Hawthorne and Benton share a fragile moment

In the aftermath of Yates’ impulsive departure to chase Jo into the cavern, Hawthorne and Benton are left alone in the Cloven Hoof bar, both visibly shaken by the escalating chaos. Hawthorne, ever the composed local figure, offers Benton a drink—a small but deliberate gesture of solidarity that acknowledges their shared vulnerability. Benton, still recovering from his earlier confrontation with the Master’s cult, accepts with quiet gratitude, revealing a moment of human connection amid the unfolding crisis. Their brief exchange underscores the fragility of their alliance: Hawthorne’s offer is both a practical comfort and a tacit recognition of Benton’s resilience, while Benton’s acceptance signals his trust in her, despite their differing roles in the unfolding conflict. This quiet interlude contrasts sharply with the surrounding tension, hinting at a potential shift in their dynamic—one that could either strengthen their resistance or expose deeper fractures as the Master’s influence tightens its grip on the village.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Hawthorne checks on Benton's well-being after an unseen event, and both admit to being shaken.

anxiety to concern

Hawthorne offers Benton a drink, signaling shared anxiety and gratitude amid the chaos.

tension to camaraderie

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

Shaken but composed; her vulnerability is tempered by a steadfast resolve to maintain stability amid chaos.

Hawthorne stands in the Cloven Hoof bar, her usual composed demeanor slightly frayed as she checks on Benton’s well-being. She pours two stiff drinks, one for herself and one for Benton, her hands steady despite the tension in the air. Her dialogue is minimal but deliberate, admitting to being shaken—a rare moment of vulnerability for the village’s white witch. She engages in a quiet, vulnerable exchange with Benton, her offer of a drink serving as both a practical comfort and a symbolic gesture of solidarity.

Goals in this moment
  • To offer Benton emotional and practical support in a moment of shared crisis.
  • To acknowledge her own fear and humanize herself in front of Benton, fostering trust.
Active beliefs
  • That shared humanity can bridge the gap between her role as the village’s white witch and Benton’s role as a UNIT soldier.
  • That even in moments of extreme danger, small acts of kindness can strengthen alliances.
Character traits
Compassionate Vulnerable (uncharacteristically) Practical Diplomatic Observant
Follow Jo Grant's journey
Mike Yates
primary

Recovering but wary; his gratitude and acceptance of Hawthorne’s gesture reveal a moment of trust and shared humanity amid the chaos.

Benton, still recovering from his earlier confrontation with the Master’s cult, stands in the Cloven Hoof bar, his posture reflecting a mix of wariness and exhaustion. He responds to Hawthorne’s concern with a measured tone, reciprocating her inquiry about his well-being. When Hawthorne pours him a drink, he accepts with quiet gratitude, his acceptance signaling trust in her and a momentary lowering of his guard. His dialogue is sparse but meaningful, reflecting his resilience and the unspoken bond forming between them.

Goals in this moment
  • To maintain his composure and professionalism despite the escalating crisis.
  • To acknowledge Hawthorne’s gesture of solidarity, reinforcing their alliance.
Active beliefs
  • That Hawthorne’s offer of a drink is a genuine gesture of support, not just a social nicety.
  • That their shared vulnerability in this moment can strengthen their ability to face the Master’s threat together.
Character traits
Resilient Wary but trusting Grateful Composed under pressure Loyal
Follow Mike Yates's journey
Benton

Sergeant Benton is briefly mentioned in Yates’ dialogue as he departs, with Yates cautioning Benton not to ‘cop it like …

The Third Doctor

The Third Doctor is not physically present in this event but is referenced indirectly through Yates’ departure to pursue Jo …

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Cloven Hoof Guest Room Front Window

The two stiff drinks poured by Hawthorne serve as a symbolic and practical gift, representing a moment of human connection amid the crisis. They function as a tangible gesture of solidarity, offering both comfort and a brief respite from the tension. Benton’s acceptance of the drink signifies trust and mutual reliance, while the act of pouring underscores Hawthorne’s role as a caretaker in the village. The drinks are consumed in silence, their presence amplifying the weight of the unspoken fears and the fragility of the alliance forming between Hawthorne and Benton.

Before: Available in the Cloven Hoof bar, part of …
After: Consumed by Hawthorne and Benton, symbolizing the momentary …
Before: Available in the Cloven Hoof bar, part of the establishment’s inventory.
After: Consumed by Hawthorne and Benton, symbolizing the momentary bond formed between them.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
The Cloven Hoof Bar

The Cloven Hoof bar serves as a fragile sanctuary in this moment, a neutral ground where Hawthorne and Benton can briefly lower their guards amid the escalating crisis. The bar’s warm, dimly lit atmosphere contrasts sharply with the chaos outside, creating a pocket of relative safety. The wooden counters and tables, usually bustling with village life, now host a tense but intimate exchange between Hawthorne and Benton. The bar’s role here is multifaceted: it is a place of refuge, a site for the formation of alliances, and a reminder of the normalcy that the Master’s influence threatens to erase.

Atmosphere Tension-filled yet intimate, with a warm glow from the pub lamps casting long shadows that …
Function Neutral ground for human connection and temporary refuge amid chaos; a place where alliances can …
Symbolism Represents the last bastion of normalcy and shared humanity in a village increasingly gripped by …
Access Open to those present (Hawthorne, Benton, Yates), but the crisis outside makes it feel like …
Warm glow from pub lamps casting long shadows. Wooden counters and tables, usually bustling but now quiet. The clinking of glasses as Hawthorne pours the drinks. The hum of distant tension, a reminder of the chaos outside.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

1
UNIT

UNIT’s influence is felt indirectly in this event through the presence of Benton and Yates, both of whom are UNIT personnel. Yates’ departure to pursue Jo into the cavern reflects UNIT’s proactive approach to crisis management, even as it strains the organization’s resources and testing its protocols. Benton’s role as a recipient of Hawthorne’s gesture highlights the human element of UNIT’s operations, where trust and alliances with local figures like Hawthorne become critical to mission success. The organization’s goals are implied in Yates’ instructions to inform the Doctor of Jo’s departure, underscoring UNIT’s reliance on the Doctor’s expertise to counter the Master’s threat.

Representation Via the actions and dialogue of its members (Benton and Yates), reflecting UNIT’s institutional protocols …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority through its personnel (Yates’ departure to pursue Jo) but operating under constraint due …
Impact The event highlights UNIT’s reliance on both its own personnel and external alliances to navigate …
Internal Dynamics The tension between Yates’ impulsive departure and Benton’s cautious demeanor reflects internal dynamics within UNIT, …
To maintain communication and coordination among its personnel (e.g., Yates instructing Benton to inform the Doctor). To leverage local alliances (e.g., Hawthorne’s support) to counter the Master’s influence and protect the village. Through the actions of its personnel (Yates’ pursuit of Jo, Benton’s role as a liaison). By fostering trust and cooperation with local figures (Hawthorne’s gesture of solidarity with Benton).

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 1

"Yates and Jo decide to head out on their own, putting themselves at risk. This echoes the Brigadier's worry about the Doctor who also faces difficult circumstance by being cutoff from the group."

Brigadier and Benton Discuss Doctor’s Absence
S8E24 · The Daemons Part 4

Key Dialogue

"HAWTHORNE: You all right?"
"BENTON: More or less. How about you?"
"HAWTHORNE: Shaken, I'll admit."
"BENTON: Thank you."