Fabula
S1E18 · Rider From Shang-Tu

Susan and Ping-Cho bond over exile

Susan and Ping-Cho stand by a pond observing goldfish, using the fish as a playful metaphor for the caravan’s personalities—Wang-Lo’s smoothness, Marco’s solemnity, Ian’s energy, Barbara’s independence. The lighthearted moment shifts when Ping-Cho identifies Susan as the lone, ‘wicked’ goldfish, prompting Susan to notice a small, veiled fish and apologize. Ping-Cho’s homesickness for Samarkand sparks a deeper conversation about displacement. Susan reveals her home is impossibly distant—‘as far away as a night star’—and confirms she can never return, especially if Marco Polo gifts the TARDIS to Kublai Khan. Ping-Cho, torn between her sworn secrecy and Susan’s despair, admits she knows where the key is hidden but refuses to break her promise. The exchange deepens their fragile alliance, underscoring their shared vulnerability as exiles in a world where return is impossible. Susan’s quiet reassurance—‘no-one will ask you’—hints at her growing trust in Ping-Cho, while Ping-Cho’s conflicted silence foreshadows her eventual decision to help the Doctor’s group.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Susan and Ping-Cho observe goldfish in a pond, drawing comparisons to Marco Polo and the other travelers, revealing Susan's longing for home and her connection with her companions.

reflective to fond

Ping-Cho expresses her longing for her home and asks Susan about hers, probing if she could reach it from Venice, leading Susan to reveal the impossibility of her return and the potential permanence of her situation if Marco Polo gives their caravan to Kublai Khan.

melancholy to resigned

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

Melancholic yet cautiously trusting, with a surface calm masking deep longing for home and a quiet resolve to protect Ping-Cho from conflict.

Susan is physically present by the pond, engaged in a moment of playful observation that quickly turns introspective. She uses the goldfish as a metaphor to describe her companions, revealing her keen observational skills and her role as an outsider analyzing the group dynamics. Her tone shifts from lighthearted to melancholic when Ping-Cho labels her the 'wicked goldfish,' and she apologizes for an unspoken offense, hinting at guilt or self-awareness of her outsider status. Susan’s dialogue about her home being 'as far away as a night star' is a poignant confession of her exile, underscoring her vulnerability and the emotional stakes of the TARDIS being gifted to Kublai Khan. Her reassurance to Ping-Cho—'no-one will ask you'—shows her growing trust in Ping-Cho and her strategic empathy.

Goals in this moment
  • To connect with Ping-Cho emotionally and build trust through shared vulnerability.
  • To subtly communicate the urgency of their situation (the TARDIS being gifted to Kublai Khan) without directly pressuring Ping-Cho.
Active beliefs
  • That Ping-Cho is a potential ally but is bound by her loyalty to Marco Polo.
  • That her own home is irretrievably distant, reinforcing her sense of exile.
Character traits
Observant Metaphorical Melancholic Empathetic Strategic Vulnerable Trusting
Follow Ian Chesterton's journey

Nostalgic and conflicted, torn between her duty to Marco Polo and her growing compassion for Susan’s plight. Her silence speaks to her internal struggle, and her empathy is evident in her questions about Susan’s home.

Ping-Cho is physically present by the pond, engaging in a conversation that begins as lighthearted but deepens into a confession of homesickness and moral conflict. She identifies Susan as the 'wicked goldfish,' a label that shifts the tone and reveals her perceptiveness. Ping-Cho’s longing for Samarkand is palpable, and her questions about Susan’s home expose her curiosity and empathy. She admits knowing the location of the TARDIS key but refuses to break her promise to Marco Polo, showcasing her internal struggle between loyalty and compassion. Her conflicted silence and eventual reassurance from Susan hint at her growing alliance with the Doctor’s group, despite her sworn secrecy.

Goals in this moment
  • To understand Susan’s background and forge a deeper emotional connection with her.
  • To navigate her conflict between loyalty to Marco Polo and her compassion for Susan’s situation.
Active beliefs
  • That her sworn secrecy to Marco Polo is absolute, even as she sympathizes with Susan.
  • That Susan’s home is as unattainable as her own, reinforcing their shared exile.
Character traits
Perceptive Empathetic Conflict-Averse Loyal Curious Compassionate
Follow Susan Foreman's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
TARDIS (Time and Relative Dimension in Space)

The TARDIS is referenced indirectly through Susan’s dialogue about her home being 'as far away as a night star' and her confirmation that she can never return if Marco Polo gifts it to Kublai Khan. The TARDIS symbolizes home, freedom, and the possibility of escape for Susan and the Doctor’s group. Its absence in the scene is palpable, as the conversation revolves around the consequences of its potential loss. The TARDIS functions as a MacGuffin whose fate hinges on the recovery of the key, and its symbolic significance as a vessel of return is central to the emotional weight of the exchange.

