S1E42
Tragic
Written by Dennis Spooner
View Graph

Prisoners of Conciergerie

The Doctor and his companions must navigate the treacherous political landscape of the French Revolution, helping a British agent expose a plot involving Napoleon while trying to save Susan from imprisonment and certain execution during The Reign of Terror.

The Doctor, Ian, Barbara, and Susan find themselves caught in the web of the French Revolution, specifically during the Reign of Terror. Their adventure begins inside of Chez Jules, after Ian and the Doctor make a deal with LeMaitre to find Susan, who is being held prisoner. LeMaitre reveals his identity as James Stirling, a British agent, who orchestrated Ian's escape from prison, needing them to deliver a message. Stirling explains that he needs their help to uncover a plot against Robespierre, promising safe passage for them all in return.

Stirling reveals that Robespierre suspects a plot against him. Stirling was ordered to follow Paul Barrass, a deputy. Ian recalls Webster mentioning Barrass and a meeting at "The Sinking Ship," an inn on the Calais Road. Stirling proposes that Barbara and Ian attend the meeting, while he and the Doctor remain behind. Jules agrees to take them to the inn.

At the Sinking Ship inn, Barbara and Ian discover that Barrass is meeting with General Napoleon Bonaparte. They learn of a plot to overthrow Robespierre and establish a new government with Napoleon as one of three consuls. They return to Stirling and the Doctor with this information. Stirling realizes the implications of Napoleon's potential rise to power. The Doctor, however, remains focused on rescuing Susan.

As Robespierre's power crumbles, the Doctor and Barbara head towards the prison, while Stirling and Ian seek news of Robespierre's fate. The Doctor manages to outwit the jailer and free Susan. However, Robespierre is captured and imprisoned in the same prison. The Doctor, Susan, Barbara, and Ian reunite and prepare to leave Paris. Stirling reveals his intention to return to England.

As they prepare to depart, the time travelers meet back up with Jules, who leaves the group. Stirling departs from the group as well. The episode concludes as the TARDIS dematerializes, leaving behind the chaotic and uncertain France, journeying toward their next adventure.


Events in This Episode

The narrative beats that drive the story

26
Act 1

The narrative opens in Chez Jules, where the Doctor, Ian, Barbara, and Jules confront LeMaitre. LeMaitre reveals his true identity as James Stirling, a British agent, admitting he orchestrated Ian's prison escape to facilitate a critical message delivery. Stirling's strategic reveal also involves holding Susan captive, using her as leverage to compel the Doctor's cooperation in a new, urgent mission: uncovering a plot against Robespierre. In exchange for their assistance, Stirling promises safe passage for all four companions. Ian's memory provides a crucial lead, recalling Webster's cryptic mention of Barrass and "The Sinking Ship" inn. Stirling proposes a dangerous infiltration, suggesting Barbara and Ian attend the secret meeting, while he and the Doctor remain behind. Despite the Doctor's initial, strong objections regarding the inherent risks, Ian and Barbara ultimately agree, driven by the paramount need to secure Susan's freedom and their own escape from revolutionary France. Jules, a local contact, volunteers to transport them to the inn, thus setting the stage for their perilous undercover operation. This act meticulously establishes the immediate stakes—Susan's precarious situation and the companions' desperate need for safe passage—while simultaneously introducing the central, high-stakes mission to expose the burgeoning conspiracy. The tension builds through the forced alliance and the acceptance of a dangerous assignment.

Act 2

Barbara and Ian, adopting convincing disguises as a waitress and a temporary innkeeper, successfully infiltrate "The Sinking Ship" inn. Their meticulous preparation involves creating a spy hole, through which they observe Paul Barrass arriving for his secret rendezvous. The true gravity of the situation becomes apparent when Barrass's guest is revealed to be General Napoleon Bonaparte, a figure whose ambition Stirling already fears. Barbara and Ian meticulously listen, overhearing the full, audacious details of a plot to overthrow Robespierre. The plan involves Robespierre's arrest and execution, paving the way for a new government with Napoleon as one of three powerful consuls. Upon their return to Chez Jules, they relay their shocking findings, confirming Stirling's gravest concerns about Napoleon's potential rise to power. The Doctor, however, remains steadfastly focused on the immediate, personal crisis of Susan's rescue, largely dismissing the broader political implications unfolding around them. As the news of Robespierre's imminent downfall gains traction, the group strategically splits: Stirling and Ian venture out to gather intelligence on Robespierre's fate, while the Doctor and Barbara head directly to the prison. Their fears are soon realized as Robespierre is captured, wounded, and dragged away, confirming the plot's success and signaling the definitive end of his brutal reign, thereby escalating the urgency and complexity of Susan's rescue. This act effectively amplifies the political stakes, thrusting the companions directly into a pivotal, history-altering event.

Act 3

The Doctor, demonstrating his characteristic ingenuity and resourcefulness, executes a cunning plan to free Susan. He boldly impersonates a high-ranking official, skillfully manipulating the unsuspecting jailer with false news of Robespierre's downfall and LeMaitre's demise. The Doctor then orders the gullible jailer to release prisoners and, crucially, obtains the key to Susan's cell, successfully freeing her from imminent danger. Coincidentally, almost immediately after Susan's release, Robespierre himself, wounded and captured, is dramatically brought into the very same prison, a stark visual confirmation of the successful coup and the abrupt end of his Reign of Terror. Outside, Barbara, Ian, and Stirling witness Robespierre's ignominious arrival, solidifying their understanding of the profound political upheaval that has just occurred. The companions joyfully reunite with Susan, and the entire group prepares for their long-awaited departure from the chaotic streets of Paris. Stirling, having fulfilled his mission and obtained the crucial intelligence, announces his intention to return to England, signaling the resolution of his storyline. Jules, their local ally, also bids farewell, expressing his intent to observe the evolving political landscape from a safer distance. In the TARDIS, the companions reflect on their adventure, acknowledging their inherent inability to alter fixed historical events, despite their direct involvement and observations. The episode culminates as the TARDIS dematerializes, leaving behind the turbulent French Revolution and journeying toward their next unknown destination, with the companions accepting their fundamental role as passive observers rather than active influencers of history.