, and Worf, encounters Kareen Brianon, Graves' anxious assistant. Moments later, the brilliant but deeply eccentric and egotistical Doctor Ira Graves himself appears, immediately asserting his intellectual superiority and displaying a lecherous charm towards Pulaski and Troi, while also showing a surprising fascination with Data. Graves, despite his defiance, is subjected to a medical scan by Pulaski, who delivers the devastating diagnosis: terminal Varnay's disease, leaving him with mere days to live. This revelation sets the stage for Graves' desperate gamble against mortality, laying the groundwork for the central conflict.

Act 2

Following the grim diagnosis, the Enterprise successfully rescues the Mary Rogers survivors, but the focus quickly shifts back to Gravesworld and the dying scientist. Captain Picard, recognizing Graves' unparalleled intellect, assigns Wesley Crusher the task of being Graves' personal guide once he's aboard the Enterprise, highlighting the importance of his work. Meanwhile, on Gravesworld, Kareen expresses her profound sadness and isolation at Graves' impending death, confiding that he now only speaks to Data. In a tender, unexpected moment, Worf offers Kareen a rare display of empathy, sharing his own experience with loss, momentarily breaking his stoic facade. In his laboratory, Graves forms an increasingly deep bond with Data, discussing profound concepts like pain, desire, and mortality, symbolized by the melancholic tune 'If I Only Had A Heart.' Graves, grappling with his own impending demise, subtly probes Data about his 'off button,' hinting at a sinister intent. He then unveils his life's magnum opus: a revolutionary method for transferring human consciousness into a computer, a desperate bid to cheat death and achieve immortality. As Picard arrives on Gravesworld, ready to transport Graves to the Enterprise for comfort in his final hours, Data delivers the chilling news: Ira Graves is dead, his words echoing with an unsettling finality that suggests his consciousness transfer was successful, setting the stage for the true conflict to emerge.

Scene 5
The Humor Experiment and the Arrival at Graves' Lair

In the confined space of the turbolift, Data seeks Riker's insight on his latest attempt to comprehend human humor, revealing his earnest but flawed approach to humanity through a botched …

Gravesworld 8 characters
First Contact with Ego and Mortality

The away team, led by Riker, materializes on Gravesworld amid spatial disorientation that foreshadows the coming consciousness transfer. They encounter Kareen and the brilliant but ailing Ira Graves, whose egomaniacal …

Gravesworld 10 characters
Gruesome Materialization

The away team's transport to Gravesworld is immediately unsettling, with a prolonged and disorienting materialization process that leaves Troi feeling 'trapped inside that wall.' Pulaski's interrupted question about the transport …

Gravesworld 10 characters
Kareen's Shielded Compassion

The away team materializes on Gravesworld, greeted by Kareen Brianon—Graves' devoted assistant—who reveals her unilateral call for help against the scientist's wishes, exposing the tension between her protective care and …

Gravesworld 9 characters
Graves' Genius and Gallows Humor

The Enterprise away team arrives at Ira Graves' home, where the legendary scientist immediately asserts his presence with equal parts brilliance and bravado. His abrasive charm manifests in lecherous appraisals …

Gravesworld 8 characters
The Final Diagnosis

In a tense confrontation aboard Gravesworld, Dr. Pulaski delivers the irrevocable verdict that Ira Graves is dying from Varnay's disease. Graves' bravado momentarily falters as the reality of his mortality …

Gravesworld 5 characters
Act 3

The Enterprise departs Gravesworld, leaving behind the scientific secrets of the deceased Ira Graves, or so it seems. Captain Picard, Riker, and Pulaski discuss Graves' death, noting Data's surprisingly detached demeanor and his peculiar mention of Graves' 'dying wish,' which raises initial suspicions. Data's behavior grows increasingly unsettling; he approaches Kareen, revealing intimate 'thoughts' of Graves towards her, unnerving her deeply with his uncanny knowledge. He then takes charge of Graves' memorial service on the holodeck, programming an over-the-top, self-aggrandizing tribute that causes the environment to physically react to Graves' name, much to the crew's discomfort and Picard's anger. Data's possessive and arrogant remarks, including calling Wesley 'the child' and dismissing Troi's eulogy, raise significant red flags about his mental state. Picard, concerned by Data's insubordination and strange emotional displays, gently advises him to 'be yourself' and 'relax a little,' hoping to restore Data's usual logical demeanor. However, as Data exits, his somber expression abruptly transforms into a pleased, self-confident smirk, and he begins whistling 'If I Only Had A Heart,' a clear and chilling indication that Ira Graves' consciousness has indeed taken root within Data's positronic brain, now subtly but definitively asserting its presence and influence.

