The Police Box Hides Susan’s Truth
Plot Beats
The narrative micro-steps within this event
Ian and Barbara, searching the junkyard, express frustration at their inability to find Susan, but Barbara calls Ian's attention to the police box, which is emitting a faint vibration.
While contemplating the mysterious police box, Ian and Barbara overhear a cough, and they hide as an old man, who is revealed to be Susan's grandfather, approaches the police box, with Susan calling out to him from inside.
Who Was There
Characters present in this moment
Deeply concerned for Susan’s well-being, with a growing sense of urgency that overrides her initial hesitation. Her defiance of the Doctor is rooted in a moral conviction to act, even in the face of the unknown.
Barbara takes the lead in investigating the police box, her initial curiosity turning into defiance as the Doctor denies Susan’s presence. She listens intently to Susan’s voice from inside the box, her concern for Susan’s safety overriding her caution. When the Doctor refuses to open the door, she makes the bold decision to enter the box herself, despite his protests. Her physical presence is assertive and unyielding, her voice firm with conviction, and her actions driven by a sense of duty to her student. Barbara’s entrance into the box marks the moment when their investigation crosses into the unknown, and she becomes the first to confront the impossible.
- • To confirm Susan’s safety and ensure she is not being harmed by the Doctor.
- • To challenge the Doctor’s authority and expose the truth, even if it means entering the police box against his wishes.
- • The Doctor is lying about Susan’s presence and has something to hide.
- • She and Ian have a responsibility to intervene, regardless of the personal risk or the Doctor’s hostility.
Unclear, but her tone suggests a sense of normalcy or familiarity with the situation, possibly indicating she is unaware of the external conflict or is accustomed to the Doctor’s protective behavior.
Susan’s physical presence is absent from the scene, but her voice calls out twice from inside the police box, confirming her location and her familiarity with the Doctor. Her tone is calm and unconcerned, suggesting she is unaware of the tension outside or is accustomed to such confrontations. Her voice serves as the catalyst for Barbara’s decision to enter the box, providing the final proof that the teachers’ suspicions are correct. Susan’s role in the event is passive but pivotal, as her presence inside the box is the driving force behind Ian and Barbara’s actions.
- • To communicate with the Doctor, unaware of the external confrontation.
- • To remain hidden inside the police box, as implied by the Doctor’s protective actions.
- • The Doctor is her protector and will handle any external threats.
- • Her presence inside the police box is safe and unremarkable, as suggested by her calm demeanor.
Righteously indignant and increasingly frustrated, masking a deeper concern for Susan’s safety that fuels his defiance of the Doctor’s authority.
Ian emerges from hiding as the Doctor arrives, his frustration and suspicion now fully directed at the old man. He confronts the Doctor aggressively, demanding to know why Susan is inside the police box and accusing him of hiding her. His actions escalate from curiosity to confrontation, culminating in his struggle with the Doctor as Barbara enters the box. Ian’s physical presence is tense and combative, his voice sharp with accusation, and his body language reflects his growing determination to uncover the truth, even at the risk of physical conflict.
- • To confirm Susan’s presence inside the police box and ensure her safety.
- • To challenge the Doctor’s evasiveness and expose his lies, regardless of the personal risk.
- • The Doctor is hiding Susan and knows more than he is letting on.
- • Barbara and he have a moral obligation to protect Susan, even if it means defying the Doctor’s authority.
Defensively hostile, with a underlying sense of urgency to maintain control and protect Susan’s secrecy. His irritation masks a deeper fear of exposure, driving his aggressive responses to Ian and Barbara’s interference.
The Doctor arrives at the junkyard and immediately takes a defensive stance, inserting a key into the police box’s lock while denying Susan’s presence inside. His demeanor is hostile and evasive, his voice sharp with irritation as he deflects Ian and Barbara’s questions. He feigns interest in a nearby picture frame to distract them, but his focus remains on the police box, which he guards protectively. His physical presence is imposing, his body language tense and defensive, and his actions are calculated to maintain control over the situation. When Barbara enters the box, he reacts with alarm, his hostility escalating into a physical struggle with Ian.