Before: Hidden in the stables of the Cheng-Ting way …
After: Remains hidden, but its potential gifting to Kublai …
Before: Hidden in the stables of the Cheng-Ting way station, under Marco Polo’s orders to shield it from bandits and Wang-Lo’s carelessness. Its location is known to the group but inaccessible without the key.
After: Remains hidden, but its potential gifting to Kublai Khan looms as an imminent threat. The TARDIS’s symbolic role as a means of escape and a connection to home is reinforced, making its recovery a critical narrative goal.
TARDIS Access Key (Marco Polo's Journal)

The goldfish in the pond serve as a symbolic prop and narrative device, used by Susan and Ping-Cho to metaphorically compare the personalities of their caravan companions. The goldfish create a lighthearted yet revealing moment, where Susan’s observations about Wang-Lo’s smoothness, Marco Polo’s solemnity, Ian’s energy, and Barbara’s independence reflect her keen insight into the group dynamics. The moment shifts when Ping-Cho identifies Susan as the 'wicked goldfish,' a label that exposes Susan’s self-awareness of her outsider status. The goldfish also symbolize the fragility and isolation of the characters, mirroring their emotional states and the unspoken tensions within the caravan.

Before: Swimming freely in the pond, observed by Susan …
After: The goldfish remain in the pond, but their …
Before: Swimming freely in the pond, observed by Susan and Ping-Cho. Their behavior and appearances serve as a catalyst for the metaphorical comparisons and the deeper conversation that follows.
After: The goldfish remain in the pond, but their symbolic role as a mirror for the characters’ personalities and emotions is solidified. The 'wicked goldfish' label lingers, adding to the subtext of Susan’s outsider status and the group’s dynamic.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Cheng-Ting Way Station Courtyard

The Cheng-Ting way station courtyard serves as a neutral ground for Susan and Ping-Cho’s intimate conversation, providing a quiet and reflective space away from the chaos of the caravan. The pond in the courtyard becomes a focal point, symbolizing both the transient beauty of their moment and the deeper emotional currents beneath the surface. The courtyard’s open yet secluded atmosphere allows for vulnerability and honesty, as the characters share their longing for home and their fears about the future. The location’s role as a liminal space—neither fully part of the caravan’s hustle nor entirely separate—mirrors the characters’ own in-between status as exiles and travelers.

Atmosphere Tranquil yet emotionally charged, with a sense of quiet introspection. The pond’s stillness contrasts with …
Function A sanctuary for private reflection and emotional connection, offering a respite from the caravan’s pressures …
Symbolism Represents the fragility and isolation of the characters’ emotional states, as well as the transient …
Access Open to anyone in the way station, but the moment’s intimacy suggests it is effectively …
A pond with goldfish, including one with a 'wedding veil' (symbolizing fragility or fate). The sound of water and the distant hum of caravan activity, creating a sense of separation from the larger world.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1

"Polo hiding the keys in his journal, extracting a promise from Ping-Cho reinforces Ping-Cho's internal conflict."

Marco hides TARDIS keys from Ping-Cho
S1E18 · Rider From Shang-Tu
What this causes 2

"Susan revealing the impossibility of her return motivates Ping-Cho to act, culminating in her giving the key to Susan out of compassion."

Tegana witnesses betrayals and surveillance
S1E18 · Rider From Shang-Tu

"Susan revealing the impossibility of her return motivates Ping-Cho to act, culminating in her giving the key to Susan out of compassion."

Susan’s farewell complicates the escape
S1E18 · Rider From Shang-Tu

Themes This Exemplifies

Thematic resonance and meaning

Key Dialogue

"PING-CHO: There's you, Susan. A wicked goldfish."
"SUSAN: Oh, look there. That little pretty one down there, with the wedding veil. Oh, Ping-Cho, I'm sorry."
"PING-CHO: How I miss my home in Samarkand. And your home, Susan? You've never told me about that. Is it so very far away?"
"SUSAN: Yes, it is. It's as far away as a night star."
"PING-CHO: And if Messer Marco does give your caravan to Kublai Khan, you will never see your home again?"
"SUSAN: That's right."
"PING-CHO: I gave him my word, Susan. I promised not to tell anyone where he put the key."
"SUSAN: And I promise you that no-one will ask you."