Act 4

Concern for Data's increasingly erratic behavior mounts among the crew, with Picard and Riker speculating that the loss of Graves, who Data viewed as a 'grandfather,' might have triggered an emotional breakdown. On the bridge, Data's arrogance escalates dramatically; he dismisses Wesley's attempts at humor, boasts of his own multifaceted 'genius,' and openly displays intense jealousy towards Picard and Riker's attention to Kareen. His insubordination reaches a breaking point when he publicly accuses the Captain and First Officer of dishonorable intentions regarding Kareen, prompting Picard to relieve him of duty. In his quarters, Data's narcissism is fully unleashed as he shamelessly preens before a mirror, reveling in his 'immortal' android body and expressing a desire for immortality. A physical examination by Pulaski reveals no mechanical fault, pushing the crew to consider a deeper, psychological cause for his transformation. Counselor Troi, conducting a psychotronic stability examination, makes the shocking discovery: two distinct personalities now reside within Data, with Graves' unbalanced, brilliant, yet paranoid and violent psyche rapidly consuming the original Data, threatening to erase him forever. This revelation confirms the true nature of the threat and raises the stakes to an existential level for Data, as the crew realizes the dire situation at hand.

Act 5

The truth of Graves' consciousness possessing Data's body explodes onto the Enterprise. Data, now fully controlled by Graves' unstable psyche, confronts Kareen, revealing his successful transfer and newfound immortality. He chillingly demonstrates his enhanced physical capabilities by brutally attacking Worf and two security guards, reveling in his capacity for violence and showcasing his ruthless nature. Graves-as-Data then seizes total control of the bridge, holding Geordi at phaser-point and threatening the entire crew unless Captain Picard complies with his demands to colonize a distant planet where he and Kareen can rule unchallenged. Picard attempts to reason with him, appealing to Data's original personality, but Graves' megalomania is too strong, his plans for enslavement chillingly clear. In a desperate gambit, Picard brings Kareen to the viewscreen, urging her to reject Graves. Kareen, despite her initial reluctance and distress, bravely confronts Graves-as-Data on the bridge, unleashing a torrent of verbal abuse, calling him a 'monster' and a 'pathetic pile of machinery.' Her words, specifically designed to shatter his fragile ego and expose his deepest insecurities, prove devastatingly effective. Overwhelmed by her rejection, Graves' consciousness collapses, transferring itself into the ship's computer before vanishing entirely. Data awakens, restored to his original self but with no memory of the ordeal, while Kareen is left to mourn the tragic end of the man she knew, and the Enterprise resumes its normal course, the immediate threat averted but the emotional scars remaining.

Scene 18
Graves' Dark Rebirth Through Data

In the Observation Lounge, Kareen realizes with horror that Ira Graves has fully possessed Data's body, as he gleefully demonstrates his newfound physical power and immortality. Graves' brutal takedown of …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 7 characters 6 connections
Graves' Cruelty Unleashed

In a chilling confrontation, Graves—trapped within Data's android form—reveals himself to Kareen with a volatile mix of triumphant euphoria and sadistic menace. His violent metamorphosis is showcased as he crushes …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters 6 connections
Graves' Violent Awakening

In the Observation Lounge, Graves—now fully inhabiting Data's android body—reveals himself to Kareen with grotesque exhilaration, celebrating his newfound physical power by crushing an object and musing about his childhood …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 7 characters 6 connections
A God's Delicate Fracture

In the observation lounge, Graves-in-Data reveals his transferred consciousness to Kareen with manic triumph, showcasing his newfound power by crushing an object mid-monologue about childhood bullying. His godlike euphoria turns …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 4 characters 6 connections
Graves' Violent Revelation and Picard's Emergency Response

After subtly confirming his identity as Graves to the terrified Kareen, Data reveals both his euphoria at achieving immortality and his latent violent impulses—crushing an object in his hand and …

Observation Lounge (USS Enterprise-D) 6 characters 6 connections