- • To prevent Ian and Barbara from discovering the truth about Susan and the police box.
- • To maintain control over the situation and protect Susan’s hidden identity, even if it means lying or using physical force.
- • Ian and Barbara are a threat to Susan’s safety and the secrecy of their existence.
- • The police box and its contents must be protected at all costs, regardless of the consequences.
Not applicable (off-screen), but his potential involvement is framed as a last resort for Ian and Barbara, and a deterrent for the Doctor.
The Policeman is mentioned but does not appear in the scene. Ian and Barbara threaten to involve him as a means of pressuring the Doctor, but his presence is purely hypothetical. The mention of the Policeman serves as a narrative threat, implying that the Doctor’s secrecy could be exposed if the teachers follow through on their threat. His role in the event is indirect but significant, as it influences the Doctor’s defiance and Ian and Barbara’s determination to act without external intervention.
- • To serve as a potential authority figure to resolve the conflict, should Ian and Barbara follow through on their threat.
- • To represent the external world’s order and rules, which the Doctor is attempting to evade.
- • The Policeman’s involvement would force the Doctor to comply with Ian and Barbara’s demands.
- • The Policeman’s authority could expose the Doctor’s secrets, making him a powerful leverage point.
Objects Involved
Significant items in this scene
The Doctor’s key is a critical tool in the event, symbolizing his authority over the police box and his control over Susan’s secrecy. He uses it to insert into the box’s lock, a gesture that underscores his protective role and his determination to keep Ian and Barbara out. The key’s presence and use are direct challenges to the teachers’ demands, reinforcing the Doctor’s defiance and the box’s role as a guarded threshold. While the key itself is not the focus of the event, its function is pivotal in maintaining the tension and highlighting the Doctor’s power dynamic over the situation.
Ian’s small torch is a tool that fails him during the event, symbolizing the limitations of their ordinary methods in uncovering the extraordinary. When Ian drops it after tripping over the bucket, the loss of light forces the teachers to rely on their instincts and the faint ambient glow of the junkyard. The torch’s failure is a narrative device that heightens the tension and underscores the inadequacy of their conventional approach to the mystery. Its absence leaves them more vulnerable and reliant on other senses, such as hearing Susan’s voice from the police box.
The junkyard bucket is a minor but functionally significant object in the event, serving as an obstacle that disrupts Ian’s search. When Ian trips over it, he drops his torch, plunging the area into deeper darkness and amplifying the tension of the scene. The bucket’s presence contributes to the junkyard’s cluttered and treacherous atmosphere, symbolizing the physical and emotional barriers Ian and Barbara must overcome to reach the truth. While its role is brief, it underscores the challenges of their investigation and the urgency of their mission.
The ornate picture frame is a red herring in the event, used by the Doctor to distract Ian and Barbara from the police box. He feigns interest in it, declaring it damp and dirty, in an attempt to shift their focus away from the humming box and Susan’s voice. The frame’s elaborate but neglected state contrasts with the box’s eerie vibration, highlighting the Doctor’s desperation to misdirect the teachers. While the frame itself is irrelevant to the mystery, its use underscores the Doctor’s evasiveness and the lengths to which he will go to protect his secrets.
The police box is the central object of the event, serving as both a physical barrier and a portal to the unknown. Its unnatural vibration immediately sets it apart from the junkyard’s debris, drawing Ian and Barbara’s attention and suspicion. The Doctor interacts with it directly, inserting a key into its lock and guarding it protectively, which reinforces its significance as a hiding place for Susan. The box’s lack of a visible door handle and its eerie hum create an atmosphere of mystery, while Susan’s voice emanating from inside confirms its role as a threshold to the impossible. Barbara’s decision to enter the box marks the moment when the object’s true nature is revealed, shifting the event from a confrontation to a crossing into the unknown.
Location Details
Places and their significance in this event
The junkyard serves as the primary setting for the event, a cluttered and treacherous landscape that mirrors the emotional and intellectual obstacles Ian and Barbara face. Its twisted metal heaps and discarded debris create a labyrinthine atmosphere, where every step is fraught with potential danger—both physical, as seen when Ian trips over the bucket, and metaphorical, as the teachers navigate the Doctor’s lies and the police box’s mysteries. The junkyard’s foggy, isolated environment amplifies the tension, casting an eerie stillness over the scene that masks the hidden anomalies within it. The location’s role is pivotal, as it is here that the ordinary world of Coal Hill School collides with the extraordinary, setting the stage for the teachers’ journey into the unknown.
The interior of the police box is the climactic location of the event, serving as the threshold between the ordinary junkyard and the unknown. While its exterior is unassuming, its interior is revealed to be a hidden space where Susan’s voice emanates, confirming her presence and the box’s true nature as a portal or hiding place. Barbara’s decision to enter the box marks the moment when the event shifts from confrontation to revelation, as she crosses into the unknown. The box’s interior is not fully described, but its role as a mystery hub is underscored by Susan’s voice and the Doctor’s protective stance. The location’s significance lies in its function as a gateway, symbolizing the teachers’ transition from a mundane investigation to an extraordinary journey.
Organizations Involved
Institutional presence and influence
Coal Hill School is the institutional backdrop to the event, serving as the source of Ian and Barbara’s authority and concern for Susan. Their roles as teachers at the school provide the moral and professional justification for their investigation into Susan’s disappearance. The school’s influence is felt in their assertive questioning of the Doctor, their threat to involve the policeman, and their unwavering commitment to protecting Susan. While the school itself is not physically present in the junkyard, its presence is implied through Ian and Barbara’s actions and dialogue, grounding their investigation in a sense of duty and responsibility. The organization’s values—protection, education, and accountability—drive their confrontation with the Doctor and their decision to enter the police box.
Narrative Connections
How this event relates to others in the story
"Barbara recounts visiting the junkyard at Totter's Lane. Later, they return to the junkyard and find the police box, fulfilling the earlier description."
Barbara convinces Ian to investigate"The inability to find Susan leads Ian and Barbara to focus on the police box, and they get startled by the arrival of the Doctor, and Susan's voice speaking to him within the box."
The Doctor’s Lies Collapse Under Susan’s Voice"Ian and Barbara decide to investigate Susan and stakeout at the junkyard. Later, they enter the police box, finally acting on their decision to investigate."
Barbara convinces Ian to investigate"Spotting Susan entering the scrap yard leads Ian and Barbara to move into the scrap yard where they continue seeking Susan."
Teachers Follow Susan into the Scrapyard"The Doctor feigns ignorance, and deflects questions, prompting Ian and Barbara to threaten to involve the police."
The Doctor’s Lies Collapse Under Susan’s Voice"Susan senses something is wrong with the book. Foreshadows her connection to something beyond normal reality."
Susan reacts to the book’s unsettling presence"Susan senses something is wrong with the book. Foreshadows her connection to something beyond normal reality."
Susan’s cryptic evasion exposes deeper secrets"The inability to find Susan leads Ian and Barbara to focus on the police box, and they get startled by the arrival of the Doctor, and Susan's voice speaking to him within the box."
The Doctor’s Lies Collapse Under Susan’s Voice"The Doctor feigns ignorance, and deflects questions, prompting Ian and Barbara to threaten to involve the police."
The Doctor’s Lies Collapse Under Susan’s VoiceThemes This Exemplifies
Thematic resonance and meaning
Part of Larger Arcs
Key Dialogue
"IAN: It's alive! It's not connected to anything, unless it's through the floor."
"DOCTOR: Young man, is it reasonable to suppose that anybody would be inside a cupboard like that, hmm?"
"SUSAN [OC]: What are you doing out there?"
"IAN: She is in there!"